I went in to talk saddles today. They did a full refit first and wound up raising the seatpost, leveling out the saddle and pulling it forward. No idea why is was so screwed up during the original fitting.
The guy measured my butt, and from a Specialized standpoint I should have a 155mm seat in the "black" saddles
(which I believe are the more race-oriented) and a 143mm in the "red" saddles
(which are the more recreational). I currently have a 143mm Phenom Comp GT, which is a "black" saddle, so theoretically too small. However, since we made so many adjustments the guy suggested doing some rides first before I drop more cash.
I took a ride this evening and while I think my numbness issues have gone way down, I'm still feeling my bones digging in, so I'll take another ride tomorrow but will likely go in next week for new saddle.
I can get the larger Phenom, which is a $100 saddle, but the guy actually picked out the 143mm Toupe Sport (a "red" saddle) which is $35. It's 100 grams heavier, but are there other big advantages to the more expensive saddle? I actually don't mind paying the extra money if there is good reason. I mostly want to get the saddle that's going to be most comfortable for me.
A little followup - if my butt is sensitive and I will be doing longer rides, is there a downside to getting a model like this?
https://www.specialized.com/us/en/117434
Some of the saddles are for racing or aero position, but for some of the other saddles it's difficult to tell what the purpose is for one vs. another.
Edit: also, it looks like the "black" and "red" don't have to do with ride type, it's just a weird design thing.