-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Bloodborne |Mafia OT| The Night Brims With Defiled Scum
- Thread starter ScraftyDevil
- Start date
shoulda downloaded the patch
TheWorthyEdge
Member
ScraftyDevil
Banned
The townspeople filed into the streets for the nightly Hunt, but something felt different.
"Does the blood moon seem lower than usual tonight?"
"Well, it did seem to get dark a lot later than last night..."
"Must be daylight savings. Lousy farmers..."
One they had finished their quibbling, the townspeople's attention was drawn towards two corpses.
Much to their surprise, they were met not with human cadavers, but with monstrous, hulking carcasses which both bore signs of a struggle.
The being once known as Flatearthpandas lay on top, fur crackling with electricity and a gigantic fracture in its skull which oozed a dark sanguine liquid.
The being once known as TheWorthyEdge lay beneath, the once-pious man's robes tattered and torn by the process of his transformation. The beast clutched in its hand a pendant; the last vestiges of its humanity and one of the scant reminders that this brute once seemed an innocuous townsperson.
Flatearthpandas and TheWorthyEdge have been slaughtered.
(Thousand pardons for the late start; a major traffic accident caused me to arrive home a full two hours later than anticipated.)
Day 5 begins.
The Blood still flows within:
01 [m] II-Vanguard-II - New
02 [m]Verelios - New
03 [-]Nudull - New
04 [m] MickD - New
05 [m]TheWorthyEdge
06 [m] Camjo-Z
07 [m]Kristoffer
08 [m] Freakinchair
09 [m]Ri'Orius
10 [m]Haly
11 [m] MagnumBoy20xx
12 [m]flatearthpandas
13 [m]EzekelRAGE
14 [m] Flame_AC
15 [m] CrimsonFist
16 [m] johnnyquicknives
17 [m]Never Forever
18 [-] Seath
19 [m]Mazre
20 [m]Palmer_v1
21 [m] roytheone
22 [m] squidyj
23 [m] Zippedpinhead
24 [m] Kalor
From now on, day phases shall last 72 hours and night phases shall last 48.
The Blood Moon rises in:
"Does the blood moon seem lower than usual tonight?"
"Well, it did seem to get dark a lot later than last night..."
"Must be daylight savings. Lousy farmers..."
One they had finished their quibbling, the townspeople's attention was drawn towards two corpses.
Much to their surprise, they were met not with human cadavers, but with monstrous, hulking carcasses which both bore signs of a struggle.
The being once known as Flatearthpandas lay on top, fur crackling with electricity and a gigantic fracture in its skull which oozed a dark sanguine liquid.
The being once known as TheWorthyEdge lay beneath, the once-pious man's robes tattered and torn by the process of his transformation. The beast clutched in its hand a pendant; the last vestiges of its humanity and one of the scant reminders that this brute once seemed an innocuous townsperson.
Flatearthpandas and TheWorthyEdge have been slaughtered.
(Thousand pardons for the late start; a major traffic accident caused me to arrive home a full two hours later than anticipated.)
Day 5 begins.
The Blood still flows within:
01 [m] II-Vanguard-II - New
02 [m]
03 [-]
04 [m] MickD - New
05 [m]
06 [m] Camjo-Z
07 [m]
08 [m] Freakinchair
09 [m]
10 [m]
11 [m] MagnumBoy20xx
12 [m]
13 [m]
14 [m] Flame_AC
15 [m] CrimsonFist
16 [m] johnnyquicknives
17 [m]
18 [-] Seath
19 [m]
20 [m]
21 [m] roytheone
22 [m] squidyj
23 [m] Zippedpinhead
24 [m] Kalor
From now on, day phases shall last 72 hours and night phases shall last 48.
The Blood Moon rises in:
So FEP was a veteran. That explains why they told people not to visit them. I assume the vagueness was to attempt to draw mafia and it might have worked, unless FreakinChair targeted TWE / Weemad.
Kristoffer's role explains why he was going after Verelios so heavily. It would be worth looking at his other "suspects" and see who pops up a lot. He probably thought that Verelios would be the most likely to be lynched so he went after him.
Kristoffer's role explains why he was going after Verelios so heavily. It would be worth looking at his other "suspects" and see who pops up a lot. He probably thought that Verelios would be the most likely to be lynched so he went after him.
TheWorthyEdge
Member
Well that was short lived!
CrimsonFist
Member
So we have a claimed tracker, a claimed doctor and a claimed vig, and yet the suspicious role claims died.
I want to lynch Roy.
I think he might have been lying about what his conversion did.
Even if he wasn't it still puts us further away from a Mensis victory.
We have at least 1 healing church hidden member left too.
Johnny Q is still alive, but he claimed doctor. but he's still alive, but he claimed doctor. but he's still alive, but he claimed doctor, but he's still alive, but he claimed doctor, but he's still alive.
I think he might have been lying about what his conversion did.
Even if he wasn't it still puts us further away from a Mensis victory.
We have at least 1 healing church hidden member left too.
Johnny Q is still alive, but he claimed doctor. but he's still alive, but he claimed doctor. but he's still alive, but he claimed doctor, but he's still alive, but he claimed doctor, but he's still alive.
CrimsonFist
Member
We very likely have a doctor since most towns do, and scum had a strongman, so in absence of any counter claims, I guess Johnny would have to be telling the truth.
...but there were three power role claims and scum can't have blocked all of them and none of them died.
...but there were three power role claims and scum can't have blocked all of them and none of them died.
CrimsonFist
Member
Also, yeah. Kris' flip makes mention of being "recruited" by Mensis. That really doesn't sound like a simple cow lick/dousing.
Zippedpinhead
Member
A winner and more deaths...
Congrats kristoffer... Anyone want to claim or make a guess at that other redacted...
Personally I'm thinking their were two. One for each faction...
Congrats kristoffer... Anyone want to claim or make a guess at that other redacted...
Personally I'm thinking their were two. One for each faction...
If Seath is town, I really don't understand why scum didn't strongman kill him. Unless they already used it, but on who? I don't see a kill that was likely a strongman on previous nights. Really curious about their night actions.
Squidyj, I was speaking 100 % the truth about my conversion. If it did more, why lie about it instead of just staying quiet? And I think killing people just to delay a Mensis Victory is a bad idea, I doubt the math works in our favor.
Also, I assume that if the Hidden Partner is the only one left they probably got activated automatically (only hopefully without the double kill bonus, that would be dumb).
CrimsonFist
Member
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=208407771&postcount=1252
http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=208406128&postcount=1238
Seath was kind of defensive of Weemad too
Please elaborate on the role blocking
Sure, I tried to track vanguard but was role blocked.
And also yes, based on my previous experience playing with Haly and Weemad, I assumed that Haly was scum, and to me even though he was town, Haly played more scummy than Weemad.
CrimsonFist
Member
Squidy and Roy: At the end of yesterday, the two of you voted for Pandas. Is there any reason you went for him over Weemad? Considering how much scummier the timing of Weemad's role claim was. (1536 and 1541).
CrimsonFist
Member
Any flavour?
the role he gave was literally a serial killer.
I seriously had the feeling nudull used the "seems" to point to their investigations, which would clear weemad as town, plus the theory about pandas being the Hidden Partner activated by jqk sounded believable. Clearly, both were wrong.
Freakinchair
Member
I chose not to shoot last night because I wasn't sure who to target. I've been wrong twice so far so I decided to hold back this time. JQK can pretty much say anyone and I can't dispute him so I might as well disclose now. If you want my opinion on who I was going to shoot (if anyone) it was going to be Flame_AC. I'm heading out to eat and will post more later but the basic theory is as follows:
Kristoffer turns out to be someone who needs to lynch one of 2+(?) people to win the game. He manages to win by lynching Verelios which explains his strange targetting early-midgame. I went over his posts and it looks like he possibly had three targets:
Verelios, Me, and Hobohodo.
Based on the text:
The Workshop Hunter, Verelios, would like to kill you in the name of the Healing Church.
I'm going to assume, knowing that I'm town, that he possibly had a target for each of the three factions. It would read something like this:
This would mean that Hobohodo is his Mensis target. And by Hobohodo.. I mean Flame_AC. Of course this theory is slightly marred by the fact that Mensis doesn't seem to have a kill power. I do need to check posting histories for the newly dead Healing Church member. There's likely to be at least one more Healing Church left provided the teams are relatively balanced. I'll be back laterz.
johnnyquicknives
Member
The first part could still be true, wee mad's role says he would show as town for the first 3 nights.
I protected Seath last night.
I'm pretty shocked I'm still here. The only thing I can think is that they were paranoid about being seen targeting someone obvious.
CrimsonFist
Member
There was only one redacted in his role PM wasn't there? I assumed that was you. But it would make sense if Mensis had someone targeting him as well.
CrimsonFist
Member
hmm, guess the redacted could be multiple people. Will look at his voting on Flame.
CrimsonFist
Member
If scum used their strong kill on Pandas last night, and blocked the tracker then they wouldn't need to worry about the doctor. But I don't get why they'd leave so many power roles alive if they're all town.
CrimsonFist
Member
The Verelios-Kris feud was getting comical, I was half-expecting Kris to be a lyncher or something... and I was half-right! Also, thank sweet baby Jesus that weemad died before WorthyEdge could swoop in and reset any ill will from that shitty Patches roleclaim. For once I get to be confirmed right about someone being maf BEFORE I'm dead! But enough about these small victories, clearly there's still something else out there or else the game would have ended.
So... has anyone else been converted to kin yet? It seems really weird that roy would be the only one who it's happened to when we're at Day 5. I highly doubt that they're spreading their points thinly to pop everyone at once, as that would just make things more difficult if another one of them were to get killed/lynched.
So... has anyone else been converted to kin yet? It seems really weird that roy would be the only one who it's happened to when we're at Day 5. I highly doubt that they're spreading their points thinly to pop everyone at once, as that would just make things more difficult if another one of them were to get killed/lynched.
II-Vanguard-II
Member
So FEP was town, and wee/worthyedge scum.
This pretty much wraps up the game for us town.
We got this in the bag.
Also, I want to mention that I was role blocked last night.
In the meantime.
Vote: ii-vanguard-ii
Enjoying the game so far?
Yes, very much
Three questions however
Why track me was there no one more suspicious?
how does you being roleblocked implicate me?
how many more HC members do you think are left?
Alright, so I've been thinking about bringing this up, I noticed it on Day 2 but figured it was a coincedence, however it happened again this past night and so here it is.
Note of course that Verelios ended up as scum and so the idea of a scum roleblocker protecting him seems very likely.
Fastforward to Night 4 and think about what scum is planning and the roles out there. They know that Freakinchair is a vig and isn't planning on shooting one of their members (Freakinchair even mentioned today that I would have been the one shot had he decided to do so.) So then who should the roleblocker go for, they knew FEP was the target of the night kill so that wouldn't be a problem. It stands to reason the strongman kill was used to make sure FEP died.
It is likely that scum thought that since JQK didn't die when visiting FEP after they though the powers activated, that killing FEP would be safe.
So now someone might ask, well then why hasn't a doctor come forward and counterclaimed? Well I would presume that there must be no doctor, why else wouldn't they have counterclaimed? This part is speculation, but my point is that 2 times now the 'protection' of people has resulted in the loss of night actions, the first time likely saving Verelios, one of their partners.
Vote: johnnyquicknives
I also note that I don't know if he is the hidden partner, it is unlikely given the coordination, but it is a hole in my theory. Also doesn't account for the seeming closeness between Mazre/JQK, but I think this is a good avenue to explore today.
What say you to this JQK, and if not you today, then who do you propose we go for?
Note of course that Verelios ended up as scum and so the idea of a scum roleblocker protecting him seems very likely.
Fastforward to Night 4 and think about what scum is planning and the roles out there. They know that Freakinchair is a vig and isn't planning on shooting one of their members (Freakinchair even mentioned today that I would have been the one shot had he decided to do so.) So then who should the roleblocker go for, they knew FEP was the target of the night kill so that wouldn't be a problem. It stands to reason the strongman kill was used to make sure FEP died.
It is likely that scum thought that since JQK didn't die when visiting FEP after they though the powers activated, that killing FEP would be safe.
So now someone might ask, well then why hasn't a doctor come forward and counterclaimed? Well I would presume that there must be no doctor, why else wouldn't they have counterclaimed? This part is speculation, but my point is that 2 times now the 'protection' of people has resulted in the loss of night actions, the first time likely saving Verelios, one of their partners.
Vote: johnnyquicknives
I also note that I don't know if he is the hidden partner, it is unlikely given the coordination, but it is a hole in my theory. Also doesn't account for the seeming closeness between Mazre/JQK, but I think this is a good avenue to explore today.
What say you to this JQK, and if not you today, then who do you propose we go for?
You decided to post and answer him with questions of your own. Could you talk about who you think we should lynch today?
Nothing to add?
II-Vanguard-II
Member
we absolutely should lynch JQK because he's a liar
you pointed out the main reason that everyone knows by now but i knew he was a liar as soon a he claimed doctor i didn't say any thing though because i didn't have any evidence. it would be my word against him.
My role name is Blood Minister and i'm the doctor i didn't role claim because i would've painted a bullseye on my back i wasn't going to do it today either but JQK needs to go down.
the people i protected were Haly\Squidy\Chair\Seath(was role blocked).
II-Vanguard-II
Member
Vote: johnnyqucknives
Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh.
Why'd you roleclaim!
We probably could have lynched him anyways without this and then we wouldn't have to worry about you dying just yet.
Is that in order, who you protected?
II-Vanguard-II
Member
we should have lynched him yesterday and we didn't because people were scared that he might be the doctor it could have happend again.
yes that is in order
II-Vanguard-II
Member
they didn't, i can just protect someone from kills i don't know if they're gonna be hit or not
haly was random
i was a little overwhelmed on D1 so don't read too much into haly i didn't know what i was doing
on day 2 i picked the only person i trusted
day 3 i picked chair for obvious reasons
day 4 i had to chose between seath and chair ultimately i chose seath
Whew, I don't know where I got that from. Was it not this game where a kill was blocked on Day 1, I thought it was. Late, so I'm going to bed I guess.
Yeah, I got why you did the rest of the days as you did.
We don't want to turbo today, or at least we want everyone to have an opportunity to speak, JQK included I suppose.
CrimsonFist
Member
With a doctor counterclaim I have no issues ending the day early.
Vote: Johnnyqucknives
Vote: Johnnyqucknives