The Death Of Nintendo Has Been Greatly Under-Exaggerated

oVerde

Banned
If am I Sony or MS, would fear the Next console, with so much head pounds Nintendo will pull a beast (or the last one?).
 
The reason they are really doomed is that they don't put the customer first. Then they put their fingers in their ears when customers give them feedback and say "LALALALALALA NOT LISTENING!!"
 
gj4tz.gif

full.png


Nintendo-is-Doomed.jpg


Think that about covers it.

Incredible. I especially like the chalkboard. We need more chalkboards.
 

jeffers

Member
someone should make a web tool to auto-generate these nintendo editorials. not sure why journos think its original thought.
 
I won't deny that Wii U sales are abysmal and I think they're past the point of being able to really turn it around, however as far as I'm concerned Wii U has had a great first year:

ZombiU
New Super Mario Bros U
New Super Luigi U
Pikmin 3
Lego City Undercover
The Wonderful 101
Rayman Legends
Wind Waker HD
Donkey Kong: Tropical Freeze
Super Mario 3D World

If I have played as many great exclusives as that (Rayman being the only non exclusive) on my PS4 as that in the first year I'll be extremely happy. Nintendo has delivered with the games, just not the sales.
 

tchaten

Neo Member
"But all the 2DS really is is an admission that the 3DS is ultimately a failure."

That line alone sells it to me that the author is an idiot. The 3DS is the currently the highest month to month selling gaming system out there. The 2DS is not an admission of anything except that Nintendo wants to expand the market to 7 and under kids and those that aren't huge gamers and $129 might be an impulse buy.
 
I'm not going to argue public perception of the Wii U, because it's pretty cut and dry how that's working out. That said, I don't think it can get any worse than it is right now. Well, it can, but I don't think it's going to happen. It has a really good holiday lineup this year, and while it doesn't have the game the console needs for sales to bloom, it's going to pick up. Also, the idea of amputating the Wii U now is just crazy. Nintendo wouldn't have a replacement more in line with public desire. What they need to do is what they're always been good at: making great software. They needed this year's lineup last year, and they need a more diverse, inventive lineup for next year. If they can do they, they'll probably be all right.

And the 3DS a failure? C'mon. It's certainly no DS at this point, but I'd say they're doing all right. Saying that right before the release of Pokemon is laughable.
 

PureGone

Banned
I won't deny that Wii U sales are abysmal and I think they're past the point of being able to really turn it around, however as far as I'm concerned Wii U has had a great first year:

ZombiU
New Super Mario Bros U
New Super Luigi U
Pikmin 3
Lego City Undercover
The Wonderful 101
Rayman Legends
Wind Waker HD
Donkey Kong: Tropical Freeze
Super Mario 3D World
Rayman Legends

If I have played as many great exclusives as that (Rayman being the only 3rd party title) on my PS4 as that in the first year I'll be extremely happy. Nintendo has delivered with the games, just not the sales.

That's not a great year, you listed Rayman twice, you listed a reskin DLC, and HD re release, some of those games are not even out yet, and look at the metacritic scores of those that are.

At this point I would be perfectly fine with Nintendo giving up consoles and being a handheld only company, more 3DS games the better
 

Broken Joystick

At least you can talk. Who are you?
From the same article, this will get discussion going

Nintendo needs to make a case for why stand-alone gaming should still exist. I’m not sure this is possible, mind you. But I think this is the only way they exit our current era as a leader, rather than a has-been. The Wii seemed close, but ultimately turned out to be pretty much the definition of a fad. Still, that thinking-outside-the-box allowed them to — albeit briefly — surpass both Sony and Microsoft.
 

Randdalf

Member
That's not a great year, you listed Rayman twice, you listed a reskin DLC, and HD re release, some of those games are not even out yet, and look at the metacritic scores of those that are.

At this point I would be perfectly fine with Nintendo giving up consoles and being a handheld only company, more 3DS games the better

I see you've actually played it then. Oh wait.
 

?

By the time it's been out a year there will have been 10 great exclusives out for it. Is that really so bad? I can honestly say that neither the 360 or PS3 brought ten great exclusives out every year over. They might not be the top tier, games of forever titles like Mario Galaxy and Ocarina of Time, but they're all great games.

I judge my consoles by the experiences I've had with it, not sales.
 

Fonz72

Member
Nintendo is the Apple of video games. Mass profit, followed by a not so hot year or two and BOOM! The company is dead! They will never regain success! DOOM! GLOOM!

What a terrible link bait article.

The 2DS is taking the place of the DSi in Nintendo's lineup. It is an entry level handheld that will play all of the current 3DS games as well as the huge DS library. I can't believe people don't see that. It's the perfect handheld for young kids, as they aren't supposed to use the 3D on the 3DS anyway.

It will be a huge success and in no way spells failure for the 3DS, in fact it is a testament to the success of the 3DS as there are enough games made for the system that Nintendo has the option to sell a second platform for them.
 
That's not a great year, you listed Rayman twice, you listed a reskin DLC, and HD re release, some of those games are not even out yet, and look at the metacritic scores of those that are.

At this point I would be perfectly fine with Nintendo giving up consoles and being a handheld only company, more 3DS games the better

Luigi is far more than re-skinned DLC. It's worthy of being a standalone title and is better than the Mario game. WW HD should be great, it's just WW with better graphics. Safe bet no? And who cares what the metacritic of some of those games are, ZombiU was SLATED yet it's one of my favourite horror games ever.
 
maybe if we all wish this was true long enough Nintendo would finally listen and do something so stop denying the article and agree with it :3

I want change!

man that sucked to read lol
 

redcrayon

Member
Nintendo definitely don't have as rosy a future as many would have you believe, but I think 'on the path to failure' is an exaggeration. They do need to step their game up though.
I can agree with that, challenging times but they'll still be around for a while yet.


I totally can't jive with this bit. The 2DS is a sign that Nintendo still 'get it'. It's a really good move and will go some way to getting their handhelds back on track.
Heh.
If Nintendo had based all of their software entirely around 3D, and were now withdrawing the 3DS models, he'd have a point. But they deliberately set it up so that 3D wasn't essential, future non-3D portables would still be able to play the software, and the 3DS and XL are still selling. That's not failure, it's called having a bit of regard for future compatibility while expanding a successful product range and cross-selling with software (Pokemon). Not really sure how anyone can say it means they've run out of ideas, it'll be interesting looking at the Xmas sales of the thing and how much it cannibalises the standard 3D models, or whether it adds growth, that's what I'm interested to see. Every so often Nintendo get a batshit-crazy simple idea that just works.
 

RMI

Banned
well it's about time we had one of these. It's already Thursday.

For a company that is always never not doomed, Nintendo is doing pretty good.
 
They realize the metrics that really matter: that the 3DS is tracking roughly 20 percent behind its predecessor in terms of sales. That’s not only not a good trend, it’s a devastating one (after a few early price cuts, to boot). A couple more of those and we have a company on the brink.
So selling worse than best selling handheld ever makes company doomed.
ok
 

hachi

Banned
They realize the metrics that really matter: that the 3DS is tracking roughly 20 percent behind its predecessor in terms of sales. That’s not only not a good trend, it’s a devastating one (after a few early price cuts, to boot). A couple more of those and we have a company on the brink.

Absurd to go in with the expectation that any Nintendo handheld can bring DS-level success, and likewise with any Wii successor. Nintendo makes entertainment gadgets, and sometimes with a little luck these arrive at exactly the right moment to catch the world on fire. The DS hit just as touchscreen casual gaming was ready to explode, and the Wii hit just as the TV set was ready to become a social hub for accessible gaming. Those are wonderful success stories, but there's no way to expect that level of success to be sustained consistently. I'm sure big hits will come in the future, but in the business of making unique gadgets with various hooks, you'll never see a straight line of sales gen after gen.
 

Sendou

Member
Mostly the same, couple new levels and bosses, still a reskin

Are you talking about Super Luigi U? There are no same levels BUT bosses are the same IIRC. So that's 82 completely new levels for $20. Why are you talking shit about game you haven't clearly played?
 
WiiU's complete failure in one of Nintendo's two main markets has to be a huge concern but the author's points regarding the 3DS are just garbage. The product has been very successful and there really isn't any reason to think the next mobile won't do roughly as well. 3DS has made money while competing with smart phones and tablets, I don't see anything else out there to threaten that.
 

Burger

Member
MG Siegler is usually worth reading, and pretty well placed to comment.

Replying to the article with a funny picture or "Horrible Article" isn't exactly a great counter point.
 
It's funny to see how many think Nintendo cannot be harmed. I've been a fan and owner of thei platforms for decades and this is the worst situation I can ever remember them being in (excluding the Virtual Boy disaster).

I actually think people are too optimistic.

It's not just about games. Momentum is a big part of it all and the Wii U doesn't even have a chance to get going without Mario Kart for the holiday. They're gonna get steamrolled by next gen launches.

Any logical gamer should be concerned about Nintendo's future in the marketplace.
 

qko

Member
I hate the "tracking below the DS" argument because the DS was one of highest selling products in the history of video games. Everything is tracking below the DS. Why didnt this argument pop up with the PS3 which has not and will never reach the PS2. Heck the Vita isn't even tracking with the PSP. Yet no "Sony is dooooooomed"
 
The article is fairly in depth, I suspect most people are just reading a couple of lines in the OP. I don't think the company is doomed for failure but they have shown a lack of innovation and willingness to adapt that is being magnified by the speed of change in the industry (smartphones, tablets and games on them). The author also makes a point that this is also a threat to Sony and MS, one that they must adapt to in order to thrive. Anecdotally my kids time with their 3DS is also shared with time on our tablets and the smartphones that we handed down to them. The market is actually expanding but the part that Nintendo caters to is shrinking rapidly. They have to adapt.
 

Maedhros

Member
He should right a article about vita if he wants to talk about failure.

Nah, he should stick with the Wii U.

I hate the "tracking below the DS" argument because the DS was one of highest selling products in the history of video games. Everything is tracking below the DS. Why didnt this argument pop up with the PS3 which has not and will never reach the PS2. Heck the Vita isn't even tracking with the PSP. Yet no "Sony is dooooooomed"

You must live in a rock or something like that.
 

Stet

Banned
I think the headline is the most inflammatory part, as usual, but there are some salient points in the body of the article.
 
I was with him, then he started talking about IOS ports and Disney buyouts. Sorry, but he takes this way too far to take seriously.
 
MG Siegler is usually worth reading, and pretty well placed to comment.

Replying to the article with a funny picture or "Horrible Article" isn't exactly a great counter point.

There are many posters who have pointed out why the article is bullshit, you're just picking the worst/most simplistic ones. It's a bad article because it skirts around facts, exaggerates the negative, and at time outright lies to push its agenda.
 

KAL2006

Banned
I totally agree WiiU is absolutely Dead, there is no saving the system, whether you have a price drop, remove Wii pad and etc. I think Nintendo have lost the console market and cannot regain it even with their next system. Luckily their 3DS system is successful, however not as successful as DS due to smartphones taking over. I think all Nintendo can rely on is the handheld market right now with games like Pokemon and Mario like they have been successful before with the Gameboy. Perhaps their next system would be basically a handheld system with a HDMI output.
 
Top Bottom