If they do another 180 and remove the Kinect, that would be the last straw. I would never buy XB1 in that circumstance. Well, certainly not for $399. The Kinect is about the only "uniquely interesting" thing the XB1 has going for it. Get rid of that and you've just got a PS4, except slower. And with better online.
What they
need to remove is the Kinect
price premium. If Microsoft wants to force everybody to purchase the Kinect, with all benefits currently sight unseen, then they can by-god pick up the tab for it! Or, at least subsidize the shit out of it. As it is now, only Microsoft seems to think the Kinect will be super useful, and yet everybody
except Microsoft is being forced to pay for it. It might suck!
Now, I personally believe that the Kinect
might be cool. And I certainly believe that it
has to be packed into every SKU, or it will be ignored by developers just like the first Kinect was. But since Microsoft has not shown us any
evidence of this theoretical future coolness, I'll be damned if I'll plunk down $100+ of my money, just to be part of some grand experiment.
So, again to repeat:
- XB1 plus Kinect for $499 -- Hell, no. That's too much to pay, even if the Kinect turns out to be sweet.
- XB1 with no Kinect for $399 -- Still no. You just described a slightly shoddier version of the PS4. I can get an actual PS4 for that.
- XB1 plus Kinect for $399 -- Okay, now you're starting to appeal to those of us who have some "faith" in the Kinect. Maybe a bit slower than the PS4, but it's got that fairly snazzy camera...
- XB1 plus Kinect for $349 -- Now you're starting to appeal to the folks that don't even want the Kinect. It's (at worst) a slightly cheapafied PS4 at this point, and if the Kinect does pan out, that's an actual damn good value.
- XB1 without Kinect for $299. This is the last ditch, "get out of hell" SKU. Rolled out only when all else has failed. This is the "Faster Wii U, except with games" SKU. And at that price, it might even sell to the imaginary demographic that buys consoles to watch TV on.