The facebook numbers...WHAT DO THEY MEAN?! WHAT DO THEY MEAN

Status
Not open for further replies.
Came to post this. Get real-time updates of who's keeping track of you.



Perfect for instances like that. You see when that someone special is looking at your profile, and just send them a message saying "How you doin'?"
If the list is really about who is stalking you (which I doubt), hell no to real time tracking updates. I don't want anyone to know who's profile I'm looking at.
 
Just curious has anyone tried it long enough to see if the list changes? ie: the order of the ranks?

Because that may help to know more about what its really doing.

As in if you're best friend is the top "stalker" now but tomorrow he's like number 5 then, the thing is more dynamic and works different than "most frequent visitor" of your profile.

EDIT: beaten... kinda
 
If OP said it was on reddit then it's already been spread around. Besides, that's how we're discussing it in the first place. It's not like it's our dirty little secret or anything.

But no, I probably won't do that.

EDIT: Here's the Reddit thread, along with their takes on it.

"This list is NOT the list of people viewing your profile the most. This is just an array of user ID that is used when you start to type stuff into the search box. Facebook pre-loads the data so that your search results appear instantly. So these user IDs are simply the people/games/groups/etc that YOU most likely to search for.
There are a number of applications, groups, and games are in my list - are they really stalking me? Of course not.
"

This makes the most sense from that script^

It makes no sense why Facebook would store anything related to page views.


EDIT: Yep i'm pretty sure its this. Put a single letter in the search bar and you will see those top people pop up.
EDIT2: This is a pretty interesting algorithm.
 
Couldn't a group of people test this?

One would create a dummy account, then have ~10 people visit the page a certain number of times.
The top person would visit the most, the last person would visit the least.
 
Just curious has anyone tried it long enough to see if the list changes? ie: the order of the ranks?

Because that may help to know more about what its really doing.

As in if you're best friend is the top "stalker" now but tomorrow he's like number 5 then, the thing is more dynamic and works different than "most frequent visitor" of your profile.

EDIT: beaten... kinda

It changes.
 
"So these user IDs are simply the people/games/groups/etc that YOU most likely to search for."

This makes the most sense from that script^

Nope. Why would my top #3 likely searched/page view would be for 3 married/engaged people that I rarely talk to online or IRL? I'm not a homewrecker, FB!
 
Nope. Why would my top #3 likely searched/page view would be for 3 married/engaged people that I rarely talk to online or IRL? I'm not a homewrecker, FB!

Try putting a single random letter of that #3 into the search bar. Lemme know if that person pops up? Seems like an neat algorithm..maybe you two share a lot of mutual friends or likes of posts/movies/music/etc?
 
Facebook knows exactly how catastrophic that kind of data breach would be. This is the search cache, the algorithm will spit out weird results in some cases but this absolutely is not what the image in the OP purports it to be.
 
The top 3 in my list are my closest friends and they show up first in the search bar.

Couldn't a group of people test this?

One would create a dummy account, then have ~10 people visit the page a certain number of times.
The top person would visit the most, the last person would visit the least.

This is a good idea. Someone should do this. Or even try it using existing accounts and just keep visiting.
 
"This list is NOT the list of people viewing your profile the most. This is just an array of user ID that is used when you start to type stuff into the search box. Facebook pre-loads the data so that your search results appear instantly. So these user IDs are simply the people/games/groups/etc that YOU most likely to search for.
There are a number of applications, groups, and games are in my list - are they really stalking me? Of course not.
"

This makes the most sense from that script^

It makes no sense why Facebook would store anything related to page views.


EDIT: Yep i'm pretty sure its this. Put a single letter in the search bar and you will see those top people pop up.
EDIT2: This is a pretty interesting algorithm.

Except this doesn't seem to be it exactly. I have three people in my top 10 whose name starts with an M but one of the three doesn't even show up when I just type in M. Also one of the other two is the second result (while the first, my brother, has a name that starts with a different letter) and the other is the fifth. So I guess it's part of the above but also something else.

Also, there's some really recent additions in my list but I've only looked at their profile once/twice, so I wonder why they're in the list.
 
Try putting a single random letter of that #3 into the search bar. Lemme know if that person pops up? Seems like an neat algorithm..maybe you two share a lot of mutual friends or likes of posts/movies/music/etc?

Afraid not:

Still nope. I got Pacific Rim, which I did like a few months ago.
 
Nope. Why would my top #3 likely searched/page view would be for 3 married/engaged people that I rarely talk to online or IRL? I'm not a homewrecker, FB!

Afraid not:

lol i meant the facebook search bar.

Facebook seems like its queuing up a "ordered list of friends" in its script to immediately popup (hence the instant drop down).

The question now is what variable/s its taking into account for it.
 
Something to do with interactions with each other.

For those who want to go through them quickly, try something like this:

Code:
javascript:(function(){a=[ PASTE_LIST_HERE ];for(i in a){window.open("http://facebook.com/" + a[i], '_blank');}})()

Copy that code, paste it in your address bar (if chrome strips out the "javascript:" at the start, type it back in), go to the facebook source and copy the list (everything inside the square brackets) and past the list where the code says PASTE_LIST_HERE. Hit enter and it should open a new tab for each member of the list in order, then scroll through the tabs (Ctrl+Tab in Windows/Linux).

UPDATE.

Made this:

http://jsfiddle.net/DerFlatulator6/BApjQ/embedded/result/
 
If it's any consolation the reverse is also true...I tried something different, I started searching the numbers from the bottom of the list, and sure enough they were of "friends" I barely knew that were on my Facebook friends' list, I barely knew they existed. People who never posted anything on my wall, liked anything or even messaged me in my inbox. And at the same token people I have never interacted with on their page/profile.

On the flip side, almost everyone on my top 25 list has "liked", has posted something on my wall or in my inbox at least once if not half to full dozen times and vise versa.

Is step 1 in the OP actually required? Seems unlikely this would have any browser type bias.

Nope, no browser biased for Firefox, works equally the same on Chrome and Firefox, I've never tested on others to confirm anything further.
 
Did anyone do the method a few times by logging in and out just to see whether the list of friends are arranged randomly or it stays constant?

I've tried refreshing my FB main page and relogging three times and found the order is sort of random. I said sort of because the friends that I usually chat on FB or interacted the most didn't seem to appear in the list whereas those I hardly communicate with are the ones in the list of order and the names shuffled everytime I refresh/relogging.
 
This could cause some social drama... I love it! :D


Something to do with interactions with each other.

For those who want to go through them quickly, try something like this:

Code:
javascript:(function(){a=[ PASTE_LIST_HERE ];for(i in a){window.open("http://facebook.com/" + a[i], '_blank');}})()

.

Nice!
 
Number 5 on my list is the girlfriend of one of my good friends who ranks much lower. I never use chat, and I never interact with her in much form really ever on facey-b, barring the occasional comment or like, while those I do interact with on a much larger basis rank lower. She did however tag me in a shitload of her own photos from summer so I can only hope this isn't a stalking list. There's some backstory that provides reason for my suspicions but nah, she can't be stalking me. In fact I stalk myself a lot (hey I like to browse my own photos okay) so perhaps when I browse the photos that she tagged/uploaded that counts as some sort of interaction.

Oh Facebook. U so Crazy.

Edit: Sheeeeet. I'm a member now? Time to shit up the gaming side with horrible threads.
 
Number 5 on my list is the girlfriend of one of my good friends who ranks much lower. I never use chat, and I never interact with her in much form really ever on facey-b, barring the occasional comment or like, while those I do interact with on a much larger basis rank lower. She did however tag me in a shitload of her own photos from summer so I can only hope this isn't a stalking list. There's some backstory that provides reason for my suspicions but nah, she can't be stalking me. In fact I stalk myself a lot (hey I like to browse my own photos okay) so perhaps when I browse the photos that she tagged/uploaded that counts as some sort of interaction.

Oh Facebook. U so Crazy.

Edit: Sheeeeet. I'm a member now? Time to shit up the gaming side with horrible threads.

congrats
 
I made a quick tool to do the laborious part for you, check it out!

http://jsfiddle.net/DerFlatulator6/BApjQ/embedded/result/

O2v0.png

Takes a little while due to it choking on heaps of API requests at once, but it works :P
 
"This list is NOT the list of people viewing your profile the most. This is just an array of user ID that is used when you start to type stuff into the search box. Facebook pre-loads the data so that your search results appear instantly. So these user IDs are simply the people/games/groups/etc that YOU most likely to search for.
There are a number of applications, groups, and games are in my list - are they really stalking me? Of course not.
"

This makes the most sense from that script^

It makes no sense why Facebook would store anything related to page views.


EDIT: Yep i'm pretty sure its this. Put a single letter in the search bar and you will see those top people pop up.
EDIT2: This is a pretty interesting algorithm.

Nope. Half of the names are people I don't even think about yet they're in the "top list". If this is a list favorite search results, then all of it must be girls.
 
my girlfriend was at number 1, but the following two didn't make any sense. the fourth one resulted in a page not found error
 
I wouldn't be surprised if they threw in a couple randoms to mix up the list. The first on my list is a girl I talked to for a bit a year ago, but now I don't think I've looked at her profile for about a year and I don't see her stuff pop up on my feed. Could be she is infatuated with me though
 
I can confirm this is just a random list of people. The first 5 of mine are people I rarely chat with (or post on their wall)
 
I inputed the codes into this tool and it just lists in order the profiles I have visited most recently
I wish I was having the same results...

"This list is NOT the list of people viewing your profile the most. This is just an array of user ID that is used when you start to type stuff into the search box. Facebook pre-loads the data so that your search results appear instantly. So these user IDs are simply the people/games/groups/etc that YOU most likely to search for.
There are a number of applications, groups, and games are in my list - are they really stalking me? Of course not.
"

This makes the most sense from that script^

It makes no sense why Facebook would store anything related to page views.


EDIT: Yep i'm pretty sure its this. Put a single letter in the search bar and you will see those top people pop up.
EDIT2: This is a pretty interesting algorithm.

It is indeed the list used to populate the search results, but I don't think searching actually affects the generation of the list. It has to be something to do with interactions.
 
Methinks this just means the list of people you share interests the most with in your friendslist, ordered.

Edit: Oh. :p
 
It is indeed the list used to populate the search results, but I don't think searching actually affects the generation of the list. It has to be something to do with interactions.

Thats what I figured. Its definitely using some variation of interactions to populate it.

The first 11 on my list are a group of friends and we're all in a group chat together. (Thats why I quickly jumped to the messages conclusion earlier.) Then I checked the last handful of tokens from the list and its some random people i've never interacted with other than I accepted their friend request and vice versa.
 
Yea its deff not #1 stalker. I also don't use FB chat so not sure its that. My gf came up as #3 and my #7 is someone who never even uses FB.

I don't think you have to be on your page either. I went on a friend's page and the same results came up
 
I got my ex-girlfriend, we broke up nearly a year ago and we don't have any contact through facebook ever since.

I don't know what to think of this.

I wish I was having the same results...



It is indeed the list used to populate the search results, but I don't think searching actually affects the generation of the list. It has to be something to do with interactions.

Hahah, now i look really bad. Weird though, haven't 'interacted' (chatting, searched her name etc) with her through facebook since the breakup.
 
ITT: People who don't understand how huge websites work.


PROTIP: It's not some huge conspiracy.

It's like whenever there's a new digital service that allocates a big temp file for downloads, but they don't zero the file out and people think the service is sending the left over file data to themselves because they don't understand how file tables work.
 
It definitely seems related to the sidebar chat. When I shrunk the window vertically to the point where the list is split in two, the numbers corresponded with the order of the people in the list, with the exception that people who were currently online got bumped up in the list.

EDIT: That still doesn't explain how the list is generated though, but the code snippet is most likely used by the chat.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom