So Angry Birds has always got a shitty rep here on GAF. It's mocked and used as an example of a game which is showing how stupid the mobile market is and "killing hardcore games".
I've been playing it for the last few days (yeah, way behind the times, I know!) and I'm honestly baffled why. Right now, all I can assume is the people who say this are either extremely anti-phone games, haven't ever played it, or both.
To me, it seems no different to a game like Peggle, a game which is almost universally loved by "gamers". I've managed to get three stars on all of the levels for the first two parts of the game, but as I'm progressing it's becoming quite damn hard and very much a respectable puzzle game. I can see some levels taking a lot of effort to get three stars on and I'm not ashamed to admit I've given up on a few already because I just couldn't figure out how to do it.
I honestly think if this game launched on Steam/XBLA etc it wouldn't have nearly as much of a bad rep as it does on GAF, because it's a damn good game.
I will say I wish they listed the requirements for getting three stars. It sucks I have to get two stars and then try to guess what the next threshold is to get three...
I really need to stop playing it to try out other games, but man, it's so tough not to load it up and try to perfect another level...