-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Anime Mafia |OT| My Little Scum can't be this cute! ()
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
Nah, never happens! Never!
30yearsofhurt
Member
Hey, it's that talking owl.
Am I supposed to be ignoring him?
Am I supposed to be ignoring him?
oreomunsta
Banned
Awe, don't ruffle his feathers. He's a hoot
flatearthpandas
Member
I think it is okay to ignore Roy, if you want.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Uh, how, exactly
People have been asking me and I have been giving honest opinions. If you want to be a negative fucking Nancy, then fine. That's your business. But don't be fucking rude about it. You can do that shit alone, don't drag me into your cesspool of "fuck you guys, you're all stupid"
how? you persisted in believing a fake cop claim after he flipped vigi that's how.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Yeah and I've explained my shit multiple times and I stand by it
If you don't like it then that's cool, I don't really give a fuck. I'm playing the game and I'm not gonna be put off by your shit attitude.
30yearsofhurt
Member
So angry.
oreomunsta
Banned
30, I don't think I've heard a whole lot from you. Can you provide a read list, or at least some player opinions?
30yearsofhurt
Member
The only two I'm sus of left are Dragonz and Polt.
Maybe I don't like the look of Cabot but they have more to do with his avatar than anything he's said. Gorillaz is overrated.
Otherwise I'm clueless. Like the owl.
Maybe I don't like the look of Cabot but they have more to do with his avatar than anything he's said. Gorillaz is overrated.
Otherwise I'm clueless. Like the owl.
oreomunsta
Banned
flatearthpandas
Member
Whoa there.
Been listening to Humanz on loop for like a week now.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 5 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
oreomunsta (2)
TheExodu5 2283
BlackBuzzard 2339
WhereAreMahDragonz (2)
squidyj 2317 2386
Cewyn 2370 2394
squidyj 2386
30yearsofhurt 2388
Swamped (1)
cabot 2244
cabot (1)
Cewyn 2232 2257
Swamped 2242 2343
WhereAreMahDragonz 2250
Cewyn (0):squidyj 2236 2284
Kawl_USC (0):squidyj 2284 2317
30yearsofhurt (0):Cewyn 2281 2370
No active vote for Day 5: Cewyn (has previously voted), flatearthpandas, Kawl_USC, oreomunsta, Poltergust, rac, Swamped (has previously voted), ultron87
Day 5 Postcount: 30yearsofhurt 6, BlackBuzzard 11, cabot 36, Cewyn 18, flatearthpandas 6, Kawl_USC 10, oreomunsta 13, Poltergust 14, rac 4, squidyj 14, Swamped 18, TheExodu5 7, ultron87 2, WhereAreMahDragonz 19
Day 5 ends:
Automated vote tally here
8 votes for majority
oreomunsta (2)
TheExodu5 2283
BlackBuzzard 2339
WhereAreMahDragonz (2)
squidyj 2386
30yearsofhurt 2388
Swamped (1)
cabot 2244
cabot (1)
WhereAreMahDragonz 2250
Cewyn (0):
Kawl_USC (0):
30yearsofhurt (0):
No active vote for Day 5: Cewyn (has previously voted), flatearthpandas, Kawl_USC, oreomunsta, Poltergust, rac, Swamped (has previously voted), ultron87
Day 5 Postcount: 30yearsofhurt 6, BlackBuzzard 11, cabot 36, Cewyn 18, flatearthpandas 6, Kawl_USC 10, oreomunsta 13, Poltergust 14, rac 4, squidyj 14, Swamped 18, TheExodu5 7, ultron87 2, WhereAreMahDragonz 19
Day 5 ends:
Automated vote tally here
8 votes for majority
give me your reads on ultron and oreo
30yearsofhurt
Member
Oreo is a type of overrated biscuit.
no lies detected.
(I will leave now, please continue the murdering)
30yearsofhurt
Member
Okay. 25 words or less why? I still think Dragonz is the 'scummier'* bet.
*less sincere town act.
*less sincere town act.
Will be at a desktop this afternoon so expect more reads then. Just wanted to add that Dragonz is probably telling the truth. She alluded to being a "senpai" before, and there are many senpais in Host Club. Her most recent posts feel like town to me.
I'd like to know: who here does *not* scum read Ultron?
My own opinion is that i lean very slightly town on him. I do think it's a town PR, and the flavor makes sense with the role (this isn't a big deal though). But i also feel he has been on the sidelines of most of the important discussions, although I'll be giving him a reread this afternoon as well.
I'd like to know: who here does *not* scum read Ultron?
My own opinion is that i lean very slightly town on him. I do think it's a town PR, and the flavor makes sense with the role (this isn't a big deal though). But i also feel he has been on the sidelines of most of the important discussions, although I'll be giving him a reread this afternoon as well.
Oh so you do have a read on him.
He's done nothing to contribute to scumhunting and I have a problem with his claim and how it works.
Whats yours?
Here's what he said about his voting power after death:
We're nearing end-game now, and this is a thing. This is an incredibly dangerous power.
I still struggle to accept this being a game mechanic, because it's hiding information about a mechanical system like voting. It's not the same as other parts of the game, a very recent example was Cewyn bluffing about a double vote and Bear instantly calling that out as a lie. This doesn't feel in tune with how I expect the rules of the game.
But hey, we lynch him he still gets to use it right?
He gets his power, and I get really annoyed with Bear if it works as advertised, because we have one vote we can't track at all in a crucial point in the game.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
He is way too busy thinking what waifu to recruit tonight.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Part 2
08. [m] Bowlie - GMT-3 --> [m] flatearthpandas Solid read list hasn't really said too much could have to do with being a day 2 sub-Slight town
11. [m] ultron87 - EST Has been too silent since role claiming on Day 1.-Slight scum
12. [m] cabot - GMT+1 Has been poking and giving reads list since day, only thing that makes me read him as scum is that they haven't NK'd him yet 1.-Town
15. [m] Cewyn - EST Still a bit of an enigma to me one of the more quiet early day players now starting to contribute more -Null
16. [m] BlackBuzzard - CET ME!
18. [m] squidyj - MST Aggressive player just seems straight forward havent really caught anything that stands out -town
PART 3 will probably be tonight.
08. [m] Bowlie - GMT-3 --> [m] flatearthpandas Solid read list hasn't really said too much could have to do with being a day 2 sub-Slight town
11. [m] ultron87 - EST Has been too silent since role claiming on Day 1.-Slight scum
12. [m] cabot - GMT+1 Has been poking and giving reads list since day, only thing that makes me read him as scum is that they haven't NK'd him yet 1.-Town
15. [m] Cewyn - EST Still a bit of an enigma to me one of the more quiet early day players now starting to contribute more -Null
16. [m] BlackBuzzard - CET ME!
18. [m] squidyj - MST Aggressive player just seems straight forward havent really caught anything that stands out -town
PART 3 will probably be tonight.
30yearsofhurt
Member
Yes, I was playing Persoma 5. I'm on NG+. I think I'll romance them all.
Sorry, but that's how it works.
Look, I fully admit I'm not playing the best that I could be. You shouldn't kill me for that.
We should get rid of Squidy. The Dusk sideshow distracted us all from the fact that he's been going after people for reasons that are specious at best, and he was the still living player that was at risk during the Monkey bandwagon from nowhere.
Vote: squidyj
Interesting choice, but anyway.
My play was to catch out 30, who I suspect was neutral.
I asked him what his reads were of oreo and ultron, the two people who claimed they were harem'd.
He gave me a useless response:
I then asked him to vote ultron with me, who admittedly I scumread, but this was about the harem'd target.
He gives me more of a response than when he did when I directly asked him for a read.
I respond with my reason:
He doesn't respond to me, but when BB makes a joke about him choosing his next harem target, he responds:
I've given him a few more hours to respond to me directly, but nothing.
I am 85% sure 30 is our neutral harem maker.
The question is, what do we do with him?
Personally, I'm not much for Exo's plan of 'lets make him win and eliminate my scumreads' because, well, we fucking had Dusk pull that shit and it was a nightmare.
UNVOTE
thoughts?
BlackBuzzard
Banned
I think he gave it away on day 1 where he said there is probably a harem mechanic he was the first to even bring this up.
Yeah, i saw that post, and thought the same. Being like any solid investigator though, I wanted more evidence.
I think today has favoured the theory he is neutral more than anything else.
Poltergust
Member
To back that up, 30 has never voted for the people who claimed they were in a harem, and he kept his No Lynch vote to the end of the day on Day 1.
The longer the game goes on, the likelier he would be able to find enough people to satisfy his win condition.
The longer the game goes on, the likelier he would be able to find enough people to satisfy his win condition.
do you scumread squidy more than Dragonz?
oreomunsta
Banned
You guys are making a convincing argument for 30 being the harem king, to which he hasn't properly addressed
The question is, though, if his role is Town or neutral. We've lost a lot of town people, so getting rid of another isn't in our best interests, but then again, he's got Ultron and me tied up and possibly ready to go at the end of day :<
The question is, though, if his role is Town or neutral. We've lost a lot of town people, so getting rid of another isn't in our best interests, but then again, he's got Ultron and me tied up and possibly ready to go at the end of day :<
Poltergust
Member
Actually, this is really interesting. Let's assume ultron is telling the truth about his role. That would mean that this is a harem of females. That means that whoever is creating it failed on two nights, either due to finding males or because his target died.
Something I've noticed is that almost every townsperson who has died so far is female, the only exception so far being Palmer. I dunno if it is just luck, but this indicates to me that the vast majority of townspeople are indeed female.
Which means that, if the harem maker knows who he targeted and failed (yet that person is still alive), that can be very valuable information to the town. If the majority of townspeople are female, why couldn't the majority of scum be male?
The problem here is extracting that information. If we can properly target the harem maker and force him to cough up info in exchange for keeping him alive, we could learn a lot.
Something I've noticed is that almost every townsperson who has died so far is female, the only exception so far being Palmer. I dunno if it is just luck, but this indicates to me that the vast majority of townspeople are indeed female.
Which means that, if the harem maker knows who he targeted and failed (yet that person is still alive), that can be very valuable information to the town. If the majority of townspeople are female, why couldn't the majority of scum be male?
The problem here is extracting that information. If we can properly target the harem maker and force him to cough up info in exchange for keeping him alive, we could learn a lot.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Yeah well we are not getting much out of him atm. He has generally seemed uninterested in what's going on in town only coming into vote and make sure he has enough posts.
oreomunsta
Banned
Polter, interesting take on the harem mechanic and what that could imply for the whole game.
As much as I'd love to hop on to your conclusion that "female heavily implies town", I'm not quite sure that that information is there. If there's a rough 50/50 split on genders in the game, then this outcome that we're experiencing falls within probability
As much as I'd love to hop on to your conclusion that "female heavily implies town", I'm not quite sure that that information is there. If there's a rough 50/50 split on genders in the game, then this outcome that we're experiencing falls within probability
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
There is no way a role like this is town
BlackBuzzard
Banned
yeah i dont think its town at all. As harem master you have the obligation not to care about good and evil.
Poltergust
Member
Technically, any possible outcome falls into any probability.
But I'm going to use math here to calculate the chance of our 8 dead townspeople having a distribution of 6 females and 1 male (gonna ignore SkyOdin since he's a special case).
We have 2^7, or 128, possibilities for gender distributions. Out of those, only 7 possibilities would fall into that distribution of 6 female/1 male:
Male, Female, Female, Female, Female, Female, Female
Female, Male, Female, Female, Female, Female, Female
Female, Female, Male, Female, Female, Female, Female
Female, Female, Female, Male, Female, Female, Female <-- What we got, by the way.
Female, Female, Female, Female, Male, Female, Female
Female, Female, Female, Female, Female, Male, Female
Female, Female, Female, Female, Female, Female, Male
A 7/128 chance translates to 5.46%. If the distribution among town members really is 50/50, that's the percentage we got.
So it makes no logical sense to assume that there really is a 50/50 distribution, especially considering the small player base.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
They're both up there, but yeah I think so. Also Squidy would give more info if he were to flip scum.
Poltergust
Member
Well, you wanted to find the harem maker, right? I'm just providing the rest of the town the reason as to why this is so important. =P
Poltergust
Member
With all that said, I'm willing to run along with cabot's theory.
Vote: 30yearsofhurt
Vote: 30yearsofhurt