WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Cewyn-kun what are your thoughts so far? Haven't heard much from you. （￣ε￣）
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Anime Mafia |OT| My Little Scum can't be this cute! ()
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I'm bored and trying not to overeat (º﹃º)
Yeah it's right on the OP:
So, because it's burb moderating you're talking about this?
Next.
Honestly I just caught up from the last 3 pages and am in utter disbelief how much effort we're spending speculating about lovers etc. because Burb is moderator and he made a lovers game once.
Just...what?
We work with what we've got, nothing yet so far hints at any sort of lovers/mixed alignment gossips.
Creating far too much noise here.
for the record, lovers can't be mixed alignment.
A mixed alignment masonry can be possible, known as Neighbours. I had this in one of my games.
All threats to Anime (AKA Town) is the generic Town win condition for most games.
Dragonz what do you think of 30yearsofhurt
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
i have to agree with caboot, the shipper discussion seems to have really run away with itself, we have zero reason to actually believe its actually in this game.
(that said i would probably probably be willing to put money on it being here).
so polts whole self-sacrifice thing, as fars as it could really determine his alignment, i cant decide. the comments about it, taking in regard to pretty much everything else he has said so far, entirely speaks of a inexperience, but i cant for the life of me tell if this is an inexperienced scum overextending himself in his attempts to appear townie, or and inexperience townie legitimately thinking that this is the attitude a townie should have.
but there still two days to make up my mind, so ayyyyyyyy.
(that said i would probably probably be willing to put money on it being here).
so polts whole self-sacrifice thing, as fars as it could really determine his alignment, i cant decide. the comments about it, taking in regard to pretty much everything else he has said so far, entirely speaks of a inexperience, but i cant for the life of me tell if this is an inexperienced scum overextending himself in his attempts to appear townie, or and inexperience townie legitimately thinking that this is the attitude a townie should have.
but there still two days to make up my mind, so ayyyyyyyy.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
what the bet its a trick prize?
sure you get a steam game, but its one of those super creepy anime games that steams become flooded with.
kyaaa
ok imma like this is a joke reaction baiter and such. could be dank gambits too from meanies but eeeeeeh. dunno!
gustie is playing the newbie very hard, nothing that incriminating imo, as long as the play keeps going til the end of the game.
since i thinks "imma the law" is jokes, this seems to go lil too deep imo. does super dragonz detective who looks over every detail match the rest of her content? hmm.
online? have ya played mafia offline then?
reaaaaaally newbish or extremely filler-y.
we can't do anything until we have something concrete, eh. disagree, as that magical point of concrete might never even come (beyond lynched ppl getting revealed). gives the newbie vibes too but also reeks of scum.
really digging that newbie hole. if you is of valuable town asset, you is of engaging self defense.
change of behavior, sure. the joke, naaaah.
i don't see this. feels fake. scummy too.
palmer too seems to be thinking of gambits. takes it more seriously than dragonz i think?
an another bit of speculation. notable part is that everything is speculated about to cover them bases. scum or a super anime analyst professor type? hmm.
silly no lynchers. is no good line of thinkings. all these newbie feels make it hard to pinpoint which of the bunch is an actual meanie and who is not grr.
nice noise. superb filler. i'd reward some shitpostpoints but all this lead was a bunch of filler so no points for you.
ok imma like this is a joke reaction baiter and such. could be dank gambits too from meanies but eeeeeeh. dunno!
gustie is playing the newbie very hard, nothing that incriminating imo, as long as the play keeps going til the end of the game.
since i thinks "imma the law" is jokes, this seems to go lil too deep imo. does super dragonz detective who looks over every detail match the rest of her content? hmm.
online? have ya played mafia offline then?
reaaaaaally newbish or extremely filler-y.
we can't do anything until we have something concrete, eh. disagree, as that magical point of concrete might never even come (beyond lynched ppl getting revealed). gives the newbie vibes too but also reeks of scum.
really digging that newbie hole. if you is of valuable town asset, you is of engaging self defense.
change of behavior, sure. the joke, naaaah.
i don't see this. feels fake. scummy too.
palmer too seems to be thinking of gambits. takes it more seriously than dragonz i think?
an another bit of speculation. notable part is that everything is speculated about to cover them bases. scum or a super anime analyst professor type? hmm.
silly no lynchers. is no good line of thinkings. all these newbie feels make it hard to pinpoint which of the bunch is an actual meanie and who is not grr.
nice noise. superb filler. i'd reward some shitpostpoints but all this lead was a bunch of filler so no points for you.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
30yearsofhurt gives me not great feelings, though im hesitant to put much weight on this, as much of it is how i disagree on the no-lynch/wait till power roles give us something mentality, as this isnt nessisarily a scummy mindset no matter how much i disagree with it.
also that second sentence doesnt seem to make any sense.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
wait, is this asking me to be anime about me gutfeels, asking for my gutfeels about anime, or saying im top anime gutfeel?
also what about zubz do you like?
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 1 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
No Lynch (2)
Poltergust 119
Nomadic Sparks 351
TheExodu5 (1)
cabot 565
Poltergust (1)
squidyj 289
Haly (1)
cabot 146 305
Palmer_v1 398
30yearsofhurt (1)
rac 335
Kyanrute (1)
Dusk Soldier 308
hey_monkey (1)
TheExodu5 344
hatmoza (1)
cabot 347 353
hey_monkey 453
WhereAreMahDragonz (1)
BlackBuzzard 320
30yearsofhurt 529 546
rac (1)
Swamped 204
30yearsofhurt 220 251
Dusk Soldier (0):cabot 305 347
Nomadic Sparks (0):Palmer_v1 352 398, cabot 353 565
squidyj (0):cabot 116 146, SkyOdin 131 528, 30yearsofhurt 251 529
cabot (0):Palmer_v1 274 352
No active vote for Day 1: 30yearsofhurt (has previously voted), Bowlie, Cewyn, Haly, hatmoza, Kyanrute, oreomunsta, SkyOdin (has previously voted), StanleyPalmtree, ultron87, WhereAreMahDragonz, Zubz
Day 1 Postcount: 30yearsofhurt 18, BlackBuzzard 10, Bowlie 8, cabot 50, Cewyn 3, Dusk Soldier 11, Haly 16, hatmoza 0, hey_monkey 44, Kyanrute 8, Nomadic Sparks 21, oreomunsta 19, Palmer_v1 23, Poltergust 34, rac 14, SkyOdin 26, squidyj 29, StanleyPalmtree 9, Swamped 8, TheExodu5 5, ultron87 6, WhereAreMahDragonz 64, Zubz 14
Day 1 ends:
12 votes for majority
No Lynch (2)
Poltergust 119
Nomadic Sparks 351
TheExodu5 (1)
cabot 565
Poltergust (1)
squidyj 289
Haly (1)
Palmer_v1 398
30yearsofhurt (1)
rac 335
Kyanrute (1)
Dusk Soldier 308
hey_monkey (1)
TheExodu5 344
hatmoza (1)
hey_monkey 453
WhereAreMahDragonz (1)
BlackBuzzard 320
rac (1)
Swamped 204
Dusk Soldier (0):
Nomadic Sparks (0):
squidyj (0):
cabot (0):
No active vote for Day 1: 30yearsofhurt (has previously voted), Bowlie, Cewyn, Haly, hatmoza, Kyanrute, oreomunsta, SkyOdin (has previously voted), StanleyPalmtree, ultron87, WhereAreMahDragonz, Zubz
Day 1 Postcount: 30yearsofhurt 18, BlackBuzzard 10, Bowlie 8, cabot 50, Cewyn 3, Dusk Soldier 11, Haly 16, hatmoza 0, hey_monkey 44, Kyanrute 8, Nomadic Sparks 21, oreomunsta 19, Palmer_v1 23, Poltergust 34, rac 14, SkyOdin 26, squidyj 29, StanleyPalmtree 9, Swamped 8, TheExodu5 5, ultron87 6, WhereAreMahDragonz 64, Zubz 14
Day 1 ends:
12 votes for majority
when worded like that it feels like scum going for the arrogant play
i've done that in the past as a meanie at least
need to read to see if it feels like that
Can you elaborate on this? how would squidy think that Dragonz is cop and squidy is trying to shift focus?
Dusk Soldier
Member
Cabot, I want you to be honest with me.
Who are you in a secret chat with and why don't you want us to know about it?
140 characters or less please.
Who are you in a secret chat with and why don't you want us to know about it?
140 characters or less please.
Dusk Soldier
Member
Nomadic-kun, Poltergust-kun,
I'm concerned you two are using the no Lynch stance as an excuse not to scum hunt.
I can tell you from experience that a no Lynch will not happen today.
I know there's not much to go on yet, but it will be at least 3 or 4 day phases before we get something concrete and by then it could be too late.
Placing a vote on scum even if they don't get lynched is often a sound strategy as they often are hesitant to night kill players that target them during the day phase.
Don't let this day phase go to waste.
vote: palmer_v1
I'm concerned you two are using the no Lynch stance as an excuse not to scum hunt.
I can tell you from experience that a no Lynch will not happen today.
I know there's not much to go on yet, but it will be at least 3 or 4 day phases before we get something concrete and by then it could be too late.
Placing a vote on scum even if they don't get lynched is often a sound strategy as they often are hesitant to night kill players that target them during the day phase.
Don't let this day phase go to waste.
vote: palmer_v1
It's with you, you need to answer my calls.
Dusk Soldier
Member
I was kind of surprised to see you lump Swamped-hime in with kyanrute, the_exodu5-kun and ultron87-kun.
But I'm glad you pointed it out. Reading over her posts there hasn't been much substance. She was flying under the radar for me.
Looking back at Palmer, there's not a lot there. Lot's of explaining the game and a read on squidy and Nomadic, along with his very early read list.
He's a worthwhile person to have around in the game though, and there are others doing worse than he, so I'll not be taking him down Day 1 barring some disaster he posts in future.
He's a worthwhile person to have around in the game though, and there are others doing worse than he, so I'll not be taking him down Day 1 barring some disaster he posts in future.
Dusk Soldier
Member
Just quoting this for extra emphasis because i want to make sure people read this.
Cabot's official stance is that he's in a secret chat with me.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Would like to see more going forward but cannot gauge player attitude/behavior rn. Seems to pop in once and a whole to say a whole bunch on nothin. Am not sure if newbie town trying to play smart or newbie scum who is scared
So a null
Dusk Soldier
Member
I thought it was fairly obvious based on his vote patterns and his non-committal stance.
Am I over thinking this?
Dusk Soldier
Member
I don't want to argue about this here. Let's take this to our chat.Vote patterns? With no lynch?
Are you thinking at all?
Duskabot? Caboldier? Who's the seme?
(you don't need to google that if you don't know what it means)
Nomadic, It's been some time since that was said. Could you explain to me again why is it not well for *you* to be lynched?
(you don't need to google that if you don't know what it means)
Nomadic, It's been some time since that was said. Could you explain to me again why is it not well for *you* to be lynched?
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
i am very confused by what Dusk is trying to do/say with cabot and his supposed secret chat.
am i missing something, or is confusion the natural reaction here?
i googled it,
am i missing something, or is confusion the natural reaction here?
i googled it,
i expected worse.
They both said they were and were not in a secret chat. I'm as confused as you, the argument went nowhere.
You didn't look hard enough, but that's okay.
Looked at Ultron more closely, and while his posts are devoid of meaty content his posts don't seem inherently scummy to me at this time. This is because he made two pretty unequivocal statements - he scumreads Poltergust for his overly-done statements of asking people to lynch him, and implying he is vanilla (no powers). It is useful to note that he hasn't voted for him though, but it seems like Polter is his top scum choice atm. He also said to wait a night to make a decision on squidy, which is reasonable enough.
Cewyn - he hasn't posted much. I've played several other games with him (before he got reincarnated) and he's kind of a wild-card player (super fun lol). He usually doesn't go with the flow, he has his own agenda in mind, even if he is town. Maybe things have changed now, and I'd like to see where things with him go. Currently it seems like he's holding back? He agreed with Ultron on Poltergust, whom he also scumreads. Dunno, I'll have to wait on this one.
BlackBuzzard is interesting. At first I thought his posts were kind of filler-ish, but he makes some very accusatory statements right off the bat, but he explains his thinking. I think I lean town on him
Nomadic Sparks comes across as town to me. He accused Palmer and Cabot of being scum, seemingly because they both voted for him. But Nomadic's reaction felt too quick, and too heated to be a scum one. Also, would two scum partners really vote in succession like that, especially on D1 and so early in the day? In my experience scum usually spreads out votes and tries not to draw attention to them.
Exodus seems to be on travel, hotmonza hasn't posted yet so may get replaced I think.
Thanks for explaining your stance on squidy. Like you said, it is convoluted and risky but if anyone can pull it off it's squidy. I still lean town on him today though.
Cewyn - he hasn't posted much. I've played several other games with him (before he got reincarnated) and he's kind of a wild-card player (super fun lol). He usually doesn't go with the flow, he has his own agenda in mind, even if he is town. Maybe things have changed now, and I'd like to see where things with him go. Currently it seems like he's holding back? He agreed with Ultron on Poltergust, whom he also scumreads. Dunno, I'll have to wait on this one.
BlackBuzzard is interesting. At first I thought his posts were kind of filler-ish, but he makes some very accusatory statements right off the bat, but he explains his thinking. I think I lean town on him
Nomadic Sparks comes across as town to me. He accused Palmer and Cabot of being scum, seemingly because they both voted for him. But Nomadic's reaction felt too quick, and too heated to be a scum one. Also, would two scum partners really vote in succession like that, especially on D1 and so early in the day? In my experience scum usually spreads out votes and tries not to draw attention to them.
Exodus seems to be on travel, hotmonza hasn't posted yet so may get replaced I think.
Thanks for explaining your stance on squidy. Like you said, it is convoluted and risky but if anyone can pull it off it's squidy. I still lean town on him today though.
Why? We don't even know if it's a role that is present.
That phrasing by itself felt dangerous to me (you yourself said that attitude was a "possible threat"). I'm not asking him if he's a PR or not, or to use his hypothetical ability, I just want to know why he said that - like that - when he didn't answer clearly by "besides the obvious?". Maybe it *is* obvious, but I want to hear him say it.
As I said before, I'm going to spend most of today away from the game/internet, and i'd like to clear this noise instead of keep tunneling.
What exactly should I be committing to? One of the half dozen random theories people have floated based on zero actual evidence?
The only real commitment people can make today is to voting and lynch/no-lynch. I've had and will have votes in place for most of this phase, and I'm obviously firmly in the lynch basket. There's a lot of sketchy people who haven't even made THAT far yet.
No active vote for Day 1: 30yearsofhurt (has previously voted), Bowlie, Cewyn, Haly, hatmoza, Kyanrute, oreomunsta, SkyOdin (has previously voted), StanleyPalmtree, ultron87, WhereAreMahDragonz, Zubz
These players are the problem currently, and I think it's foolish to look elsewhere on D1.
These players are the problem currently, and I think it's foolish to look elsewhere on D1.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
South Park taught me what seme means (⺣◡⺣
♡*He's either town soft claiming a PR or he's scum trying to save his skin. Pick one.
Poltergust
Member
Yeah, a handful of times. It's actually kinda popular in the Smash community lol.
That said, the last time I played was like 2 years ago. I don't even remember if I won that time or not.
Wait, I was fishing? I was fixated on them, but that's because I think special roles are super special awesome. I don't think I was actively looking for them outside of trying to figure out what squidyj is all about.
Well that smashing bowlie fellow seemed to think so. That was my impression at least
Still trying to make sense of some posts. Anyways, business as usual for a Mafia game. A cop reveal this early doesn't make sense but then again this is sdquidy
If he is indeed a cop then this must be some reverse psychology move against scum, unless he isn't a cop and has an ability that activates when he's targeted (I forgot the formal Mafia name) but I still think he pretty much gave himself in (ha! Pun intended...
Get it? Because he's a cop and he's turning himself in... Okay I'm not good at jokes
As for you... Hmmm, I'd read you as solid town for now, and given the past game we played which you probably may not remember
(I don't remember either)
So I guess if I'm too vote for someone and given that we still have more than 24 hours, I'd go with...
Vote: Squidyj
For now...
I assure you all, me squeaking by without a ton of substance on the first day is entirely within character for me. Gut reads aren't really my forte. This always results in people thinking me fishy. This is my lot.
I don't really like either of the two players currently voting No Lynch, Nomadic Sparks and Poltergust. Poltergust for reasons stated earlier with the suspicious selfishness. Sparks because of the aggressive response to being voted for: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=234315271&postcount=358 There being less than 15 minutes between the vote and the response makes it feel like a super genuine response to being voted for, which makes me think scum since they really don't want to be voted off. Town would be more chill. I can indeed put both of those off to new player jitters, but that's where I'm at.
Vote: Nomadic Sparks
The following paragraph is just possible role grousing and remembrance of game's past. It is fluff.
My initial inclination on the seeing the gender stuff was that'd it be a gender targeting Serial Killer like I was in the ill-fated Werewolf 1 game. In this game I'll just assume it is Death Note themed, because writing down names in anonymous PMs to kill people is too damn flavorful for it not to be that. It could also just be flavor, or be text that's there for tweaked versions of classic roles like a gender specific doctor. It could be all these things! Lovers talk makes me sad because it makes me think back to being public lovers with scum in Animal Crossing and everyone thought I was the scum but it was totally Franconp.
I don't really like either of the two players currently voting No Lynch, Nomadic Sparks and Poltergust. Poltergust for reasons stated earlier with the suspicious selfishness. Sparks because of the aggressive response to being voted for: http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=234315271&postcount=358 There being less than 15 minutes between the vote and the response makes it feel like a super genuine response to being voted for, which makes me think scum since they really don't want to be voted off. Town would be more chill. I can indeed put both of those off to new player jitters, but that's where I'm at.
Vote: Nomadic Sparks
The following paragraph is just possible role grousing and remembrance of game's past. It is fluff.
My initial inclination on the seeing the gender stuff was that'd it be a gender targeting Serial Killer like I was in the ill-fated Werewolf 1 game. In this game I'll just assume it is Death Note themed, because writing down names in anonymous PMs to kill people is too damn flavorful for it not to be that. It could also just be flavor, or be text that's there for tweaked versions of classic roles like a gender specific doctor. It could be all these things! Lovers talk makes me sad because it makes me think back to being public lovers with scum in Animal Crossing and everyone thought I was the scum but it was totally Franconp.
hey_monkey
Banned
That's a lot to catch up on. Suspicions in a lot of ways. I'm gonna play catchup and then change my vote away from the inactive, but where will it go? ། ﹒︣ ‸ ﹒︣ །
My gut feelings are... complicated right now. As a first-timer, doing this in text is difficult; there's a lot to process. Gonna pull some things out.
Dragonz-senpai, you've prodded a few people and given us some things to think about, but where do you stand?
Agreed - this seems possibly backwards. Dragonz made more noise after the (faux) cop claim than before, so how does this work?
I lean town on you because of some of the things you've said - and the way you've explained - but these aggressive-but-not-too moves I find puzzling. Cabot's response reads as a clear joke - why did you target in the first place?
For now... I'm suspicious on Poltergust but lean town. I think he's just newbing harder than he should be, but he's high on my watch list regardless. The next six hours or so are going to be big for a lot of people, I think.
My gut feelings are... complicated right now. As a first-timer, doing this in text is difficult; there's a lot to process. Gonna pull some things out.
Dragonz-senpai, you've prodded a few people and given us some things to think about, but where do you stand?
Agreed - this seems possibly backwards. Dragonz made more noise after the (faux) cop claim than before, so how does this work?
I lean town on you because of some of the things you've said - and the way you've explained - but these aggressive-but-not-too moves I find puzzling. Cabot's response reads as a clear joke - why did you target in the first place?
For now... I'm suspicious on Poltergust but lean town. I think he's just newbing harder than he should be, but he's high on my watch list regardless. The next six hours or so are going to be big for a lot of people, I think.
hey_monkey
Banned
The following paragraph is just possible role grousing and remembrance of game's past. It is fluff.
My initial inclination on the seeing the gender stuff was that'd it be a gender targeting Serial Killer like I was in the ill-fated Werewolf 1 game. In this game I'll just assume it is Death Note themed, because writing down names in anonymous PMs to kill people is too damn flavorful for it not to be that. It could also just be flavor, or be text that's there for tweaked versions of classic roles like a gender specific doctor. It could be all these things! Lovers talk makes me sad because it makes me think back to being public lovers with scum in Animal Crossing and everyone thought I was the scum but it was totally Franconp.
Oooh, that's interesting.
Which reminds me - I have a rules question I have to go ask.
Poltergust
Member
For what it's worth, I'm most likely not gonna end the day with my No Lynch vote still up. I just don't know who to go for now since we have nothing solid to go forward with.
I'll probably be gunning for one of the less active players, though. I'll need to parse over their post histories, but I don't see much of a reason to be so quiet so early on when everyone here is begging to have a discussion over anything of substance.
I'll probably be gunning for one of the less active players, though. I'll need to parse over their post histories, but I don't see much of a reason to be so quiet so early on when everyone here is begging to have a discussion over anything of substance.