Played for hours last night, the PS3 version plays silky smooth 100% of the time. The only thing that seems to chug slightly are the cutscenes, which after you've watched them for the 100th time, we all just skip past anyways, so not an issue for me whatsoever.
The gameplay was smooth as a baby's bottom, which is what I was concerned about after reading the morons at IGN make it sound like the gameplay was affected, so I was relieved to have my fears alleviated. Once again, IGN proves that the people reviewing these games need to work on the skill of writing and clearly illustrating the points they want to get across to avoid confusion and panic amongst the game-buying masses.
But I digress...
As for the game itself, it's hella fun. One of my biggest beefs in past NHL videogames is the lack of offensive capability on the AI's behalf. There's nothing worse than watching an AI opponent come streaking in on a breakaway and never score. It's very unrealistic. In NHL 08 however, these guys can put the biscuit in the basket, no worry there. Playing Ottawa, I was left pulling my jockstrap up off the ice on more than one occasion, as the computer made me look foolish.
The AI is also incredible at avoiding hits. Body checking in this game is incredibly difficult, where I used to get maybe 30-40 hits in a game, I find myself getting 8-10. Again, much more realistic.
The AI as a whole is pretty impressive, so much so that I was forced to play my inaugural Dynasty season on Rookie mode, so I could actually compete with them on a game by game basis. Even then, I found myself battling hard for every inch, I think my current record is 3-2, with only game game being decided by more than a lone goal thanks to a couple empty netters.
One problem I have with the game though, is I am finding it difficult to wrap my head around the prospect of shooting with both sticks simultaneously. The left stick is supposed to control my body while I'm skating, yet whenever I want to shoot, it also controls the direction of the puck. So if I want to skate one direction and shoot the other direction, I always seem to have trouble in doing so. Maybe it's because I haven't played an NHL game in so long, and I'm used to using the face buttons for shooting, but it's definitely something that I'm having a tough time getting used to.
But the game rocks, there's no doubt about that. The graphics are awesome, the sound is extremely well done, listening as the crowd starts chanting "Go Flames Go!" when I was down at home by a single goal late in the third period was awesome, and then watching as the AI pinned me in my zone with an extremely effective puck cycle, and my fans became frustrated and started booing my team, classic.
The AHL integration is also a nice touch as well, calling up players from the farm has a much greater impact when you can actually see them playing and chart their development with your own eyes should you choose to go that route. Have a guy on your team that is digustingly underperforming? Well, go ahead and watch your AHL team's next game, and see if there's anyone that stands out as deserving of a shot at the bigs.
As a GM, you need to deal with all of the day to day aspects of managing your team, one-way and two-way contracts, the waiver system, contract offers, team budgets, etc. It's all very engrossing, and nicely laid out so it doesn't feel too daunting to a newcomer such as myself.
It's got a full range of practice modes, probably the best in any hockey game ever. Whatever the situation, you can practice it. Choose the precise amount of offensive and defensive players on the ice at any given moment, skating and passing drills, shooting and goalie practices... whatever floats your boat.
What's also really neat is the RPG element that EA has added to the mix this year. Your players gain experience after a strong performance, so this allows you to actually develop young talent with a lot of potential, something that I've never experienced in a hockey game before.
For instance, I created myself, and naturally, maxed out my stats so I would be uber. However, this made it near-impossible for me to sign myself onto the Flames, as I would constantly reject any contract offer, because I was too damned awesome and wanted like 8 million per season, which was way out of my team's budget.
So I recreated myself with much more realistic stats, managed to sign myself to a contract, and gave myself some decent playing time. The first few games I didn't manage any points, then I had a 2 goal performance, and was named 2nd Star, earning myself some experience points in the process. Now, I'm still early in the season, but I can see how that with enough strong performances, by the end of the season, my player should have better stats than when he started, making the long-term deal I signed him to, a much more worthwhile investment.
It's a fun aspect of the game that I'm enjoying.
Oh yeah, almost forgot to talk about Goalie mode. So awesome, yet so difficult.
I love the camera angle they give you in the mode, as it really feels like you are the last line of defence, and they give you plenty of different moves to work with, from glove saves, butterfly stances, spread eagle desperation, stacking the pads and diving across the crease... not to mention my fave, being allowed to skate anywhere on the ice, and not just restricted to your crease.
There's a couple moves from past NHL games I'm missing in this mode, the diving pokecheck being one of them, but I haven't put a ton of time into this mode, so it might be in there, who knows.
All in all, this is a very enjoyable return to my NHL gaming roots. I haven't picked up an NHL hockey game since 2001 if I recall correctly, and this is just what the doctor ordered. It plays great, looks awesome, and sounds just as good.