Lord of Castamere
Member
Maybe. If I'm alive to give them.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Call of Cthulhu Mafia |OT| Nuts on this island taste insane! Yum Yum!
- Thread starter Zatoth
- Start date
Maybe. If I'm alive to give them.
Day 1 has ended.
I'll announce the result soon.
Please stop posting here until the night has ended.
You can use this thread.
But please refrain from game talk there.
I'll announce the result soon.
Please stop posting here until the night has ended.
You can use this thread.
But please refrain from game talk there.
We all do. This is on all of us. We shall never forget the day we succumbed to the island's madness.
D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
a.k.a. "getting Barrylocke'd".
Because it came up in another game I added something to the rules. Voting for yourself is not allowed. Such a vote would not be counted.
17. For your vote to count, it must be presented in the following format: VOTE: playername, via use of the highlight tag. It must also be in an entirely separate line from any other text. You are not allowed to vote for yourself.
17. For your vote to count, it must be presented in the following format: VOTE: playername, via use of the highlight tag. It must also be in an entirely separate line from any other text. You are not allowed to vote for yourself.
Never Forever
Member
oh
my
god
yaaaaaaaaassssss
my
god
yaaaaaaaaassssss
Never Forever
Member
oh shit, I just read Fireblend's role description, we lost the doctor too, that sucks, rip dude
but we got a Cultist! better than the other games already
but we got a Cultist! better than the other games already
Yeah, well... Um... You lost your Witch in the process, too!
... *Sniff* Poor Krieg-ly.
I was seriously questioning you for a minute there
Good results for the first night, now I have to go look at what Blargonaut's suggestions were and see if that has any impact here...
I should remind you guys that there was a serious bandwagon on Lone_Prodigy halfway through day One. We should look at what happened from there on out very carefully.
I see that there is a "turn insane" option for Cultists. I don't know if that's done through somebody's decision or RNG, but it seems like this game is going to get really weird, really fast.
I see that there is a "turn insane" option for Cultists. I don't know if that's done through somebody's decision or RNG, but it seems like this game is going to get really weird, really fast.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
Holy shit. And I was gonna back off Prodigy today.
This is interesting. I have to gather my thoughts on this. This makes the Tucah vote much more interesting.
This is interesting. I have to gather my thoughts on this. This makes the Tucah vote much more interesting.
If I had to guess, I'm betting that there were very few Cultists, perhaps as few as two, and they can grow their ranks every so often. It's our job to stop them before they convert/kill us.
Matt Attack
Member
I've never been so conflicted about morning results before. RIP Fireblend, but it's awesome that a cultist ended up dead too.
I think that might just be fluff. Otherwise they would probably need two commands, rather than just SACRIFICE.
It sounds too broken to me if it were true, but who knows.
I think that might just be fluff. Otherwise they would probably need two commands, rather than just SACRIFICE.
It sounds too broken to me if it were true, but who knows.
"Depending on Cthulhu's mood" makes it sound more like it's a random process that Cultists don't choose to me. It would probably just be sacrifice if it was flavor text.
Werewolf Jones
Member
Oh my god you guys had really read Lone_Prodigy EXTREMELY well but... How?
I was seriously questioning you for a minute there
Good results for the first night, now I have to go look at what Blargonaut's suggestions were and see if that has any impact here...
Yeah I'm sorry, I read the word ordinary and thought the results were all trash, then I saw NF was happy and re-read to saw I was dumb lol
Going through Firebrand and Lone_Prodigy's posts aswell.
Seems that the mafia can either kill or turn someone insane each night, Like a 50/50 chance, sucks that They got lucky tonight by killing our doctor. But who got the other kill? If they got the 50% chance of killing someone it seems we have a 3rd or neutral party who cab kill aswell.
I am currently on mobile but will be home in 2 more hours to dive into those questions.
Seems that the mafia can either kill or turn someone insane each night, Like a 50/50 chance, sucks that They got lucky tonight by killing our doctor. But who got the other kill? If they got the 50% chance of killing someone it seems we have a 3rd or neutral party who cab kill aswell.
I am currently on mobile but will be home in 2 more hours to dive into those questions.
Never Forever
Member
I am now pretty certain that ROTY is Town, bc there is no way Cult would go so hard on one of their own Day 1
Aside from that, I need to think for a while. Everything L_P did is now basically required reading before we can get stuck into Day 2 proper.
Aside from that, I need to think for a while. Everything L_P did is now basically required reading before we can get stuck into Day 2 proper.
Oh my god you guys had really read Lone_Prodigy EXTREMELY well but... How?
He played like absolute trash, I'm disappointed in myself for just attributing it to newbie jitters. Shouldn't have let that cloud my judgement.
Oh my god you guys had really read Lone_Prodigy EXTREMELY well but... How?
Just imagine how much more ridiculous it would have been if we had kept our votes on him Day 1.
This is a fair point. If someone loses their mind to Cthulu, it might be the same as dying.
The second kill was more then likely Blarg, it will remain to be seen whether he's lynched though, can't have him going around and killing Tourists next.
Matt Attack
Member
To me that sounds like way too big of a mechanic not to be fully detailed in the Cultist's role PM, leaving aside the fact that it sounds like it would be a really powerful ability for the cultists (who already have an information ability) to possess.
Is this something Zatoth is able to comment on? We really need to know this going forward.
Rats Off To Ya
Banned
Matt Attack
Member
That should read "information advantage", not ability.
Woohoo mostly! Losing a doctor this early is rough, but at least we didn't hang them ourselves. A Cultist death is great. Should be some good digging we can do based on the way the votes went yesterday. I'll try and look into those tonight when I have some time to dig.
The turn insane thing seems more fluff than anything else. In most Cthulu-ey stuff going insane is as good as being dead. It doesn't mean you're suddenly evil. Just your mind is gone.
The turn insane thing seems more fluff than anything else. In most Cthulu-ey stuff going insane is as good as being dead. It doesn't mean you're suddenly evil. Just your mind is gone.
I don't think any of us have reasoning yet. The deal was that Blarg had to deliver a concrete cultist for our day 2 kill. With this cult death, he may have done just that but we are going to need to look back through old posts first.
It could be role-based, like the Lost Partner in the Animal Crossing game - if the Cultists try to kill certain players, they convert them instead. The real shame of it would be that they would be playing town right up until they are converted, so it'd be hard to tell who is who.
Assuming I'm not completely off-base, of course.
/shrug. I've NEVER seen someone argue that a bandwagon is a good thing. It reeked of Mafia play.
I'll be directing everyone to look at Post #515 and on then, I had the honor of receiving his vote.
I have to admit that I'll have to apologize about my reads from the last day phase. There's no way a cultist went deep on there own and I believe you started the bandwagon so gut feeling is that you are tourist for now.
...huh. I clearly misunderstood what we were agreeing on. Well, for the moment, I'm okay with letting Blarg live, as long as everyone else is good with it. I don't actually buy that he was declaring himself a third party killer on day one anyway, but it was worth investigating.
As for how kill/turn insane exactly work. That I can not answer. But Cultists have no influence on what will happen when they used that action. That is up to me.
And being turned insane is not a permanent thing. Guess that is also something everyone should know.