Support NeoGAF

[daffy]

Her acting that entire scene was just sublime.

This. I really liked the scene a few eps back when she arrested Tyrion but this last scene was just head and shoulders!

This is one of the only shows I have seen that challenges the invincibility of key characters. And the way they play with the idea of survival, like having Robb rise up again and Catelyn crawling under the tables, it kind of lingers, the "well just maybe something will happen and they will be fine" feeling. Fantastic.

 

[Sai-kun]

Just spent 20 minutes crying in the bathroom. I'm done.

it will be okay sötnos :*

 

[nib95]

You suck at being comforting. Lol

I know it's terrible lol. I've read/seen/heard too much shit. I'm too desensitised.

 

[Phoenix]

Incredible scene. I wonder what happens to the rest of the Starks. I assume they're gonna go on full revenge mode.

There are barely enough of them to do anything now. They've lost the army, they've lost their home, they've lost their standing and future... there is nothing left for them.... that was a true decapitation strike on the Stark family .... in more ways than one.

 

[Madness]

Incredible scene. I wonder what happens to the rest of the Starks. I assume they're gonna go on full revenge mode.

How? Sansa is a naive moron married to Tyrion. Arya is stuck with the Hound who probably won't let her go. She's been wanting revenge for 3 seasons. She should add Roose Bolton, Tywin Lannister and Walder Frey to her nighttime prayer curse list.

Bran is headed north of the wall to find out what the hell is wrong with him. Rickon is off with Osha somewhere and I think this means he's done for a while since he had few lines or story.

Jon is the last one who has any chance and he has Tormund and a pissed off Ygritte on his ass, a nights watch all but done, some mutiny assholes who killed Lord Mormont and white walkers and wights and Mance Rayders army about to march on the wall.

With the death of Robb, his bannermen, and Cat, the Starks lost, the North lost. I have no hope left for any victory against the Lannisters by Starks. At best, Dany will right these wrongs if/when she comes.

 

[Luixfern]

I.... I don't even know how I feel right now. This is gonna be on my mind all day at work tomorrow.

 

[Altazor]

Well I guess that was bad suggestion and I'm sorry, just didn't want to say anything. I know for the next time. My bad.

don't worry dude, you probably had the right intentions but still.. it bears repeating - don't google anything about ASOIAF. If you're worried about certain characters' fates PM a book reader. You can even go to Tower of the Hand, a website with information that you can "customize" depending on how many books you've read.

 

[iNvid02]

note to self: prepare yourself mentally and have tissues handy for future episode 9's

and hate EVERYONE, then you can never get hurt. fuck you martin

 

[Kisaya]

I really don't care about anyone in this show anymore. I'm only watching for Daeny scenes now.

it will be okay sötnos :*

Still wiping away tears :'(

 

[DrForester]

Bah

 

[ramyeon]

How? Sansa is a naive moron married to Tyrion. Arya is stuck with the Hound who probably won't let her go. She's been wanting revenge for 3 seasons. She should add Roose Bolton, Tywin Lannister and Walder Frey to her nighttime prayer curse list.

Bran is headed north of the wall to find out what the hell is wrong with him. Rickon is off with Osha somewhere and I think this means he's done for a while since he had few lines or story.

Jon is the last one who has any chance and he has Tormund and a pissed off Ygritte on his ass, a nights watch all but done, some munity assholes who killed Lord Mormont and white walkers and wights and Mance Rayders army about to march on the wall.

With the death of Robb, his bannermen, and Cat, the Starks lost, the North lost. I have no hope left for any victory against the Lannisters by Starks. At best, Dany will right these wrongs if/when she comes.

With Jon being part of the Watch it's not like he can really do anything. I'm pretty sure they don't concern themselves with stuff South of the Wall.

I'm really warming to the Hound, and really interested in where his character ends up going. Especially with this new dynamic between Arya and him.

 

[Kyon]

I really don't care about anyone in this show anymore. I'm only watching for Daeny scenes now.

This.

Done with this shit. Hope she burns everything and everyone to death I don't care

 

[Madness]

I really don't care about anyone in this show anymore. I'm only watching for Daeny scenes now.

Isn't Brienne a favorite of yours? I'm holding out some hope for when she finds out they killed Catelyn.

 

[mr2xxx]

When Walder showed his daughters off to Robb before, he showed him all the ugly ones essentially.

Gotta explain it in simpler terms. Frey was pissed due to Rob back stabbing him, what does ugly or beautiful daughters have to do with that? I'm assuming the beautiful girl was just getting ready for the wedding, doesn't seem strange she was MIA for the apology,

 

[Moaradin]

note to self: prepare yourself mentally and have tissues handy for future episode 9's

You know, I was fully expecting a big event to happen on Episode 9. It happened in both seasons leading up to this. I don't think you could ever fully prepare for that though.

 

[Sajjaja]

How? Sansa is a naive moron married to Tyrion. Arya is stuck with the Hound who probably won't let her go. She's been wanting revenge for 3 seasons. She should add Roose Bolton, Tywin Lannister and Walder Frey to her nighttime prayer curse list.

Bran is headed north of the wall to find out what the hell is wrong with him. Rickon is off with Osha somewhere and I think this means he's done for a while since he had few lines or story.

Jon is the last one who has any chance and he has Tormund and a pissed off Ygritte on his ass, a nights watch all but done, some munity assholes who killed Lord Mormont and white walkers and wights and Mance Rayders army about to march on the wall.

With the death of Robb, his bannermen, and Cat, the Starks lost, the North lost. I have no hope left for any victory against the Lannisters by Starks. At best, Dany will right these wrongs if/when she comes.

STANNIS WILL RISE FROM THE ASHES AND SOAR THROUGH THE SKY LIKE A PHOENIX REBORN!

Tywin is already on Arya's list and Arya has no way of knowing that Bolton betrayed her family.

 

[cameron]

WTF is this shit. I guess I didn't learn my lesson after season one. Blah.

 

[PopcornMegaphone]

There are barely enough of them to do anything now. They've lost the army, they've lost their home, they've lost their standing and future... there is nothing left for them.... that was a true decapitation strike on the Stark family .... in more ways than one.

I meant jon snow and arya. Not a full war.

Remember Arya can summon that assassin.

 

[Maddocks]

STANNIS WILL RISE FROM THE ASHES AND SOAR THROUGH THE SKY LIKE A PHOENIX REBORN!

AWWWWWWW YYYYEEEEEEAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHH

 

[Sajjaja]

Gotta explain it in simpler terms. Frey was pissed due to Rob back stabbing him, what does ugly or beautiful daughters have to do with that? I'm assuming the beautiful girl was just getting ready for the wedding, doesn't seem strange she was MIA for the apology,

I mean in the seasons before when Robb vowed to marry one of his daughters and make her his queen. He showed off his ugly daughters and Robb was just completely turned off by the idea.

 

[Kisaya]

Isn't Brienne a favorite of yours? I'm holding out some hope for when she finds out they killed Catelyn.

Yeah I love her... but her traveling with Jamie isn't going to make me feel any better.

I'm so miserable right now

 

[mm04]

I guess I have the Arya and the Hound road show to look forward to. Arya will eventually kill some Lannisters with the Hound's help. Can I have that, please? I need some Lannister blood to be spilled! Not some dumb ass cousins either.

 

[Chuck Norris]

A wedding without three deaths is considered a dull affair

 

[ArbiterMajor]

don't worry dude, you probably had the right intentions but still.. it bears repeating - don't google anything about ASOIAF. If you're worried about certain characters' fates PM a book reader. You can even go to Tower of the Hand, a website with information that you can "customize" depending on how many books you've read.

Thanks for the suggestion, I'll keep it in mind.

 

[Sajjaja]

A wedding without three deaths is considered a dull affair

The Khalisar will be pleased.

 

[sp3000]

Everyone should be rooting for Stannis now

 

[Ninja Scooter]

Jon basically went down on a homeless chick. He is far too dumb to have any impact on the crown.

 

[PopcornMegaphone]

Everyone should be rooting for Stannis now

I think we both know that's not going to turn out well. He's weak.

 

[MyAbsolution]

Everyone should be rooting for Stannis now

I always have been But now more than ever. The lord of light needs to get busy.

 

[Xamdou]

A wedding without three deaths is considered a dull affair

It was actually four deaths, the fourth being the unborn heir of the north...

 

[mr2xxx]

I mean in the seasons before when Robb vowed to marry one of his daughters and make her his queen. He showed off his ugly daughters and Robb was just completely turned off by the idea.

Ahhh ok got you, you're saying all this was planned way back. Damn that is cruel.

 

[Sajjaja]

I always have been But now more than ever. The lord of light needs to get busy.

If the lord of fucking light can bring a dude back 6 times from the dead, hell yeah he's doing some crazy ass shit.

 

[ramyeon]

It was actually four deaths, the fourth being the unborn heir of the north...

I think there were a lot more than 4 deaths lol.

 

[royalan]

Sheeeeeeeeeeeeeeiit.

If my last name was Stark now would the time to go into hiding.

Yeah...I really don't see how the Stark family can come back from this.

I think the problem facing the show now is I really have no idea who I should be rooting for or sympathizing with.

Everyone left is either not in any position to be making bold moves...or are just fucking AWFUL people.

 

[Liquidsnake]

What that fuck man. I have no words for what I just watched. I shed a tear. This is not right man this is not fucking right!

 

[Balphon]

Everyone should be rooting for Stannis now

Probably a good plan given his strategy of shadow magicking kings to death.

 

[IrishNinja]

Anyone else think it would of been cool if some wizards teleported in and saved the starks?

i was personally hoping for Skull Knight

 

[Kisaya]

Also, fuck Jon Snow too. I really hope Ygritte has the chance to cut off his dick.

 

[Chuck Norris]

It was actually four deaths, the fourth being the unborn heir of the north...

A great wedding then

 

[RyanDG]

I mean in the seasons before when Robb vowed to marry one of his daughters and make her his queen. He showed off his ugly daughters and Robb was just completely turned off by the idea.

When Robb made the vow to Frey, he hadn't actually seen the daughters. Only Catelyn did, and when she told Robb about them, she sort of tried to downplay their ugliness (of the ones she saw), but it was clear what she meant when she was asked about their looks. I thought that scene was played rather well.

However, it does reinforce the fact that everything is Catelyn's fault.

Ned going to King's Landing
Jaime being let go
Telling Robb that Frey only had ugly daughters
Capturing Tyrion
Not loving Jon

She really has a laundry list of issues

 

[FlutterPuffs]

By the way, a little something for the non-book readers. The Red Wedding was part of Daenerys dream in the Season 2 finale. Check it out.

 

[vitaminwateryum]

Anyone else think it would of been cool if some wizards teleported in and saved the starks?

Time travelling alternate universe mecha-Ned Stark.

"Winter is coming...AND SO IS VENGEANCE."

 

[Psychoward]

A wedding without three deaths is considered a dull affair

HA

Also, we were shown earlier Bolton's men despised Jaime, assuming some of the men at the wedding were Bolton's, how did he convince them to fight for the Lannisters?

 

[cdkee]

Yeah...I really don't see how the Stark family can come back from this.

I think the problem facing the show now is I really have no idea who I should be rooting for or sympathizing with.

Everyone left is either not in any position to be making bold moves...or are just fucking AWFUL people.

That's the thing though. GRRM said himself that no character is written to be black or white. Even Joffrey, the insufferable little shit, is a product of his environment. His characters are all grey, with some leaning a little more to one side than the others.

 

[Jarek23]

Ahhh ok got you, you're saying all this was planned way back. Damn that is cruel.

It wasn't planned until after Robb married Talisa. It was breaking the oath to marry one of the ugly daughters that caused all of this.

 

[StopMakingSense]

This is greeeeeaaaaat:

https://twitter.com/redweddingtears/

 

[phantomspiker]

#teamlannister

Rob Stark sucked anyways.

 

[Phaethon0017]

Everyone should be rooting for Stannis now

I think it was his penis leeches are what made that event so brutal.

Or it was just the luck of the Starks. But nevertheless never rooting for Stannis. Davos all the way though. Hopefully gets off that sinking ship.

 

[pulga]

It's been a ride people. Feels good to have this finally out. This shook me to the core years back. Fucking brutal.

Anyone open yet a Red Wedding Counsel Group?

 

[Hystzen]

HA

Also, we were shown earlier Bolton's men despised Jaime, assuming some of the men at the wedding were Bolton's, how did he convince them to fight for the Lannisters?

They do what they are told by their lord