Well, you didn't actually answer any of the complaints I stated in my post. I don't think I've lost anything I've had before.
December Comic |OT| Apocalypse NOW - Time Enough At Last.
- Thread starter The Take Out Bandit
- Start date
- Status
Well, you didn't actually answer any of the complaints I stated in my post. I don't think I've lost anything I've had before.
Filthy Slug
Crowd screaming like hounds at the heat of the chase/ All the colors of the rainbow flood my face
So which Superman story would you say is most ideal?
edit: I'm not trying to be condescending, I just really want to know, because it's disheartening that you're waving off a man whose work I find fundamental to modern comics. I find that people who haven't read a lot of Morrison (and truly, there's a LOT of Morrison out there) brush him off as a babbling kook, when really, that couldn't be further from the truth.
krypt0nian
Banned
You're way too far gone, and it's pointless. Carry on.
I don't ignore anyone here, but someone who posts this as a reply to Morrison's work doesn't deserve an answer. That's why you're muted. You basically posted the equivalent of red is green. I don't argue with crazy.
I'm fairly new to comics in general. I got most of my comic book knowledge from the animated series, movies, etc. I generally do research, but I haven't read that many older comics and, frankly, the new 52 doesn't impress me that much as a whole. I've read Batman, Detective comics, Batman and Robin, Batgirl, Batman the Dark Knight, Action Comics, Superman, Aquaman, Wonder Woman, World's Finest, Talon, a little of Teen Titans, Red Hood, Nightwing, Superboy, Demon Knights, Supergirl, and some of Morrison's current Batman Inc.
Of all those, I really feel only Snyder's Batman is exceptional. Talon is shaping up to be good as well, but it hasn't completed it's first story arc, so I'm waiting to see where it goes. Even if I enjoy Gail Simone's current Batman issues, I don't think a few issues is enough to make an accurate judgement call on a writer's talents.
Except you didn't reply with an argument even before I said the 'crazy' part, so don't act like you've given me a fair chance here. Your the one here who had a balanced argument put in front of him and then dismissed it with a 'lol, i dun get it, why dont u like morrison'. You don't want to talk, fine, but I was just playing the game you started.
This isn't true unless by bad you mean you don't agree with the podcaster's comic taste.
I used to listen to Comic Geek Speak, but as was mentioned above they are really nerdy. Their event episodes are entertaining, as are their previews run throughs and book of the month stuff, but I started skipping most episodes by the end. Also, for a comic podcast, a surprisingly low number of their cast actually keeps up with (or can afford) current comics.
iFanboy is pretty good if you want a weekly review podcast. They review the week's books the Monday following their release, and unlike a lot of Comic Geek Speek, the hosts are regular, relatable guys.
If you like X-men comics, Uncanny X-Cast is worth listening too. They only release 1-2 episodes a month and are usually way behind on their books, but I find the banter to be pretty funny and it made my commutes fly by.
If you are interested in comic creator interviews, Word Balloon gets most of the big names, and can get into some really interesting behind the scenes stuff.
Well if you're interested in reading comics beyond DC's current ultra mediocrity then Morrison's other works would be high on the list.
krypt0nian
Banned
Filthy Slug
Crowd screaming like hounds at the heat of the chase/ All the colors of the rainbow flood my face
Alright--well it's awesome that you've taken a liking to comics!
I'd like to make a suggestion: Read a fuck-ton of whatever you want, and then just go to your local library, and pick up We3. If you like that, try Doom Patrol. I mean, if you say you dislike Morrison after reading those 2, then at least you'll be able to say that you gave his work a shot.
Sorry I missed your last post.
To answer your question, here are the superman stories I've read:
All Star
Birthright
Lex Luthor - Man of Steel
For the Man Who Has Everything
Secret Identity
Secret Origin
I've also seen Superman vs the Elite, the first 2 Chris Reaves movies, and remember watching the animated series as a kid.
Of that list, I enjoyed Birthright and Lex Luthor the most. It's been a while, so I can't explain why I liked Birthright as well as I would normally be able to, but Superman was very likable and relatable in that story and I liked the flashbacks. Lex Luthor (the comic) was very compelling, but it wasn't about superman, exactly. Either of those are on my top superman story list. I also enjoyed The Elite movie a lot and liked that they addressed Superman's moral policy.
meh. Just reading the plot description of what happens in final crisis turns me off. However, I am too big a batman fan to let most major stories pass. Even Morrison's. So I'll read his run on Batman. Eventually.
Oh, that reminds me. There is one other Morrison story I read. Arkham Asylum - A Serious House on Serious Earth. Surprise: I found it mediocre. Way too long ago to remember why though. Was pretty disappointed too, the art was amazing and I ordered the special anniversary edition.
This is so amazing.
krypt0nian
Banned
Pretty good for pedestrian manchild nonsense.
I can't wait to do this. Where do I send my money? (what book is that?)
Vol 2 is better. Probably not "better" enough to get you out of your funk, but better.
Filthy Slug
Crowd screaming like hounds at the heat of the chase/ All the colors of the rainbow flood my face
Have you read Casanova?
There's a pretty funny Dillon issue there where he draws Hulk hilariously short, I think.
Sometimes, I read this thread and feel like some unwashed neanderthal. Every time I roll in here, something or other I like is getting called mediocre.
I bet y'all read comics while drinking tea with your pinkies out.
More on topic, I enjoyed what I read of Morrison's Animal Man. So much so, it turned down my opinion on the current run. Buddy is a much more fun character in that older run, as opposed to now, where he's just "Swamp Thing Jr."
I bet y'all read comics while drinking tea with your pinkies out.
More on topic, I enjoyed what I read of Morrison's Animal Man. So much so, it turned down my opinion on the current run. Buddy is a much more fun character in that older run, as opposed to now, where he's just "Swamp Thing Jr."
You can tell it was a stopgap book for him. Premise of the first half was just not very interesting and the whole run suffered from art inconsistency (I'm really not a fan of Silvestri or Portacio who did the entire first volume). It kind of reminds me of Remender's Secret Avengers right now where he's using leftover ideas from UXF with characters he's not really attached to. It's B/C-grade material from an A writer.
Welcome aboard!
As far as Morrison goes, one of my absolute favorite stories is DC One Million. If you like the JLA, give it a whirl! If you still don't like his stuff after giving it a shot, don't sweat it. There's a boatload of comics out there. You're not obligated to like any of it. Read what you enjoy.
On an entirely different note. . . I'm looking for advice on how to unload a bunch of comics. Currently sifting through about 35 years worth of books, and I'd like to get rid of approximately 70% of it. They're just taking up way too much space. (It would be great to actually park the car in the garage.)
I've gone through two long boxes so far, but uncovered runs of
Suicide Squad
Firestorm
Green Arrow
Marshall Law
L.E.G.I.O.N. '89
X-Men (which I'm keeping)
The Demon
Dr. Fate
The Spectre
JSA
Dreadstar
CoIE tie-ins (keeping, I think)
I have another dozen or so boxes to go through. Majority are from '80s, '90s, 00's.
It'd be great to sell them to interested buyers, but that seems like it would be a lot of work for a small return. So I'm strongly considering unloading them at a place like Half Price Books. Or maybe taking them to a comic book store for possibly more credit. Does anyone have any experience doing this? Any advice?
Sometimes, I read this thread and feel like some unwashed neanderthal. Every time I roll in here, something or other I like is getting called mediocre.
I bet y'all read comics while drinking tea with your pinkies out.
More on topic, I enjoyed what I read of Morrison's Animal Man. So much so, it turned down my opinion on the current run. Buddy is a much more fun character in that older run, as opposed to now, where he's just "Swamp Thing Jr."
Comic Fans. Mediocre is just a synonym for "I didn't like it". I have seen people call Watchmen and Sandman mediocre in this thread (well past editions of it).
I agree with you on Animal Man. Morrison's run was great, as was the stuff done with the character in 52 (which was the best mainstream event book of the 2000s in my opinion).
Parallax
best seen in the classic "Shadow of the Beast"
Sometimes, I read this thread and feel like some unwashed neanderthal. Every time I roll in here, something or other I like is getting called mediocre.
I bet y'all read comics while drinking tea with your pinkies out.
More on topic, I enjoyed what I read of Morrison's Animal Man. So much so, it turned down my opinion on the current run. Buddy is a much more fun character in that older run, as opposed to now, where he's just "Swamp Thing Jr."
I'm sure everyone's fave has been called out at least once
I regret that I still have not read 52 (among other things). I know I'll probably love it, but I have just not gotten to it.
Oh of course. I'm just kidding.
Filthy Slug
Crowd screaming like hounds at the heat of the chase/ All the colors of the rainbow flood my face
Gaiman's Sandman is the gateway drug, dude. I got into comics the same way.
I feel bad for those people. They're denying themselves the shining excellence of comic bookery that was the DAS.
(DAT DASSSSSSS)
Comics-GAF has its share of squabbles, but I've always appreciated this thread for being so kindly to new comics readers and for generally being about enjoying funnybooks and not throwing around our collective e-peens to prove who knows which Cyclops costume is best.
It's no-cap, Birdie, YOU SON OF A BITCH!
I regret that I still have not read 52 (among other things). I know I'll probably love it, but I have just not gotten to it.
Oh of course. I'm just kidding.
I am not a big DC guy, and I really liked it. So many great moments in that series. Continuity-wise none of it matters now (I don't even think half the characters exist anymore), but I'd still recommend picking it up when you get a chance.
Supermanisdead
Member
I like Morrison comics but I find him and his fans insufferable. I've dealt with true Morrison crazy fans and they go above and beyond any fan base. Same thing with Ellis tbh, but I find his writing mostly shit.
krypt0nian
Banned
It's obviously no-cap.
Filthy Slug
Crowd screaming like hounds at the heat of the chase/ All the colors of the rainbow flood my face
I like long flowing locks and pouches--so no cap is dominant.
Most 25-30 year olds will have a fondness for the Animated Series costumes, especially on GAF (all of Capcom's Arcade classics used those costumes).
i really liked the first Casanova, i'll probably have to reread it before i dive into vol 2 and 3 that i have on hand. I think Scarlet will be my next trade to read and then Action Comics 14 for single issues in the pile.
Don't do it man.
Supermanisdead
Member
Embrace that luscious head of hair. Cyclops just looks like less of a punk with his hair out.
To me the presence or lack of a cap isn't even the deal breaker, I just love that sick Y-shaped bandoleer so damn much!
BuddyJoeHooker
Member
I like what Immonen is doing with the Cyclopsi, #TeamCAP
the thought is in my head already. If i hate it, to ebay it goes, gotta thin the herd. Did anyone pick up that Brian Bolland OHC Judge Dredd Collection? Instocktrades.com has it half off.
SpaceBridge
Member
I love Morrison, and will forever view his work on New Xmen a masterpiece.
What's is comicGafs opinion on Bendis though?
What's is comicGafs opinion on Bendis though?
TheKaeptain
Banned
Even Cyke at his worst is cooler looking than anything Hawkguy has ever worn.
Casual Hawkguy is the best superhero uniform
Forreal though, come on this shit is abhorrent.
TheKaeptain
Banned
Superheroes in casuals is the best, always.
Parallax
best seen in the classic "Shadow of the Beast"
Superboy after young justice and farmhand superman disagree with that.
Supermanisdead
Member
When Bendis wants to, he nails it. His Ultimate Spidey and Daredevil were two of the best books from Marvel during their runs. But now, the new Miles series is garbage, his whole Avengers run was a joke and the random pet projects he had like Moon Knight and Spider-woman were disasters.
All New Xmen so far is alright, but it could go downhill and fast.
All New Xmen so far is alright, but it could go downhill and fast.
- Status
Similar threads
- Poll