-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Anime Mafia |OT| My Little Scum can't be this cute! ()
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
flatearthpandas
Member
Don't really see a point in a mass claim right now. At the very least, I want everyone to agree to a mass claim before we kick it off. So no more random ones, please and thanks.
Town:
squid
kawl
cabot
buzzard
dragonz
null+:
exodus
null-:
oreo
Scum:
polter
rac
cewyn
Even though oreo more than likely was telling the truth yesterday, there's still something about his claiming the harem that just rubs me wrong. And there's basically nothing from him that has rubbed me right. So he gets the null-.
Polter is probably the person whose posts seem the least scummy to me but the votes look bad for him. I think this is most likely and have gone into it before today.
rac and cewyn don't need too much explanation. But at the same time, I have doubts they would both be on the same scum team playing the same quiet yet strange scum game. I could see dragonz's explanation for rac and polter being on the same team. At the same time, while I'm convinced dragonz is town, I would probably rather draw names from a hat than trust her reads this game. This one does happen to fit with my thoughts. But that would leave rac as probably town. I suppose that would put cabot as next in line for scum. Cabot I don't really feel scummy at all on though. He's been pretty consistent and I see logic there. I would put exo or buzzard as next most likely.
squid i've seen scum in the later part of a game just once I think, in ace attorney. He is a different squid than then, although he was carrying a lot of heat that game. I know he's rubbed a few players a bit wrong this game, as he did me that game when I was vanilla town, but it wasn't his tone. In that game I felt he targeted me and tunneled and then withdrew into himself as we closed in on him. This game he has tunneled a bit, but he's changed with new info, kept active on keeping conversation useful for the whole game. As I type this out though, I feel like I do need to give him more scrutiny.
But as we draw near mylo, I'd rather clear out the most likely before speculating too much on people I'm reading as town. Keeping my eye on accusations and rereading in the meantime.But polter seems it.
Town:
squid
kawl
cabot
buzzard
dragonz
null+:
exodus
null-:
oreo
Scum:
polter
rac
cewyn
Even though oreo more than likely was telling the truth yesterday, there's still something about his claiming the harem that just rubs me wrong. And there's basically nothing from him that has rubbed me right. So he gets the null-.
Polter is probably the person whose posts seem the least scummy to me but the votes look bad for him. I think this is most likely and have gone into it before today.
rac and cewyn don't need too much explanation. But at the same time, I have doubts they would both be on the same scum team playing the same quiet yet strange scum game. I could see dragonz's explanation for rac and polter being on the same team. At the same time, while I'm convinced dragonz is town, I would probably rather draw names from a hat than trust her reads this game. This one does happen to fit with my thoughts. But that would leave rac as probably town. I suppose that would put cabot as next in line for scum. Cabot I don't really feel scummy at all on though. He's been pretty consistent and I see logic there. I would put exo or buzzard as next most likely.
squid i've seen scum in the later part of a game just once I think, in ace attorney. He is a different squid than then, although he was carrying a lot of heat that game. I know he's rubbed a few players a bit wrong this game, as he did me that game when I was vanilla town, but it wasn't his tone. In that game I felt he targeted me and tunneled and then withdrew into himself as we closed in on him. This game he has tunneled a bit, but he's changed with new info, kept active on keeping conversation useful for the whole game. As I type this out though, I feel like I do need to give him more scrutiny.
But as we draw near mylo, I'd rather clear out the most likely before speculating too much on people I'm reading as town. Keeping my eye on accusations and rereading in the meantime.But polter seems it.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 6 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
rac (3)
Cewyn 2707
TheExodu5 2711
Kawl_USC 2743
WhereAreMahDragonz (2)
cabot 2615
squidyj 2657
Poltergust (1)
flatearthpandas 2631
oreomunsta (1)
WhereAreMahDragonz 2644
Kawl_USC 2652 2743
cabot (1)
squidyj 2599 2657
TheExodu5 2605 2711
rac 2723
No active vote for Day 6: BlackBuzzard, oreomunsta, Poltergust
Day 6 Postcount: BlackBuzzard 8, cabot 43, Cewyn 9, flatearthpandas 7, Kawl_USC 36, oreomunsta 17, Poltergust 17, rac 15, squidyj 7, TheExodu5 23, WhereAreMahDragonz 13
Day 6 ends:
Automated vote tally here
6 votes for majority
rac (3)
Cewyn 2707
TheExodu5 2711
Kawl_USC 2743
WhereAreMahDragonz (2)
cabot 2615
squidyj 2657
Poltergust (1)
flatearthpandas 2631
oreomunsta (1)
WhereAreMahDragonz 2644
cabot (1)
rac 2723
No active vote for Day 6: BlackBuzzard, oreomunsta, Poltergust
Day 6 Postcount: BlackBuzzard 8, cabot 43, Cewyn 9, flatearthpandas 7, Kawl_USC 36, oreomunsta 17, Poltergust 17, rac 15, squidyj 7, TheExodu5 23, WhereAreMahDragonz 13
Day 6 ends:
Automated vote tally here
6 votes for majority
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Would scum Cewyn put down first vote on scum buddy Rac tho?
Yes, I would totally throw my scum team under the bus like in the last game where I was scum.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Yes, I would totally throw my scum team under the bus like in the last game where I was scum.
Hey i did too but he burned himself hard.
flatearthpandas
Member
Makes me feel better.
Maybe? Like I said, I have some don't that these two would actually be on the same team though i read them both pretty scummy individually
flatearthpandas
Member
Doubt, that is
Poltergust
Member
Wouldn't that mean that there's like a 3-way bussing thing going on? That seems highly risky for the Mafia.
flatearthpandas
Member
Yes
Wait, NO
no
NOYes
But seriously, no.
Only two are even up for vote. Real bus needs real votes and real end of day votes. Talk is cheap unless you're really trying to convince us and no one has been doing a great job of that this game since everyone has been so keen to just build cases against themselves so far.
sure, cewyn probably determines his plays by throwing darts.
I offered you a damn bed, loser.
flatearthpandas
Member
Now we're going places. Or didn't
BlackBuzzard
Banned
All of Racs post feel fake to me, from his voting pattern to just his posts and reads, he is also piggy backing a lot on other peoples theory's.
Is that where your vote is going?
BlackBuzzard
Banned
I still wanna look through Cewyns posts.
Poltergust
Member
My top 3 lynch picks for today are rac, Cewyn, and Exodus, but I'm having a hard time deciding between them.
For rac, the case has been laid pretty clear against him, but I'm concerned over the fact that my other top scum picks have both voted for him.
For Cewyn, he's been dodgy all game and that fake attempt at a double vote is suspicious as hell. I'm not convinced it was done in jest as double votes are typically a town role (based on my research, anyways).
And for Exodus, I doubt his sincerity in trying to root out scum. He's made a few long posts, but his points are really weak and sometimes self-contradictory.
I'm positive at least one of these guys are scum, but I need a little more time before I can come to a conclusion.
For rac, the case has been laid pretty clear against him, but I'm concerned over the fact that my other top scum picks have both voted for him.
For Cewyn, he's been dodgy all game and that fake attempt at a double vote is suspicious as hell. I'm not convinced it was done in jest as double votes are typically a town role (based on my research, anyways).
And for Exodus, I doubt his sincerity in trying to root out scum. He's made a few long posts, but his points are really weak and sometimes self-contradictory.
I'm positive at least one of these guys are scum, but I need a little more time before I can come to a conclusion.
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
Green
Poltergust
Member
BlackBuzzard
Banned
About Dragonz her claim seems real flavor text seems in line with everything thats been posted and my own, further more she gave us everything not just a vague claim like Kyan or Dusk did.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
I dont like that Cewyn wanted to role claim a day before lylo to be fair i thought it was already that day, but it was started off with a vague role claim feels scummy to me. Otherwsie Cewyn has not ever given us a reads list.
oreomunsta
Banned
Vote: Cewyn
I've got meetings over the next few hours, so I'll do my best to stay part of the conversation, but wanted to cast my vote now.
Cewyn has been a very strange player to me all game. Rac has gotten pretty weird over the past few days, but Cewyn has been scummy question mark for me.
Cewyn, you play very close to your chest, and opportunistically. At this stage in the game, that reads scum to me :/
I've got meetings over the next few hours, so I'll do my best to stay part of the conversation, but wanted to cast my vote now.
Cewyn has been a very strange player to me all game. Rac has gotten pretty weird over the past few days, but Cewyn has been scummy question mark for me.
Cewyn, you play very close to your chest, and opportunistically. At this stage in the game, that reads scum to me :/
Poltergust
Member
OK, I've decided on Exodus. This is more of a gut read than anything, but this is no time to be wishy-washy. I just feel that the way he's been playing up until now just... isn't right.
Vote: TheExodu5
Vote: TheExodu5
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Fair point.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Zubz
Nomadic
Odin
Monkey
Blargo(Scum)
Kyanrute
Palmer
Dusk
Hatmoza
Swamped(neutral)
Ultron
Now look at the difference with Dragonz
Dragonz
I see nothing witty or funny about this flavor text i know my flavor text has some kind of witty funny line.
Nomadic
Odin
Monkey
Blargo(Scum)
Kyanrute
Palmer
Dusk
Hatmoza
Swamped(neutral)
Ultron
Now look at the difference with Dragonz
Dragonz
I see nothing witty or funny about this flavor text i know my flavor text has some kind of witty funny line.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Vote:WhereAreMahDragonz
Claiming before mylo or lylo is fairly useless cause we cant take the claim at face value. If you claim where there's no day phase left, you can accept the claim is either fully truthful or a scum lie, when it is before mylo/lylo threre is a reason to lie. I am not claiming at this point, and I will not be around at deadline, so hopefully dragonz is scum.
Poltergust
Member
Great, we're in a tie situation again...
I'm not sure how to proceed from here. rac is one of my top scum picks but two other scum members have voted for him, and Dragonz is still a mystery to me but has people voting for her that I have more favorable opinions of.
I'm not sure how to proceed from here. rac is one of my top scum picks but two other scum members have voted for him, and Dragonz is still a mystery to me but has people voting for her that I have more favorable opinions of.
flatearthpandas
Member
Dragonz and rac tied at 3 it looks like?
How are we feeling about this?
How are we feeling about this?
BlackBuzzard
Banned
I am staying on Dragonz.
flatearthpandas
Member
Remember we can't post our actual role PM. She could still have a joke.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
yes not the entire thing but the thing that makes it look genuine is missing hmmm that seems strange.
Poltergust
Member
Ugh, I've got the flu.
Keep in mind Ultron. His vote counts today.
Sure, but there is no reason for scum to pile on to one of the candidates and nullify his vote.
If we remain at a tie situation in 20 minutes I'd be surprised.
I certainly find it interesting that oreo and Polter are coming after myself and Cewyn. Makes me feel comfortable about my read of the situation.
We now have likely scum votes on myself, Cewyn, and Dragonz. Scum are just trying to see what takes at this point. Expect a shift of votes real soon.
Ultron, do us proud!
We now have likely scum votes on myself, Cewyn, and Dragonz. Scum are just trying to see what takes at this point. Expect a shift of votes real soon.
Ultron, do us proud!
flatearthpandas
Member
Doesn't really seem like anyone is here for the most part. After I got up early and everything.
Here's what I believe:
We have no more neutrals.
We have 4-5 more scum.
If it's 5, we are currently in mylo.
Probably it's 4 but I don't want to risk it.
I won't say why I know, but we don't want to lynch Dragonz. We don't want to lynch Kawl.
Squid and Oreo are indeed female.
Vote: rac
Here's what I believe:
We have no more neutrals.
We have 4-5 more scum.
If it's 5, we are currently in mylo.
Probably it's 4 but I don't want to risk it.
I won't say why I know, but we don't want to lynch Dragonz. We don't want to lynch Kawl.
Squid and Oreo are indeed female.
Vote: rac
WhereAreMahDragonz
Banned
I'm town and BB's argument is flimsy and laughable, honestly. I obviously cannot quote exactly but I did claim flavor as best as I could with the major points of my role. To base a vote on the fact that there's no humor is the stupidest thing I've heard in this game yet
Obviously i don't want to die and I have a null read of rac so
Vote: Rac
Obviously i don't want to die and I have a null read of rac so
Vote: Rac