Fate/Apocrypha (2017)
Fate/Apocrypha is a light novel written by Yuuichiro Higashide, based on the discarded scenario for a video game in the Fate franchise. The game was later rebooted in concept multiple times, and eventually what the world got was Fate/Grand Order. Kinoko Nasu wrote the original scenario but Higashide was not only the author of the LN but also the script writer for this anime. The production was handled by Aniplex’s internal studio A-1 Pictures.
I’m going to be blunt here, if you’re expecting me to shit on Apocrypha like many in the fanbase do, then you can stop reading here because I’m not going to do it. I’ll start with the obvious: Apocrypha is a big dumb shounen story where the most inane and ridiculous stuff inexplicably happens because Higashide thought it would be cool and the main protagonist suffers from an agonizing and terminal bout of video game player character self-insert syndrome. It’s also insane amounts of fun, has a fundamentally strong story with an emotionally resonant core, and has as much fighting animated as the budget would allow, which ends up being a surprising amount considering this one probably was budgeted at a fraction of whatever the ufotable entries got.
The numerous Servants of Apocrypha have been adapted to look like their artwork in FGO, a necessity because of the massive success of FGO between when the LN was published and when this anime premiered. That said, they all are given character development and motives which are absent from their FGO incarnations. The pace of the anime has to move fast and it does, because there’s a lot of characters and a series of storylines which need to be covered under the greater story arc. There are numerous cameo appearances from characters who figure in the original F/SN timeline but if you didn’t know who they were, it wouldn’t affect your understanding of the main story.
The main story, involves a plan to merge all humans into a blob called the Human Instrumentality Proj- wait. That’s not it. The main story involves magical creatures called Pokemon beating the shit out of each other to be the stronges- wait. That’s not it either. The main story involves a puppet named Pinocchio who goes on a journey to discover what it means to become huma- wait. That’s definitely not it. Alright fine, jokes aside, the main story of Apocrypha is painfully derivative of almost every other story ever written before it, but that’s kind of the point. It was based on a canceled video game script, remember? The story is intentionally simplistic and derivative at its core because you were supposed to be Sieg in the game and doing all the stuff Sieg does and it would be like fucking epic and shit. Probably.
Sigh. I need to give a paragraph to Sieg. The complaints aimed at Sieg are a direct result of Apocrypha’s origin story. He just kind of does things which are otherwise impossible in every other corner of the Fate universe because wouldn’t it be cool if you could do that in the video game? It’s really dumb, but quite frankly by the end you won’t really care because Fate is a franchise which is fundamentally built around two founding principles: grimdark and “The Rule of Cool”. So, at some point you get something like Apocrypha which takes these two things and just feeds them steroids until they literally turn into a dragon and fly off into the sunset because why the fuck not. The fact that Sieg exhibits no sign of any personal motivations to do anything he does beyond “I feel like it and I’m the protagonist” is an example of main video game character syndrome and Higashide doesn’t pretend it’s otherwise when writing this story. Higashide straight up gets a huge measure of respect for his zero fucks given attitude towards Sieg as far as I’m concerned.
Anyways, Sieg himself isn’t a particularly strong main character, but he’s surrounded by a vast cast of really enjoyable human and Servant supporting characters. Again, because of the amount of material to be covered and the large number of different characters, there isn’t a lot of time to delve into each one. This is kind of too bad, because I would have liked to have spent more time with all the other characters. The show is 25 episodes and kind of flies along and at the end you’re surprised it’s already over. That’s a good sign for any TV series when the hours are melting away and you’re still watching and enjoying yourself.
I think ultimately Apocrypha boils down to this: You’ll leave wondering what the hell just happened but also thinking damn that was a lot of fun and I don’t even know why. A bunch of fights happen and super powered people beat the fuck out of each other, something about the nature of humanity or whatever, somehow it actually relates to the rest of the Fate universe in the most ridiculous ways imaginable, and you feel like you had a good time. If you are already a fan of Fate, and especially if you have played FGO, you’ll like seeing all the Servants in their original story and you’ll get to see original Gordes Musik Yggdmillennia. This is of course Goredolf Musik in FGO as he’s carried over almost as-is from the Apocrypha timeline to FGO.
Fate likes to pretend it’s some deep and philosophical work of art, mainly due to Nasu’s pretensions in the main F/SN timeline, but really, it’s quite silly and I think everyone knows it and just goes with it. But I mean that’s how Shakespeare was too in his day, dude just wrote shit he thought his audience would like and today we all act like he was some literary playwright genius when he was just writing shit he thought was cool. I’m only mentioning this because Shakespeare is literally a Caster Servant in Apocrypha. Yeah, that shit wasn’t made up just for FGO. He was in Apocrypha first. Also, Yggdmillennia is a ridiculous yet awesome name for a family, I’m just saying.
Final Rating: Great Big Fucking Massively Engorged Holy Grail War/10