The evokers were too heavy handed and got old fast. It only seemed intense in the first 2 or 3 scenes, then you just became desensitized, P4 had so much going for it to strike the right tone between "these are high school kids" and "this is a messed up situation" but then you got to spend half the game forgetting about the messed up situation part and it became a scooby doo dating sim.
Also, robot girls in love and talking fur suits.
I think they're "letting go" of those games though. We get our mostly cutesy spinoffs and a kind of serious P4A sequel and P5 is its own beast. If you can tie the games to the system they're released on, I think I'm expecting something more in the line of Catherine than P4, honestly.