BronyCon Draws 4,000 to NJ To Celebrate Everything My Little Pony

Status
Not open for further replies.

Esch

Banned
ie62tjkOl2Awo.gif
 

tiff

Banned
If Amirox has watched and strongly disliked MLP, I don't see too much wrong with him not trusting the tastes of people who do enjoy it. If someone enjoys things that don't appeal to you at all, it seems only natural to look elsewhere for recommendations.

this is reasonable if there's a pattern of disagreement but disregarding someone's opinion because of one example is hilariously short-sighted and narrow.

like if I'm talking to some guy who likes all the same strategy games as me and he recommends I check out the newest Paradox game I'm not going to blow him off because he liked Uncharted 2 because that's ridiculously stupid.
 

Amir0x

Banned
this is reasonable if there's a pattern of disagreement but disregarding someone's opinion because of one example is hilariously short-sighted and narrow.

like if I'm talking to some guy who likes all the same strategy games as me and he recommends I check out the newest Paradox game I'm not going to blow him off because he liked Uncharted 2 because that's ridiculously stupid.

i think that's a bit of a distortion.

i don't just disregard someone's opinion if they like something I don't like. There are tons of people who like things I don't like who have opinions I trust very much on neoGAF.

It's just that there are certain key things that I consider SO offensive, so genuinely, unforgivably shitty that if someone found it in their tastes to accommodate those things, I find it difficult to be able to trust the opinions they'd share with me later. There'd always be a hint of doubt in the back of my mind.

There are very, very few things I consider in those categories. In Gaming, I only have three games that fit that description. In animation, there are only two. In movies, there are about five. In books, there are about five.

It's sufficiently specific that most people don't even have to be concerned with such a thing. For me, it's just an easy quick trigger.
 

G-Fex

Member
Ok then? I'm not sure where to go from there: the truth is in the post, you either accept it or you don't. Moving on to more pressing matters...



I didn't say I hate a convention. Point to a post where I said I hate a convention. Reading comprehension is important dude.

I said I did not want to be around smelly nerds with poor hygiene. It's true. But I always said I wanted to attend conventions, I just didn't want to have to suffer that part of it. I eventually was convinced that there was enough worth it at the convention I was interested in to suffer that aspect of it.

Did that aspect go away? No. It was there exactly as I feared. Did I still enjoy myself? Sure..

How do I know you're not in denial dude? How do I know you're not embracing the 'Fanboy nerd'?

How do I know you're not attending these things with a 'Anime Pro' shirt on and you're just denying it. I'm not saying this just to single you out cause nobody wants to make themselves look bad on the internets. But somehow I don't think I'm getting the whole story Amir0x.

Don't be a Bully, Be a STAR!
 

Razek

Banned
I'm sorry.



Twilight Sparkle at least gets much better in Season 2.

Come to think of it season 2 makes all the mediocre ponies decent and nerfs all the good ponies from the first season. Odd how that works out.

Welcome to my ignore list.
 

TheSeks

Blinded by the luminous glory that is David Bowie's physical manifestation.
OMG FUCK YOU OP. @ OP Picture. What has been seen can't be unseen. D:

I have no problem with the My Little Pony fans so long as they don't shove their fandom down my throat.
 
this is reasonable if there's a pattern of disagreement but disregarding someone's opinion because of one example is hilariously short-sighted and narrow.

like if I'm talking to some guy who likes all the same strategy games as me and he recommends I check out the newest Paradox game I'm not going to blow him off because he liked Uncharted 2 because that's ridiculously stupid.
I suppose it does depend on how much you have in common with the person's tastes to begin with, but as he said, GAF has an endless sea of opinions. You can afford to be a bit picky.
 

Amir0x

Banned
How do I know you're not in denial dude? How do I know you're not embracing the 'Fanboy nerd'?

How do I know you're not attending these things with a 'Anime Pro' shirt on and you're just denying it. I'm not saying this just to single you out cause nobody wants to make themselves look bad on the internets. But somehow I don't think I'm getting the whole story Amir0x.

Don't be a Bully, Be a STAR!

i have to say one thing I am pround about in my nerddom is that i own absolutely no clothes that feature anything relating to nerd culture, or internet memes, or ironic hot topic shit!
 
Let me run the list of animated shows I like past you to make sure it's acceptable: MLP, Adventure Time, Avengers: EMH, Archer, Wakfu, Futurama, Gravity Falls, AtlA, and Korra, just off the top of my head.
I recently tried watching a few of these after not having watched cartoons for like 5 years. Thought I might give them a chance. Needless to say, most of these are indeed directed at 7-12 year olds. Futurama obviously not, but they were really boring to me.
 

Acerac

Banned
Welcome to my ignore list.

In S2 Twilight is the best pony. It's just that in season 1 she was Applejack tier in every episode not about a sleepover.


I recently tried watching a few of these after not having watched cartoons for like 5 years. Thought I might give them a chance. Needless to say, most of these are indeed directed at 7-12 year olds. Futurama obviously not, but they were really boring to me.
You should check out Avatar:TLA again. Starts out slow (and yes, rather childish) but by the time season 2 hits it is one of the better shows out there, animated or not. The character arcs and storytelling are really well done.
 

G-Fex

Member
i have to say one thing I am pround about in my nerddom is that i own absolutely no clothes that feature anything relating to nerd culture, or internet memes, or ironic hot topic shit!

Ah okay, I assume we can rule out cosplay too?
 

jerry1594

Member
i think that's a bit of a distortion.

i don't just disregard someone's opinion if they like something I don't like. There are tons of people who like things I don't like who have opinions I trust very much on neoGAF.

It's just that there are certain key things that I consider SO offensive, so genuinely, unforgivably shitty that if someone found it in their tastes to accommodate those things, I find it difficult to be able to trust the opinions they'd share with me later. There'd always be a hint of doubt in the back of my mind.

There are very, very few things I consider in those categories. In Gaming, I only have three games that fit that description. In animation, there are only two. In movies, there are about five. In books, there are about five.

It's sufficiently specific that most people don't even have to be concerned with such a thing. For me, it's just an easy quick trigger.

Care to share the names of these abominable pieces of media?
 

Amir0x

Banned
Ah okay, I assume we can rule out cosplay too?

Not yet, although my sisters are trying to convince me this year to go as Bolin, since they're going as Korra and Asami respectively. I just... can't bring myself to do it man. I don't find that enjoyable! I only do things I can love man

I'm wearing a Dig Dug t-shirt :/

I just don't do it! But Dig Dug is cool, the retro shit is starting to get genuinely popular these days as clothing

Pizarro said:
Care to share the names of these abominable pieces of media?

i'll give you a primer

Games ->

1. Animal Crossing
2. Heavy Rain

Movies ->

1. Pluto Nash
2. Sucker Punch

Books ->

1. Sword of Truth
2. Twilight

Animation ->

1. My Little Pony
2. Lucky Star
 

G-Fex

Member
Ami how much do you weigh, out of curiousity?

Not yet, although my sisters are trying to convince me this year to go as Bolin, since they're going as Korra and Asami respectively. I just... can't bring myself to do it man. I don't find that enjoyable! I only do things I can love man



I just don't do it! But Dig Dug is cool, the retro shit is starting to get genuinely popular these days as clothing

Aw i'm sure you'd be adorable Bolin. (whatever that is)

Go for it tiger.
 

Acerac

Banned
Not yet, although my sisters are trying to convince me this year to go as Bolin, since they're going as Korra and Asami respectively. I just... can't bring myself to do it man. I don't find that enjoyable! I only do things I can love man

Rock a Noatok mask, nobody will know!

Yeah I wouldn't do it either
 

Amir0x

Banned
Ami how much do you weigh, out of curiousity?

Used to be 280lbs. Now I weight 165lbs. Started losing weight around two years ago, because I wanted to be able to look good in a tux when I finally walk down the aisle with my fiancee, and now I'm here. Feels good man.

I was the prototype socially maladjusted loser from 2002~2008. In high school I was fine, was popular enough, was on fitness club, baseball team.. then my high school sweetheart killed herself. Gained a huge amount of weight in two years til i ballooned to that crazy weight. Became something of a recluse, lost my job. Had huge anxiety in crowds and in social situations. Adapted to geek culture because I needed to escape.

Now I'm back to the way I was, only I took the geek with me. I always enjoyed games, don't get me wrong, but it was never a central fixation and hobby until those years.

Aw i'm sure you'd be adorable Bolin. (whatever that is)

Go for it tiger.

I said I'd contemplate going as Amon if they could find a way to make a rad mask like that
 

Amir0x

Banned
The original My Little Pony? Also there are far, far worse anime than Lucky Star.

New My Little Pony. never really caught the old one at all

While I am sure there are worse anime than Lucky Star, I fortunately stop myself from watching anything whose cover screens "THIS IS GOING TO BE WORSE THAN LUCKY STAR"

It's just what I think Lucky Star says about the individual who can stomach it is more than enough for me to know what I need to know about that individual on the subject of animation
 

jerry1594

Member
Not yet, although my sisters are trying to convince me this year to go as Bolin, since they're going as Korra and Asami respectively. I just... can't bring myself to do it man. I don't find that enjoyable! I only do things I can love man



I just don't do it! But Dig Dug is cool, the retro shit is starting to get genuinely popular these days as clothing



i'll give you a primer

Games ->

1. Animal Crossing
2. Heavy Rain

Movies ->

1. Pluto Nash
2. Sucker Punch

Books ->

1. Sword of Truth
2. Twilight

Animation ->

1. My Little Pony
2. Lucky Star

Eh. Not sure I'd mentally blacklist people for any of these.
 

Amir0x

Banned
Eh. Not sure I'd mentally blacklist people for any of these.

right, but that's why my mental blacklist is my own. hypothetically if you felt so passionately about something being shitty that you would make a mental blacklist, it probably would be unique from mine
 

Amir0x

Banned
man i don't want to know what an anime worse than Lucky Star looks like

but i am so morbidly curious...

edit: eh, I don't consider ecchi the same as regular animated stuff in the category. of course hentai and ecchi are going to be worse
 

FStop7

Banned
I just don't get the hate. In every type of pop culture fandom there are people who take things too far. You take the extreme examples and hold them up as the norm... why? To feel better about yourself?
 
I just don't get the hate. In every type of pop culture fandom there are people who take things too far. You take the extreme examples and hold them up as the norm... why? To feel better about yourself?

.

The worst of the Brony community should be viewed with the same disdain as the most Hardcore football superfan. The same guy that dresses up as a Pony would also be painting his face the team colors in a different fandom.
 

G-Fex

Member
I just don't get the hate. In every type of pop culture fandom there are people who take things too far. You take the extreme examples and hold them up as the norm... why? To feel better about yourself?

I think the anime pillows thing is the worst but that's just me.
 

Laughing Banana

Weeping Pickle
I just don't get the hate. In every type of pop culture fandom there are people who take things too far. You take the extreme examples and hold them up as the norm... why? To feel better about yourself?

What else?

Self-justify, self-gratification, "You have to admit I'm better to you" shtick is popular reasoning for this sort of--rather pathetic in itself, actually--behavior.
 

Acerac

Banned
who wears Brony shirts in public?

I own 2, though you wouldn't know what they were unless you followed the series.

People who know the series seem to love them though. I've gotten bunches of compliments.

I don't understand the appeal of my Little Pony, I watched the first few episodes on Netflix and it was designed for a 6 year old girl to understand. My little sister(said 6 year old girl) loved it though. What exactly seperates MLP from the rest of the kids shows?

It's a cute show that has lighthearted humor, something rare in comedies these days. It's not for everyone, but the creator went out of her way to make it more universal than one might expect.
 

DR2K

Banned
I don't understand the appeal of my Little Pony, I watched the first few episodes on Netflix and it was designed for a 6 year old girl to understand. My little sister(said 6 year old girl) loved it though. What exactly seperates MLP from the rest of the kids shows?
 

FStop7

Banned
I don't understand the appeal of my Little Pony, I watched the first few episodes on Netflix and it was designed for a 6 year old girl to understand. My little sister(said 6 year old girl) loved it though. What exactly seperates MLP from the rest of the kids shows?

I don't get it, either. When it first blew up as such a phenomena I ragged on it and on bronies until it hit me that it was a dumb thing to do. I watched a few episodes and what I saw was a pretty clever and well animated show that taught a bunch of sugary and cliche' lessons aimed at 6 year olds. But I don't see any reason to be antagonistic toward the fans, except the ones who sexualize it - because what the fuck.
 

Cheerilee

Member
who wears Brony shirts in public?
People who don't give a shit, people who really want to not give a shit, people who are trying to be ironic (these guys aren't popular with the fanbase). Lots of people.

Most bronies who just want to be recognized by other bronies wear subtle things that only other fans would really recognize.

I don't understand the appeal of my Little Pony, I watched the first few episodes on Netflix and it was designed for a 6 year old girl to understand. My little sister(said 6 year old girl) loved it though. What exactly seperates MLP from the rest of the kids shows?
A: It's good.

B: There are people who would pay good money for the answer to B.
 

jph139

Member
I don't understand the appeal of my Little Pony, I watched the first few episodes on Netflix and it was designed for a 6 year old girl to understand. My little sister(said 6 year old girl) loved it though. What exactly seperates MLP from the rest of the kids shows?

Eh, some people just like kids shows. The only reason there are Bronies at all is because everyone gets so riled up about it. You don't see the same sort of hardcore internet communities forming around other kids shows with adult appeal (Adventure Time being a big example) even though people do discuss and enjoy them.

They feed on internet hatred and cute fluff.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom