Alien 5 (Sigourney Weaver) TBA

Which Ripley?

civil-war-soldier-scene-2.jpg


Just please stop.
 
Hollywood writers when they have to bring back an old beloved character but it's a woman so they can't use their standard strategy of making them depressed and replaced by a strong independent woman.

nervous k&p GIF by myLAB Box
 
Last edited:
Easy instant dismissal, but then I see Walter Hill writing. Damn, been burned by the older creators just not cutting it in their later years and the dude is over 80 now, but he did The Warriors, 48 Hours, The Getaway, Southern Comfort, Aliens.

No. Even if he nails a good script the studio will screw it up some how.
 
Donald mac Ronald said:
Alien Romulus sucked . When add up the good Vs the bad. Majority of them suck.
Click to expand...

Romulus was one of my top three Alien movies, I don't get why you guys didn't like it. It was tense from beginning to end and did some great world-building. Sure, the initial crew was annoying but the main protagonists were top notch imo
 
I remember back in '97, Drew's Script-o-Rama website came out with a load of unshot/early draft movie scripts and I read a few Alien 3 ones.

One that vaguely stayed with me was William Gibson's version that featured a shopping mall. Ripley is in a coma, Hicks, Bishop, and Newt are alive with a host of new characters.


I wonder how that script stood up over the years.
 
Sonik said:
Romulus was one of my top three Alien movies, I don't get why you guys didn't like it. It was tense from beginning to end and did some great world-building. Sure, the initial crew was annoying but the main protagonists were top notch imo
Click to expand...
It had worse writing then even Prometheus, which was already a cluster fuck of stupid decisions...how can anyone like it?

I'm not someone who will say that dumb movies are not allowed, but both those movies came from 2 of the best sci-fi horror/action movies ever made with the first two Alien movies. They were both smartly written compared to the dogshit that Prometheus and Romulus were.

Romulus somehow managed to be worse with characters that were beyond stupid, but must have had brain damage.
 
Last edited:
Power Pro said:
It had worse writing then even Prometheus, which was already a cluster fuck of stupid decisions...how can anyone like it?

I'm not someone who will say that dumb movies are not allowed, but both those movies came from 2 of the best sci-fi horror/action movies ever made with the first two Alien movies. They were both smartly written compared to the dogshit that Prometheus and Romulus were.

Romulus somehow managed to be worse with characters that were beyond stupid, but must have had brain damage.
Click to expand...


Dude, wtf, it wasn't even close to the dumb decisions the imbeciles of Prometheus made, they were a bunch of desperate kids and most of the shit they did was out of desperation or love for their friends, it wasn't even close to actual scientists acting like the biggest morons on the universe

The writing was also pretty good imo, the relationship between the two "siblings" was interesting, the plot kept getting more and more tense and honestly the only moment the movie fucked up was with the fucking CGI android which I bet was a studio decision
 
MrTroubleMaker said:
Her character died, are they f'n up lore again?
Click to expand...
All they have to do is a nightmare fake out of Alien 3 and just start where Aliens ended. Aging can be explained away by drifting in space again. They can be picked up by a colonization vessel like in Covenant and be landing on a remote planet that also has Xenomorph unbeknownst to them. Maybe David can also make an appearance. Having sequels that bridge the narrative with prequels is tight.
 
Last edited:
poodaddy said:
Nailed that one, well done.

My question is, how do they bring her back? Hasn't she already died twice in the series?
Click to expand...
MrTroubleMaker said:
Her character died, are they f'n up lore again?
Click to expand...
Since this series is technically sci-fi and now attached to Predator at the hip, my guess is time travel.

Disney will have a chance to bust out the de-aging tech again like they did for Harrison Ford.

face-reveal-indiana-jones.gif


But this kind of goes against my theory of them wanting to keep it safe, so maybe it will be even dumber than that.
 
Last edited:
This would be about 15 years late man...
Besides. wasn't Neill Blomkamp supposed to shoot/was in the talks about a sequel with both Ripley, Hicks and Newt years ago ?

It could have been cool and surely better than the utter garbage we got (Prometheus/Covenant/Romulus).
 
UUuuuuuuugh. No.

AFAICT there is no gatekeeper of Alien lore, someone I would trust to greenlight good content. Alien:Earth having 200+ million spent on it tells me there is no one reading scripts and thinking clearly.

So dragging Weaver out again smacks of desperation rather than answering some long standing audience desire.
 
Power Pro said:
It had worse writing then even Prometheus, which was already a cluster fuck of stupid decisions...how can anyone like it?

I'm not someone who will say that dumb movies are not allowed, but both those movies came from 2 of the best sci-fi horror/action movies ever made with the first two Alien movies. They were both smartly written compared to the dogshit that Prometheus and Romulus were.

Romulus somehow managed to be worse with characters that were beyond stupid, but must have had brain damage.
Click to expand...
And dont forget the "Neural Diverse" robot. 😅🤣
 
Last edited:
Giallo Corsa said:
This would be about 15 years late man...
Besides. wasn't Neill Blomkamp supposed to shoot/was in the talks about a sequel with both Ripley, Hicks and Newt years ago ?

It could have been cool and surely better than the utter garbage we got (Prometheus/Covenant/Romulus).
Click to expand...
Was really bummed when Neils version was canned. He is the closest weve got to an younger Cameron these days. I wish hollywood would bankroll him more often.
 
It was already borderline ridiculous she ended up in another survival situation against xenos by the 2nd film. It just keep going from there.
 
A direct sequel to Alien Resurrection might work mixed in with a loose adaption of Steve Perry's Earth Hive trilogy.
 
I liked Romulus, the TV show seems pretty good from the couple of episodes I've seen.

This seems like a step back for a franchise that was starting to do good things.

This'll get whoops and cheers at comicon or whatever but I can't imagine it turning out well or that those same fans who cheer it will actually like it.

I can imagine the studio saying "Huh we're on the up with this, let's bring out the big guns" and that being enough to completely derail everything again.
 
Last edited:
Sonik said:
Romulus was one of my top three Alien movies, I don't get why you guys didn't like it. It was tense from beginning to end and did some great world-building. Sure, the initial crew was annoying but the main protagonists were top notch imo
Click to expand...
Because they went full Alien4 on the ending and you never go full Alien4...
 
Aliens 1 and especially 2 are still the best, wish Alien 3 never happened.

I kinda like Alien Resurrectiion too as it's my first Alien movie but realize a lot of people don't like it.
 
Listen here doubters... like yeah the bitch is older than dirt.... buuuuuut have you considered if you just put her up against Aliens™ who are also elderly you got a recipe for success?
 
Hawk The Slayer said:
Aliens 1 and especially 2 are still the best, wish Alien 3 never happened.

I kinda like Alien Resurrectiion too as it's my first Alien movie but realize a lot of people don't like it.
Click to expand...
Funnily i think that david fincher should do this movie as i think it should be a dark and slow burn scifi horror with old ripley and not a actiony extravaganza and a trent reznor/atticus ross soundtrack
 
Last edited:
Fbh said:
Hollywood writers when they have to bring back an old beloved character but it's a woman so they can't use their standard strategy of making them depressed and replaced by a strong independent woman.
Click to expand...
Except that's exactly what they did in the last Terminator movie.
 
Putonahappyface said:
That's Ripley's daughter.

BeuNhUIeTMc0T8L1.gif
Click to expand...
That was before Ripley ventured into a black hole that they didn't know was there after nuking LV426..

It was always Ripley in the picture.. it turned out Burke had just pulled a random picture from the net that just so happend to appear from a time paradox that happend 10 seconds before he even saw the picture.. Ripley was in the wardrobe behind him too, at that very point!

OgrAPuGHPUpnig34.gif


..Plot hole sorted.

Let's Alienss :messenger_sunglasses:
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Sigourney Weaver in Talks to Join ‘The Mandalorian & Grogu’
17
2K
Cyberpunkd replied
Tim Burchett : There are underwater Alien bases
2
63
375
j0hnnix replied
Alien Earth Open Spoiler Thread
14 15 16 17 18
859
5K
Romulus replied
OpenAI announces GPT-5
2
78
1K
ADiTAR replied
True Detective Season 5 starring Nicolas Cage
2
57
955
SJRB replied
Top Bottom