Support NeoGAF

[Schmo Florez]

I'm 31. I was just old enough for Transformers/ Thunder cats, obsessed with Ninja Turtles and the perfect age for the original Nicktoons.

Interesting there seems to be more youngins in here than I thought. Pokemon died in a freak accident. The random entertainment of this thread keeps delivering! Much like the shows we are voting for.

 

[Dicer]

Poor Eek! I can't save you this time, and Pokemon going out like this is just sad.

Time to drop my crusade for now and cut some of the fat off.

Kill: Weekenders
Kill: Weekenders
Save: Arthur, what other fucking cartoon can claim they had Neil Gaiman as a guest?!?!

 

[Markster]

This thread is full of babies!
How can you give an educated opinion if you weren't even alive for some of these shows?!

I'm 29.
I was watching cartoons in '88, and by '90 I was a connoisseur. And then I was nerdy enough to keep watching through the end of the decade.

Haha, it's cool. Though now I understand the serious lack of love for Reboot.

Kill: Weekenders
Kill: Arthur
Save: Reboot

I'd prefer to hit Hey Arnold or Recess first, but Weekenders has to go too, so I'm all over that bandwagon.
Arthur, is a victim of my advanced age. It's always been a "kids show" to me, and not one I could get in to.
Reboot is amazing. The humor and slapstick, combined with the countless subtle computer jokes. Hell, they had an episode that featured Guild strife, years before multiplayer RPGs hit it big!

The précis on TMNT by The Adder is spot on. Within 2 episodes of the 2003 airing, I already knew it was superior. Though, my nostalgia will probably still have me throw a save at TMNT a couple times.

 

[Camwi]

Kill: Animaniacs
Kill: Freakazoid
Save: ReBoot

I can't vote out a cartoon I've never seen, like Weekenders. Who knows, there's always a possibility that I'd enjoy it.

The first two shows annoy me, ReBoot is cool.

Oh, and I'm 31.

 

[weekend_warrior]

Kill: SWAT Kats
Kill: Weekenders

Save: Ren & Stimpy

How come Aurthur is on the list but The Magic School Bus isn't? I vote to add The Magic School Bus to the list.

PS. I'm 29.

 

[SonicMegaDrive]

Wow, I actually like most of the remaining shows. It's gonna be tough to decide who to vote off the island pretty soon.

Kill - Hey Arnold
Kill - Hey Arnold

Save - Ren & Stimpy

 

[KalBalboa]

Wow, I actually like most of the remaining shows. It's gonna be tough to decide who to vote off the island pretty soon.

Kill - Hey Arnold
Kill - Hey Arnold

Save - Ren & Stimpy

You'd kill Hey Arnold over Weekenders?!

You misspelled best friend.

Much thanks.

 

[KalBalboa]

Might just be my ego talking, but I may be partially responsible for murdering the ever loving shit out of that happening.

Nah, the alliance worked and got the show killed we were all aiming for that round.

Kill: Eek The Cat!
Kill: Arthur
Save: Hey Arnold

Hey Arnold brought us Stoop Kid, Grandpa, and a myriad of other legends. It cannot die now.

As a reminder, this is what The Weekenders was:

 

[Goliath]

Kill: The Weekenders
Kill: Spongebob

Save: Gargoyles

Spongebob is so overplayed now and is still alive and kicking. Looking at that list and knowing ReBoot never got a proper ending as good of a show as it was I just can't help but hate Spongebob even more.

 

[KalBalboa]

Kill: Pokemon
Kill: Spongebob

Save: Gargoyles

Spongebob is so overplayed now and is still alive and kicking. Looking at that list and knowing ReBoot never got a proper ending as good of a show as it was I just can't help but hate Spongebob even more.

Pokémon is already dead, my friend. May I suggest killing Arthur or Weekenders?

 

[Goliath]

Pokémon is already dead, my friend. May I suggest killing Arthur or Weekenders?

Request granted.

 

[KalBalboa]

Request granted.

 

[LordCanti]

There's now 4 Hey Arnold kills. Just throwing that out there.

 

[weekend_warrior]

Nah, the alliance worked and got the show killed we were all aiming for that round.

Kill: Eek The Cat!
Kill: Arthur
Save: Hey Arnold

Hey Arnold brought us Stoop Kid, Grandpa, and a myriad of other legends. It cannot die now.

As a reminder, this is what The Weekenders was:

Weekenders should be automatically disqualified for not being a 90's show.

 

[KalBalboa]

There's now 4 Hey Arnold kills. Just throwing that out there.

I think you know where you save must go now.

Weekenders should be automatically disqualified for not being a 90's show.

Yeah, maybe we should have started this with a "must have had one complete season in the 90s" rule or something, but what can you do.

 

[Divvy]

Kill: South Park
KIll: South Park

Save: Animaniacs

 

[CorporateClown]

Kill: Doug
Kill: Doug
Save: Eek the Cat

Doug used to get on my nerves and I would actively cheer for Roger.

 

[Schmo Florez]

Aladdin AND Hercules are still on the list people! Pure crap! C'mon guys!

 

[KalBalboa]

Aladdin AND Hercules are still on the list people! Pure crap! C'mon guys!

Soon, soon. Maybe even tomorrow.

 

[LordCanti]

Aladdin AND Hercules are still on the list people! Pure crap! C'mon guys!

Yet Doug, Hey Armold, and South Park all have kill votes now. This could be the day where it all goes sideways.

I think you know where you save must go

I really don't know lets see if anyone else tries to knife Doug or Rugrats.

 

[Schmo Florez]

Yes, Doug was pretty emo, but you gotta love everyone's unique theme music that played every time they were on screen. Oh and Porkchop! And everyone's favorite, killer tofuuuuu!

 

[KalBalboa]

Yes, Doug was pretty emo, but you gotta love everyone's unique theme music that played every time they were on screen. Oh and Porkchop! And everyone's favorite, killer tofuuuuu!

Mr. Dink and his wife still make me chuckle. She clearly wasn't thrilled they were still an item.

 

[Schmo Florez]

Alright alright.

Kill: Hercules
Kill: Hercules

Changed my mind. Had to go back and stand by my original plan to kill Disney milking crapola. The movies were great, the shows not so much.

Save: Hey Arnold!

Great theme song, grandpa was classic, Gerald was great, Helga hating Arnold but secretly loving him, and Arnold's amazing room!

 

[KalBalboa]

Alright alright.

Kill: Arthur
Kill: Arthur

Really? A kiddie PBS show.

Save: Hey Arnold!

Great theme song, grandpa was classic, Gerald was great, Helga hating Arnold but secretly loving him, and Arnold's amazing room!

The Jolly Ollly Man and his hatred of children was great.

 

[Macmanus]

Aladdin AND Hercules are still on the list people! Pure crap! C'mon guys!

Aladdin was legit. Dan Castellaneta, Jason Alexander, and Uncle Phil?! Come on!

 

[Spectral Glider]

Kill: Arthur
Kill: Weekenders (Down with the kiddie shows!)
Save: Eek!

 

[FoxSpirit]

Kill: Weekenders
Kill: Home Movies
Save: Swat Kats

Who in their right mind would vote out Swat Kats at this current point. In the finals, okay, but now?? Come on.

 

[A Human Becoming]

Pokemon was a pretty terrible anime. Still, never expected it out this early.

I turned 25 less than a week ago. Seems many people in this thread are January babies.

Kill: Arthur - Never liked it and I'll go with the majority this time.
Kill: Swat Kats - Never saw it, will probably keep voting for it until it dies.

Save: Hey Arnold! - Lots of memorable aspects: Stoop kid, Arnold's crazy dance, Helga's obsession with him.

 

[RobotNinjaHornets]

Know what, fuck you guys.

Kill: Hey Arnold
Kill: Hey Arnold
Save: The Weekenders

Hey Arnold was shite

 

[Camwi]

Aladdin was legit. Dan Castellaneta, Jason Alexander, and Uncle Phil?! Come on!

Aladdin always annoyed me because they turned Genie into a pussy.

 

[SmithnCo]

Kill: Arthur
Kill: Arthur
Save: Spongebob

Arthur was okay for a kids show I guess, but it was also bland as shit. The early Spongebob seasons were classic.

 

[Schmo Florez]

Aladdin always annoyed me because they turned Genie into a pussy.

THIS!!!

 

[Frustrated_Grunt]

Kill: Aladdin
Kill: Eek the Cat
Save: Hey Arnold
Edit: Just realized Hey Arnold was getting quite a few kills, so I changed it to that.

 

[The Adder]

Aladdin always annoyed me because they turned Genie into a pussy.

Return of Jafar did that. The show just didn't contradict the film.

 

[A Human Becoming]

I just realized King of the Hill was never on this list. I want another do over!

 

[TheAbsolution]

I just realized King of the Hill was never on this list. I want another do over!

Shouldve suggested it when we held nominations.

 

[The Adder]

"I come from the Net. Through systems, people, and cities, to this place - Mainframe. My format, Guardian: To mend and defend. To defend my new found friends, their hopes and dreams, and to defend them from their enemies."

"I come from the Net. Infecting systems, people, and cities, to this place, Megaframe: my domain. My format, Virus: To corrupt and conquer!"

"I look to the Net. I search though systems, peoples and cities for these sprites: my family. My format: Command.Com of what was once Mainframe."

"I live in the games. I search through systems, people, and cities, for this place: Mainframe; my home. My format? I have no format. I am a renegade, lost on the Net."

Loved that about that show. Having never seen someone could figure out the story arc over 3 seasons just hearing those intro quotes.

 

[KalBalboa]

Know what, fuck you guys.

Kill: Hey Arnold
Kill: Hey Arnold
Save: The Weekenders

Hey Arnold was shite

Nope.

 

[BlackNMild2k1]

Kill: Arthur
Kill: Goof Troop
Save: Ren & Stimpy


I almost joined the cause on Weekenders, especially after it's reveal to not actually be a 90's cartoon, but I already had my mind made up before I skimmed the thread on what I was voting for.

 

[The Adder]

Kill: Arthur
Kill: Goof Troop
Save: Ren & Stimpy


I almost joined the cause on Weekenders, especially after it's reveal to not actually be a 90's cartoon, but I already had my mind made up before I skimmed the thread on what I was voting for.

It is no less a 90s show than Spongebob. It, in fact, started airing a month before Spongebob did.

 

[weekend_warrior]

It is no less a 90s show than Spongebob. It, in fact, started airing a month before Spongebob did.

Agreed. Spongebob should be out too.

 

[BinaryPork2737]

Let's just keep the list as it already is to avoid unnecessary confusion.

And did we ever come to a conclusion about what happened to Beast Wars? It should be given the chance to compete

Spoiler

even if it will probably die almost immediately

.

 

[Schmo Florez]

It is no less a 90s show than Spongebob. It, in fact, started airing a month before Spongebob did.

I didn't realize Spongebob came out in '99. Out with you Spongebob! Even though I love the show to death it is not a 90's show.

 

[vikki]

Let's just keep the list as it already is to avoid unnecessary confusion.

And did we ever come to a conclusion about what happened to Beast Wars? It should be given the chance to compete

Spoiler

even if it will probably die almost immediately

.

No way, beast wars is pretty great. It would last into the top 10 at least. I actually thought it made it into the list.

I'm 29 and a half.

Spoiler

Why are we stating our ages?

 

[TheAbsolution]

It is no less a 90s show than Spongebob. It, in fact, started airing a month before Spongebob did.

Agreed. Spongebob should be out too.

I didn't realize Spongebob came out in '99. Out with you Spongebob! Even though I love the show to death it is not a 90's show.

You so much as think about cutting Spongebob, I will cut you.
The question was what is the best shows from the 90s and it qualifies. It aired during the 90s so it counts.

 

[NastyBook]

People hating on Arthur need to watch the Thomas Edison episode, or the episode where D.W. and Arthur trade insults, or the one where Arthur knocks D.W. the fuck out.

Kill: Hercules - Rarely have I enjoyed Disney shows based on movies.
Kill: Aladdin - Disney's original content cartoons from the 90s were much better than either of these two shows.
Save: SWAT Kats: The Radical Squadron. I would throw a save towards Arthur, but it wouldn't even mitigate the damage. It was a genuinely good show until they switched out all the damn voice actors three times over.

 

[Conflict NZ]

This thread is full of babies!
How can you give an educated opinion if you weren't even alive for some of these shows?!

I'm 29.
I was watching cartoons in '88, and by '90 I was a connoisseur. And then I was nerdy enough to keep watching through the end of the decade.

Yeah I had a suspicion that a lot of people in this thread were a bit old for cartoons by the time the 90s came around. Anyway.

Kill: Ren & Stimpy
Kill: Ren & Stimpy

We got so close guys lets finish this shitty show off.

Save: The Weekenders

 

[RumblingRosco]

Yeah I had a suspicion that a lot of people in this thread were a bit old for cartoons by the time the 90s came around. Anyway.

Kill: Ren & Stimpy
Kill: Ren & Stimpy

We got so close guys lets finish this shitty show off.

Save: The Weekenders

We have to regroup and strike against R&S another day, brother. It is a shit show, but we need reinforcements to over come the people that pretend to like it.

 

[weekend_warrior]

Yeah I had a suspicion that a lot of people in this thread were a bit old for cartoons by the time the 90s came around. Anyway.

Kill: Ren & Stimpy
Kill: Ren & Stimpy

We got so close guys lets finish this shitty show off.

Save: The Weekenders

Can we vote posters out too? I'd like to vote for this person to be banned from this thread.

 

[MikeHattsu]

Kill: Arthur - I know I've seen this, but can't remember much about it, so off it goes
Kill: The Weekenders - Never seen
Save: Eek! The Cat

We have to regroup and strike against R&S another day, brother. It is a shit show, but we need reinforcements to over come the people that pretend to like it.

Yup