Just for you Matty, I went back to look at Retroid's posts (he was replaced by NF) and found this from confirmed scum Kyan:
Let us begin with the feelings list:
Townies:
Dusk Soldier - Cleared by Crab and I cant see why there would be a Godfather in a game with a 1 shot cop.
nin1000 - A feeling based on his cooperative though tad cryptic behavior.
Mazre - Bit of a soft read, Catvoca did not ring any bells and neither does Mazre so far. The vote record past day one is bit iffy though.
Gorlak - His suspicion towards Crab seemed like towny suspicion. Up until now, scum have been playing somewhat conservatively, going for safe kills. Were Gorlak scum, his behavior towards Crab wouldve been very daring indeed, considering that when Crab or Dusk Soldier would be flipped, the other would instantly gain #townpoints, thus making Gorlak look bad.
timetokill - His information or scum will clear him for us.
Curiously, all townies here.
Scummies:
batsnacks - A feel and his vote record put him here. #scumpoints for d1 vote. He bussed dragonz too but that can be used against many.
SalvaPot - Scum or ordinary town trolling for lols. Final votes on townies and Gorlak. Entertained No Lynch on d1 but I think it is impossible to tell how serious this was.
Retroid - No Lynch, townie, nothing. Hardly any contributions. Competes with MattyG for the scum inactive trophy.
Zeemumu - Bad vote record, strange reasons for voting Ouro and ttk.
Hyperactivity - He too gets #scumpoints for the d1 vote. #2137 looks bad in hindsight. He argued openly for conservative scum play (what feel is true), could this be him trying to establish a cover for himself, since hes been rather active?
bats was lost partner so he couldn't know.
Retroid is here, but lumped in with Matty for some reason. Other townies and the neutral in this list.
Unknownies:
MattyG - Townie, nothing, a late vote on dragonz. Lean more towards scum but would like to flip Retroid first because I think it is more likely only one of them is scum.
Timeaisis - Not feeling bad about him but his vote record aint all rosy.
tomakasatnav - No feels, votes meh.
Lone_Prodigy - No feels, votes not that good.
Barrylocke - No feels, votes here and there.
All town here with a reference to Matty as well.
I see at least two ways to proceed with the vote. The first is Gorlaks day one vote list, bats, myself and Hyper. Since dragonz almost died on day one, it is fair to assume that scum wouldve tried to prevent that with more than one person. Here, the most suspicious in my opinion is Hyper with his last minute vote.
The second way is to look at the weird fuckery that was Ouros lynch. As bats so eloquently puts it in #1943, the various reasons that people came up with were strange. Here the candidates are (excluding Dusk Town Soldier and ttk) Zeemumu, Retroid, Barrylocke and Salvapot. Interestingly enough, some of the less active members made this list and I imagine there is scum here too. Quick scroll through the posts tells me that none of the included people did explain their vote on Ouro on day three when asked.
His top suspects for the day (this is the Hyper/CB vs. Gorlak day).
He throws Retroid and Matty in the "so inactive I can't get a read on them" camp.
Remember that late in the day Retroid comes in and just votes for Gorlak. Matty also votes Gorlak. Kyan votes CB, which is to be expected since he suspected him.
I really can't draw any conclusions from this because calling someone scummy for being inactive is not wrong.
NF's activity on the Kyan day:
-comes in, puts Kyan in town camp, puts Matty in inactive camp (along with tomkat and zeemumu)
-next post, analyzes Mazre. Kyan sits at 3 votes. I vote Kyan. Matty votes Kyan. Kyan claims.
-next post, votes Kyan, putting him one away from hammer.
Sure, things changed fast, but he could've voted earlier or at least address the "why Kyan" question.
:origin()/pre13/3a01/th/pre/i/2006/255/a/c/vegeta_having_a_laugh_by_bulmaxvegeta.jpg)
