The major problem I had with BG3 is that it incentivizes you to play "the right way," ie as a hero. If you try to play any other way, you're just locking yourself out of quests and good loot. This isn't the case with W3, with how morally grey most quests are written, it makes the impact of player choices and narrative that much stronger as a result.
For many games people collectively hype themselves into and then they linger on enshrined in a nostalgia bubble. This why you have people outside of that bubble play the game and come to their own conclusions and the people in the bubble get really angry to defend it. This still happens with even some of my own personal favorite games from when I was a teenager. I only take people's gaming opinions seriously now if they are capable of admiting flaws of what they like and are able to justify why they like certain mechanics beyond making games fun for themselves just because they are hyped to play them.I'm very surprised that The Witcher 3 is winning the vote, very surprised indeed.
For many games people collectively hype themselves into and then they linger on enshrined in a nostalgia bubble. This why you have people outside of that bubble play the game and come to their own conclusions and the people in the bubble get really angry to defend it. This still happens with even some of my own personal favorite games from when I was a teenager. I only take people's gaming opinions seriously now if they are capable of admiting flaws of what they like and are able to justify why they like certain mechanics beyond making games fun for themselves just because they are hyped to play them.
The poll should've been "which game you enjoy more?"I voted for BG3 but not really surprised to see Witcher 3 winning here. I loved both games myself, but I'm a big fan of Larian on their gameplay mechanics so BG3 got my vote. Folks can simply disagree....no worries. Don't think they need to justify it either way. If a couple of folks want to debate it then that's fine too. But ultimately, it comes down to opinions. Some can get far too heated just because someone else has a different view on a game.
The poll should've been "which game you enjoy more?"
BG3 and it isn't even close.
Witcher 3, no question.
Witcher 3 by a country mile. The music, the characters, the atmosphere, the lore... BG3 feels like a slapdash cartoon. There is nothing holding that world together. There is no charm or soul. The Witcher 3 is the greatest game ever and I don't even really like the gameplay. That is how much more of a sum of its parts it is. It is a triumph.
I completed act 1 in BG3 and haven't gone back. Meanwhile I've played and beaten W3 on the PS4, XboneX, PC, Switch and repurchased on the PS5.
when we talk about the pacing witcher 3 isnt a whole lot better ...Witcher 3.
BG3s pacing is slow as molasses.
BG3 has no charm? are you seriousWitcher 3 by a country mile. The music, the characters, the atmosphere, the lore... BG3 feels like a slapdash cartoon. There is nothing holding that world together. There is no charm or soul. The Witcher 3 is the greatest game ever and I don't even really like the gameplay. That is how much more of a sum of its parts it is. It is a triumph.
Entirely.BG3 has no charm? are you serious
BG3 is joke against TW3
But obviously Dark Souls is the superior game….Theyre different games. Its like comparing Persona 5 to Dark Souls, only because they both are rpgs. Ridiculous. Both are amazing in their own way. There is nothing to compare.
Penetration ofc. The woman gets no pleasure from a bj.Blowjobs or penetration?
Theyre different games. Its like comparing Persona 5 to Dark Souls, only because they both are rpgs. Ridiculous. Both are amazing in their own way. There is nothing to compare.
One can say which RPG approach they like better. Or like your example stay clear of both because A is too long and B makes you waste too much time getting gud.Theyre different games. Its like comparing Persona 5 to Dark Souls, only because they both are rpgs. Ridiculous. Both are amazing in their own way. There is nothing to compare.
No?BG3 has turn based combat, so loses regardless of the game you pair it with that doesn't.
So easy to rattle folks cages on this forumNo?
What's this idiotic NONSENSE?
BG3 was so not for me. I read the reviews, listened to the hype, saw the awards, and eventually jumped in and played 25 hours and dropped it and want my hours back. Incredibly slow game. Super clunky. Can't do anything without fiddling with icons and menus. I literally fell asleep while doing a fight. It's just not for me.
On the other hand, haven't finished The Witcher 3 either but I genuinely enjoyed what I played and should actually go play it instead of talking about it. Thanks OP for bringing it up!
Penetration ofc. The woman gets no pleasure from a bj.
Not close for me. Witcher 3.
if you had asked me as a teenager with all the time in the world though, easily BG3.
BG3 and its not even close for me.
Witcher 3 combat is trash in my opinion, you know that thing the gameplay rides.