D
Deleted member 231381
Unconfirmed Member
dont talk about it
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Call of Cthulhu Mafia |OT| Nuts on this island taste insane! Yum Yum!
- Thread starter Zatoth
- Start date
dont talk about it
Blargonaut
Banned
Blargonaut
Banned
UNVOTE: GreatCharleston
VOTE: Coppanuva
Back to life, back to reality
VOTE: Coppanuva
Back to life, back to reality
Blargonaut
Banned
yo I just thought of a great idea
Why don't you all role-claim?
Seriously, think about it.
Why don't you all role-claim?
Seriously, think about it.
17. For your vote to count, it must be presented in the following format: VOTE: playername, via use of the highlight tag. It must also be in an entirely separate line from any other text.
I counted it. But there is a good chance I will not notice your vote if it is not in a separate line.
Blargonaut (8)
TheWorthyEdge
Never Forever
johnnyquicknives
ultron87
Matt Attack
Timeaisis
Coppanuva
nin1000
Coppanuva (5)
GreatCharleston
Rats Off To Ya
Droplet
Darryl
Blargonaut
GreatCharleston (4)
Flame_AC
Sorian
Lord of Castamere
ScraftyDevil
Sorian (1)
Neuromancer
11 votes are need to end the day early
Hope my count is correct.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
Allow me to interject.
A man cannot get some sleep without being suspected of killing someone? I don't even know what "evidence" Scrafty has against me nor does this sudden upsurge of votes even scare me. This is Cthulhu mafia, after all, you all think you're True Detectives but that's a far cry from the truth. I think each round from now if I survive will just be a full circle of "Hmm, these people seem susp-- VOTE: GREATCHARLESTON." I mean, I can clearly see why you think that & I wish I could offer more to you through the means of truth but I can't just... sell myself out and give up my position you know? I am truly worthless though and that might be a contradiction but still. I cannot guide my fellow tourists to victory. Unless you think I'm pulling a Lone_Prodigy and simply claiming to be something I am not but due to his his lack of a way with words that type of thing won't work twice.
Maybe I did kill Fireblend and maybe even Lone_Prodigy to take the heat off of myself? Or maybe I'm just an innocent tourist trying to get by in the game? I'm not playing the strongest support role. Well, I'm not even supportive at all this much is clear. But killing me won't get you as close to the truth as wiping out Blarg, that much is obvious and you KNOW it to be true. I too wanted Blarg to stick around, he made the game interesting you know? But now... He's starting to get a little tired, a little desperate even. His tricks and amusing posting style can only get you so far in this game and time is running out.
But by all means, vote for me if you trust Scrafty's evidence she has against me, I've clearly shown some signs of weakness that could be taken advantage of the opener to this day, the lament of Fireblend and the amazement of you all overcoming Lone_Prodigy. That's literally all I can think of, a quick show of "We did it guys" straight back into keeping quiet, is that all it is? Killing me is a shot in the dark but if you're willing to take it then go for it. Show me your reasons as to why first though beside the rather predictable bandwagon of distrust.
Rats Off To Ya seems to have some faith in me and he's one of the more aggressive posters in this game. But do what you must.
Tell me, Charlie... Why are you so afraid to is th' one power that every person on this island has?
By now it's no secret to everybody that you completely forwent votin' yesterday, and again, I ask why? The only time you voted today is once that information was brought to the attention o' the group, at which point ya threw out an excuse vote for someone who was already gettin' dogpiled before bailin' out again until someone else called you out. Seems like you're only prone to add input once the pressure's on, which I don't think is the ideal situation for any'a us here. Tryin' t' remain a "neutral party" does nothin' 'cept make ya look like you don't want to be associated with a certain group, and doesn't help us get any closer t' discoverin' what goes bump in the night.
And if you're so sure that Blarg's the one who hasta die tonight, why didn't you change your vote to him? Or do you know somethin' about Coppa that you'd like to share?
.png)
To be honest, there's another thing that's been botherin' me too. On the first day, you were actually one'a the first people to draw suspicion from the group, even if they gradually shifted their votes onta other folks. Once the heat was off you "jokin'ly" said that you were "honoured" that someone would be suspicious of you. Maybe I'm readin' too far inta this, and I'll admit that I do sometimes have trouble readin' other folks' poker faces, but can ya answer me this: why is it that you got all defensive this morning once minimal pressure was applied by me and Sorian? You'd faced much greater opposition the day before, an' yet you seemed t' act offended that we'd consider you even after your comment yesterday.
You definitely know more than you're lettin' on, and I'll find out what you know even if I've gotta grill ya til yer last breath.
Tell me Charlie, are you a gamblin' man?
Never Forever
Member
a summary of stuff I've noticed in the thread since my last post:
- Sorian gets into an argument with Darryl re: Blargonaut, Sorian argues that Darryl is acting really suspiciously, Darryl makes the point that the confirmation of Blargonaut's role is the first time that he's actually been worth the time of day. GC and nin chirp up in support of Darryl yet don't really add much, but that's basically par for the course.
- Neuromancer notes that Sorian has more posts than anyone else, although the corollary of this argument is the fact that he (just like me) is languishing at the bottom of the leaderboard and doesn't really post much, so doesn't that make us equally as suspicious? The fact is that it's far easier for scum to post little in order to be more controlled than to completely blitzkrieg the thread the way Sorian does, but honestly is the amount of posts a scumtell at all? The main issue is whether all Sorian's posts have content, and whilst not all of them do, he has proportionately made more posts with content than quite a lot of people and he's been useful to pushing discussion forward.
Neuromancer has a bee in his bonnet re: Tucah, but I think he's seeing ill intent where there's none.
- Nin posts his reads, but they're bothersome because I don't see a lot of logic there and he brings up two incredibly odd candidates in Neuromancer and ScraftyDevil, where what he's saying really doesn't make sense, and however he tries to explain it it doesn't really get explained. There's just a bizarre disconnect going on as if the names were picked first and then something was made up to fit them,. I think that when somebody posts up reads you should be able to easily see where they're coming from, or at least understand why they're thinking what they're thinking. I was unable to grab onto anything tangible there.
- ROTY votes for Coppanuva and says that we should stick with voting for a scummy player rather than a confirmed neutral, setting off a complete roundabout mess where nobody is actually persuading each another of anything aside from increasing the stubborn conviction that their side is the one that's in the right. I tried to summarise it, but I got bored. Oh wait, LoC had his mind changed. Hooray.
I actually thought like ROTY when I first read through the whole MA/Blarg exchange when I woke up yesterday, but I changed my mind when I collected my thoughts because I would rather play it safe. Even if it's true that there are still a lot of people for power roles to sift through, there are still some players who are more worthy of attention than others, assuming that the power roles have brains. The issue also arises that every day we will return to this topic, will today be the day we lynch Blargonaut, and no matter how much one tries to ignore it, one will inevitably get dragged into it if one wishes to participate in any meaningful capacity. It's an easy way for scum to control the discussion and ensure that chaos reigns for as long as possible. There is no way that Blarg is getting night killed when he's still a tantalising out for any potential cultist in need of any easy defence.
I would rather wipe the slate clean, eject the neutrals, and move onto Coppanuva without any distractions buzzing away every few posts, breaking my chain of thought and making me question why I'm even bothering.
- We've returned to GC again, but he seems to have taken a page from the Coppanuva book of self-defence. Rather than presenting alternatives, it's all 'fine go ahead lynch me now you'll regret it when I flip town uh-huh yes you will'
- Sorian gets into an argument with Darryl re: Blargonaut, Sorian argues that Darryl is acting really suspiciously, Darryl makes the point that the confirmation of Blargonaut's role is the first time that he's actually been worth the time of day. GC and nin chirp up in support of Darryl yet don't really add much, but that's basically par for the course.
- Neuromancer notes that Sorian has more posts than anyone else, although the corollary of this argument is the fact that he (just like me) is languishing at the bottom of the leaderboard and doesn't really post much, so doesn't that make us equally as suspicious? The fact is that it's far easier for scum to post little in order to be more controlled than to completely blitzkrieg the thread the way Sorian does, but honestly is the amount of posts a scumtell at all? The main issue is whether all Sorian's posts have content, and whilst not all of them do, he has proportionately made more posts with content than quite a lot of people and he's been useful to pushing discussion forward.
Neuromancer has a bee in his bonnet re: Tucah, but I think he's seeing ill intent where there's none.
- Nin posts his reads, but they're bothersome because I don't see a lot of logic there and he brings up two incredibly odd candidates in Neuromancer and ScraftyDevil, where what he's saying really doesn't make sense, and however he tries to explain it it doesn't really get explained. There's just a bizarre disconnect going on as if the names were picked first and then something was made up to fit them,. I think that when somebody posts up reads you should be able to easily see where they're coming from, or at least understand why they're thinking what they're thinking. I was unable to grab onto anything tangible there.
- ROTY votes for Coppanuva and says that we should stick with voting for a scummy player rather than a confirmed neutral, setting off a complete roundabout mess where nobody is actually persuading each another of anything aside from increasing the stubborn conviction that their side is the one that's in the right. I tried to summarise it, but I got bored. Oh wait, LoC had his mind changed. Hooray.
I actually thought like ROTY when I first read through the whole MA/Blarg exchange when I woke up yesterday, but I changed my mind when I collected my thoughts because I would rather play it safe. Even if it's true that there are still a lot of people for power roles to sift through, there are still some players who are more worthy of attention than others, assuming that the power roles have brains. The issue also arises that every day we will return to this topic, will today be the day we lynch Blargonaut, and no matter how much one tries to ignore it, one will inevitably get dragged into it if one wishes to participate in any meaningful capacity. It's an easy way for scum to control the discussion and ensure that chaos reigns for as long as possible. There is no way that Blarg is getting night killed when he's still a tantalising out for any potential cultist in need of any easy defence.
I would rather wipe the slate clean, eject the neutrals, and move onto Coppanuva without any distractions buzzing away every few posts, breaking my chain of thought and making me question why I'm even bothering.
- We've returned to GC again, but he seems to have taken a page from the Coppanuva book of self-defence. Rather than presenting alternatives, it's all 'fine go ahead lynch me now you'll regret it when I flip town uh-huh yes you will'
If you don't mind me summarizing your summary, it reads like you have varying levels of suspicion for Coppa, Nin, and Charleston? The rest of the people you mentioned didn't seem to be suspicious but instead were just key players in the proceedings. Am I reading your post right?
Never Forever
Member
Yes. They're my three main candidates for D3 lynch who've been sticking out for the wrong reasons.
I think that you, ROTY, Darryl and Neuro come across as being more town than not.
Thank you for your input, I'll admit that I've been letting Nin fly under the radar because we keep having bigger things that pop up but it's true that I need to keep him on my radar only because he hasn't done enough to get a real read on.
Sorry about that, I wrote that up in a hurry and reading through my post again, it does not really make a lot of sense why i picked those candidates. I will try to write an updated one today which will make a lot of more sense
Sorry about that, I wrote that up in a hurry and reading through my post again, it does not really make a lot of sense why i picked those candidates. I will try to write an updated one today which will make a lot of more sense
I look forward to it, I'm holding you to this before the day is out.
Bravo ScraftyDevil, I like this interrogation tactics. For future record, I'm marking "unwilling to go along with questions" as a point of suspicion. Given that Rats off To Ya uses it as an argument against me, I think it's fair if I call out when people don't answer accordingly, or reply to a question with "I'm not answering that."
Also looking over a theory I was making last night and... jesus. I should not be making mafia theories late at night. Way too many holes.
Also looking over a theory I was making last night and... jesus. I should not be making mafia theories late at night. Way too many holes.
If the theory had any basis at all, it doesn't hurt anyone if you post it. It may be full of holes but it might be the push that someone else needs to come up with a stronger conclusion on their end.
I plan to, but don't expect it for a bit. It needs a bit of work and I'm kinda busy this morning with my job (yay being on-call). I'll try to get it up by this afternoon but no guarantees it'll pop out this before tonight.
Werewolf Jones
Member
If we come to the mutual consensus that Blarg is the one that should go tonight then I will change my vote. Like every other player with my vote I can giveth and I can taketh away. I'm not even that passionate about killing off Coppanuva anymore but a vote is a vote. I can switch it to someone else.
The power to vote? Well... I didn't wanna crush others at first and put pressure onto them right away but I've come around. But the ascent to madness from others can be quite amusing.
Like I said above it just didn't feel right at the time but now everyone is more settled it's easier to make assumptions and throw votes around the established groups and/or individuals in the game. Certain people crack under pressure, others don't and just refuse to play the game, which is their choice just like how I've not really tried to be pro or anti town. Yeah, this brings up questions but wouldn't a smarter move for as the game starts to try and individualise someone else and me turn into a down right rabblerouser and try and get others killed? That way I'd come across as a "stronger" player dumb accusations of others or not.
Oh, no, I simply did not like how Coppa tried pointing the finger at me... Say, Blarg, would you like my vote? Would you like that honour? I will give it to you, it'd be a blessing.
I didn't think someone would rise up against me so quickly and funnily enough the very person who was the first to question me and bring me to everyones attention now seems to be one of the few who has some form of faith in my role as a player in this very game. One vote against me? Wouldn't really cause concern for ANYONE here, but if others start getting on your case as well then of course anyone will feel pressured. If you mean the first time you brought me up then I didn't feel a need to strongly defend myself, I just think you're going off of a hunch with very little evidence beside how I don't post as much as the others nor do I really give my judgement of others. But if we're all judges, who is the jury and who is the executioner?
I know as much as everyone else, if I'm honest. There's no real information I could give to anyone to benefit you. Am I a gambling man? Not by choice but I will partake if I have to. The odds aren't quite stacked against me just yet. Now lemme ask, do you all unironically believe I'm a cultist? I think I deserve this answer for the questions I'm getting. Now with that...
Here's an interesting little idea though given what Blarg and Matt Attack have said. If you're all so sure about me:
Kill Blarg gaining an immunity for no one to die then have Matt Attack play his little role out to investigate upon me then on Dawn of Day 3 have him post his conclusive evidence on my behalf if you're THAT confident I'm not to be trusted. I am sure this would give you all the answers to the questions you desire, of course, you could also do that for anyone else given your trust levels for them. The future is in your hands, take this chance or wait for the great old one to take you away!
That would be a solid idea, except Matt's investigation doesn't work that way. His investigation asks one question: Is this the person I've been looking for? [Y/N]
And he already found his person. Matt's skill is now useless.
Werewolf Jones
Member
Seems it won't be so easy. I wanted to have faith in Blarg, except unlike most I wasn't really taken by his posts of nonsense. He's become too much of a wildcard and what was once funny is now really quite annoying. So yes, I believe he should be taken out of the game, it'll get a whole lot quieter but thien maybe some of the others will start posting more.
SO....
Vote: Blargonaught.
Also you didn't answer my question.
Thank you for making a real choice even if I felt that I had to goad you into it. I did leave the option to you though and you did post reasoning as well so that does mean something. I hope you see that going forward you'll have to do this more often or the suspicion will just keep coming back to you. In regards to this:
Is that to me? I didn't see any questions in your post meant for me, only for Scrafty.
-------------
That being said, keep in mind that Blarg is at 9 votes, only 2 more and the day ends. My own vote is already withheld but reserved for him but I still don't want the day to end early, no reason to lose time. That being said:
VOTE: Nin1000
We were promised a well thought out post and we may not get it for awhile because of time zones but I'm willing to sit on this vote for a bit.
Is that to me? I didn't see any questions in your post meant for me, only for Scrafty.
-------------
That being said, keep in mind that Blarg is at 9 votes, only 2 more and the day ends. My own vote is already withheld but reserved for him but I still don't want the day to end early, no reason to lose time. That being said:
VOTE: Nin1000
We were promised a well thought out post and we may not get it for awhile because of time zones but I'm willing to sit on this vote for a bit.
Still at work for the next 4 hours and i dont want to put down a post that will be as harmful as the last one. This one has to be thought out well
Werewolf Jones
Member
It's for whoever feels I'm not to be trusted, I should have made that clear I suppose.
Blargonaut
Banned
Let's fuck.
Flame_AC CULT
You know that sound an open hand makes when it slaps a bare supple ass from a perfectly perpendicular angle? You're half a pair of flip-flops and you echo with an indecent ripple.
GreatCharleston 50% TOWN
I'm torn. I think you're using those Danganymedaneeda pics to spice up your boring Ordinary Tourist life.
Lone_Prodigy Night 1 RIP
Ordinary Cultist
Rats Off To Ya 110% TOWN, 100% "TOWN"
You contribute and you "contribute". You understand #TownLife.
UNCONDITIONAL TRUST: Rats Off To Ya
I really think you're Town. I hope I'm right.
Neuromancer CULT
Get out of my mind, mageling. You're there, but you're not.
Fireblend Night 1 RIP
Witch Doctor
Sorian CULT/NEUTRAL
I don't believe you're Town, and if you are, you're too publicly pro-Town for the Cult to keep alive any longer, if they're practical. If you're not dead in 2 or 3 Nights at the rate you're going, you're probably Cult, or a fellow Neutral.
OG "Town" Cultists; if you're smart, you should terminate Sorian ASAP if you want to win this more cleanly and efficiently. Or else, go hardcore and try manipulating him to be your cover like I did, by slipping him a framework of role hints and allowing him to put words in your mouth to fill out your character sheet for you; thereby, publicly disguising you with minimal effort on your part. That's how "Town" uses these types of analytical machine-gun players. Risky, but rewarding.
If you're wondering why I'm telling you this despite saying I'm legit pro-Town; there comes a time in every Town's life when Town must choose to be Town, or "Town". I want you to go "Town" on Sorian. I want to witness the slow burn. Kill him, and create a power vacuum.
Darryl, can you put a stop to my chosen champion? You are both cut from the same cloth; but, who is the paladin, and who is the inquisitor?
"Town" chooses. Town obeys.
TheWorthyEdge ??? NEW*
How you doin'?
Droplet 50% TOWN, 50% "TOWN"
You go with the flow, but sometimes you don't. I can't read you. And--
Never Forever 11% CULT
--I can't read you either. However, with you, I feel something. You maintain a presence, but remain mostly under the radar, like Droplet. You get in and out. I know there's an intellect there and I feel it watching, I feel you watching. If Sorian is the commander, I see you as his lieutenant; but, you and Droplet are interchangeable in that regard. You're like his left and right hands. One of you is sinister. I think you are.
I find the both of you hella suspicious, and I just can't shake off that blank space.
Sorry for dissing your waifu before, that's a line no man should cross.
johnnyquicknives ??? NEW*
I see you're getting cozy with Sorian. I look forward to seeing what you do.
ultron87 CULT/NEUTRAL
Timeaisis.copypasta
Matt Attack The Other.
I would've gotten away with it if it weren't for you, meddling kid. Fucking Scooby Snacks.
Tucah Day 1 RIP
Ordinary Tourist
Timeaisis CULT/NEUTRAL
His hard-on to get me killed since Day 1 is exactly what I wanted to tease out of his pants with my body language. I'm a highly convenient target for any player to acknowledge, hence an easy means to maintain a presence in-game through. I doubt a real, smart Town would commit to harassing me with constant vote attacks like he has. You're either Cult, or a Neutral 3rd-party trying to skirt the Line enough during daylight in order to dissuade the Cult from offing you.
Darryl Where's your fuck?
You should rest and meditate on what you've learned.
Lord of Castamere TOWN, 1% CONCENTRATED "TOWN"
This island doesn't have a waterfall. I know we've played together before Mr. Castamere, but what are you playing at now? I don't understand. What are these moves? I DON'T UNDERSTAND YOUR MOVES. WHY WON'T YOU GIVE UP, MR. CASTAMERE? WHAT IS THIS FILTH; RIGHT JAB TO SOLAR PLEXUS, FORWARD SLIDE DOWN CHAIR AS SEATED TO DOUBLE-KICK OPPONENT'S CHAIR LEGS ACROSS. SHOCK TOPPLES HIM FORWARD ONTO TABLE, I LET MOMENTUM SLIP ME FULLY UNDERNEATH IT; GROIN KICK, GROIN KICK. HIS LEGS SNAP TOGETHER IN PAIN REFLEX; KNEES BUCKLE. THERE'S THE TICKET. SIR'S CENTRE OF GRAVITY SHIFTS TO THE TABLE'S DOMAIN, I EXTEND TO ACCEPT THE PRESENTED FARE; PRONE THROAT-PUNCH THROUGH THE WOOD ABOVE. IT SPLINTERS UPON ME. THROAT-PUNCH, THROAT-PUNCH. THROAT-PUNCH. YOU CALL THAT SHERLOCK COSPLAY!?! It's pretty good.
You're absent sporadically and intermittently enough to suggest that you're on a side-forum, especially considering the depth of your contributions compared to your public appearances. Yeah, I said it. I said "contributions". This is serious business. Jobs are at steak.
Coppanuva 100% TOWN, 100% CULT
100% honest truth, I legit forgot why I was gunning for you in the first place. You just give off a distinct aroma of scum with a bouquet of shady masked under naive innocence. I do remember Rats having a presentable case against you though, y'all refer to him. At least, I think I remember. Coppanuva's probably a Mind Flayer or something. Or a really, really clumsy Ordinary Tourist with an Inkling hat.
RetroMG 60% TOWN
You're absent sporadically and intermittently enough to suggest that you're on a side-forum, especially considering the depth of your "contributions" compared to your public appearances. I think. I dunno.
ScraftyDevil 50% TOWN
Part of the Sorian Squad, yet apart from it? Your unique accent is a very effective tool for masking your true feelings. I've added it to my spell book.
Blargonaut
#xanax
nin1000 CULT
You're from the same cask of wine that Coppanuva was poured out of, but you were left out in the air too long before the tasting and everyone who sips you backwashes you back into the glass. Then pets come and try to lick you out because you still smell of the old vintage despite being mixed with discerning saliva, but their tongues aren't long enough to reach your backwash at the bottom and so they give up after trying for a few seconds.
Vylash ??? OLD*, CULT LEADER?
Cthulhu. Dat indifference.
---
20 remain.
MAJOR CULT SUSPECTS(x9) (x8)
(x9) (x7)
MEDDLING KID (x1)
---
*puts hand up*
No breeze. No storm. All doldrums. Is this how you're all going to escape the Isle? Waiting for the wind to come to topple the dominoes for you? Pathetic.
I'm giving you the chance to use these fingers. Fuck the sea. None of us are swimming out there and making it alive. Our best option is to go deeper. Deeper into the island.
Innocents will die. Innocence will die. They don't care.
Let's make them.
I usually hate doing lists, because all it does is conveniently put words into people's mouths for them to manipulate to their own ends and hide behind, instead of allowing people to speak up for themselves. It's too direct a conversation piece for everyone involved. No, Sorian. I prefer the indirect approach of abstractly teasing people to see what their priorities are.
But, I'm choosing to sell-out for once. If you want more of this corporate-ordered direct-to-home-DVD list shit straight from me, let's go Plan 800 Feet. Lynch someone else today.
Or, kill me now and take the easy reward from my death; fine, I don't care about losing. I never have. I care about "winning". I care about COURAGE.
Follow me, sightseers; follow me to the heart of dankness. Do you know who I am? I'm fucking H.P. Lovecraft. We arrived here on a cruise. Now let's depart on the Love Boat.
I'm the one who fucks the tentacles.
S'MAKE YOUR CHOICE, NERDS.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A:- Play the main quest with Sorian, who is sworn to carry to your burdens. (Lynch Blargonaut today, and I shall bestow my Blessing upon you, no ire.)
OR
B:- Take my fucking side-quest to the heart of the Shivering Isles. (Don't lynch me today, because I'm a known quantity; instead, lynch an unknown quantity to gain 100% unknown info, and gamble with the fact that I may or may not survive to Day 3 for you to use me. It's entirely a cosmic gamble that relies on power role distribution and blind faith in the stars. Let's fuck. REMEMBER: My Blessing's damage output scales the higher the level/Day you are when you claim me, but only to a point. Lynch me on Day 3. It's the sweet spot.)
Flame_AC CULT
You know that sound an open hand makes when it slaps a bare supple ass from a perfectly perpendicular angle? You're half a pair of flip-flops and you echo with an indecent ripple.
GreatCharleston 50% TOWN
I'm torn. I think you're using those Danganymedaneeda pics to spice up your boring Ordinary Tourist life.
Rats Off To Ya 110% TOWN, 100% "TOWN"
You contribute and you "contribute". You understand #TownLife.
UNCONDITIONAL TRUST: Rats Off To Ya
I really think you're Town. I hope I'm right.
Neuromancer CULT
Get out of my mind, mageling. You're there, but you're not.
Sorian CULT/NEUTRAL
I don't believe you're Town, and if you are, you're too publicly pro-Town for the Cult to keep alive any longer, if they're practical. If you're not dead in 2 or 3 Nights at the rate you're going, you're probably Cult, or a fellow Neutral.
OG "Town" Cultists; if you're smart, you should terminate Sorian ASAP if you want to win this more cleanly and efficiently. Or else, go hardcore and try manipulating him to be your cover like I did, by slipping him a framework of role hints and allowing him to put words in your mouth to fill out your character sheet for you; thereby, publicly disguising you with minimal effort on your part. That's how "Town" uses these types of analytical machine-gun players. Risky, but rewarding.
If you're wondering why I'm telling you this despite saying I'm legit pro-Town; there comes a time in every Town's life when Town must choose to be Town, or "Town". I want you to go "Town" on Sorian. I want to witness the slow burn. Kill him, and create a power vacuum.
Darryl, can you put a stop to my chosen champion? You are both cut from the same cloth; but, who is the paladin, and who is the inquisitor?
"Town" chooses. Town obeys.
TheWorthyEdge ??? NEW*
How you doin'?
Droplet 50% TOWN, 50% "TOWN"
You go with the flow, but sometimes you don't. I can't read you. And--
Never Forever 11% CULT
--I can't read you either. However, with you, I feel something. You maintain a presence, but remain mostly under the radar, like Droplet. You get in and out. I know there's an intellect there and I feel it watching, I feel you watching. If Sorian is the commander, I see you as his lieutenant; but, you and Droplet are interchangeable in that regard. You're like his left and right hands. One of you is sinister. I think you are.
I find the both of you hella suspicious, and I just can't shake off that blank space.
Sorry for dissing your waifu before, that's a line no man should cross.
johnnyquicknives ??? NEW*
I see you're getting cozy with Sorian. I look forward to seeing what you do.
ultron87 CULT/NEUTRAL
Timeaisis.copypasta
Matt Attack The Other.
I would've gotten away with it if it weren't for you, meddling kid. Fucking Scooby Snacks.
Timeaisis CULT/NEUTRAL
His hard-on to get me killed since Day 1 is exactly what I wanted to tease out of his pants with my body language. I'm a highly convenient target for any player to acknowledge, hence an easy means to maintain a presence in-game through. I doubt a real, smart Town would commit to harassing me with constant vote attacks like he has. You're either Cult, or a Neutral 3rd-party trying to skirt the Line enough during daylight in order to dissuade the Cult from offing you.
Darryl Where's your fuck?
You should rest and meditate on what you've learned.
Lord of Castamere TOWN, 1% CONCENTRATED "TOWN"
This island doesn't have a waterfall. I know we've played together before Mr. Castamere, but what are you playing at now? I don't understand. What are these moves? I DON'T UNDERSTAND YOUR MOVES. WHY WON'T YOU GIVE UP, MR. CASTAMERE? WHAT IS THIS FILTH; RIGHT JAB TO SOLAR PLEXUS, FORWARD SLIDE DOWN CHAIR AS SEATED TO DOUBLE-KICK OPPONENT'S CHAIR LEGS ACROSS. SHOCK TOPPLES HIM FORWARD ONTO TABLE, I LET MOMENTUM SLIP ME FULLY UNDERNEATH IT; GROIN KICK, GROIN KICK. HIS LEGS SNAP TOGETHER IN PAIN REFLEX; KNEES BUCKLE. THERE'S THE TICKET. SIR'S CENTRE OF GRAVITY SHIFTS TO THE TABLE'S DOMAIN, I EXTEND TO ACCEPT THE PRESENTED FARE; PRONE THROAT-PUNCH THROUGH THE WOOD ABOVE. IT SPLINTERS UPON ME. THROAT-PUNCH, THROAT-PUNCH. THROAT-PUNCH. YOU CALL THAT SHERLOCK COSPLAY!?! It's pretty good.
You're absent sporadically and intermittently enough to suggest that you're on a side-forum, especially considering the depth of your contributions compared to your public appearances. Yeah, I said it. I said "contributions". This is serious business. Jobs are at steak.
Coppanuva 100% TOWN, 100% CULT
100% honest truth, I legit forgot why I was gunning for you in the first place. You just give off a distinct aroma of scum with a bouquet of shady masked under naive innocence. I do remember Rats having a presentable case against you though, y'all refer to him. At least, I think I remember. Coppanuva's probably a Mind Flayer or something. Or a really, really clumsy Ordinary Tourist with an Inkling hat.
RetroMG 60% TOWN
You're absent sporadically and intermittently enough to suggest that you're on a side-forum, especially considering the depth of your "contributions" compared to your public appearances. I think. I dunno.
ScraftyDevil 50% TOWN
Part of the Sorian Squad, yet apart from it? Your unique accent is a very effective tool for masking your true feelings. I've added it to my spell book.
Blargonaut
#xanax
nin1000 CULT
You're from the same cask of wine that Coppanuva was poured out of, but you were left out in the air too long before the tasting and everyone who sips you backwashes you back into the glass. Then pets come and try to lick you out because you still smell of the old vintage despite being mixed with discerning saliva, but their tongues aren't long enough to reach your backwash at the bottom and so they give up after trying for a few seconds.
Vylash ??? OLD*, CULT LEADER?
Cthulhu. Dat indifference.
---
20 remain.
MAJOR CULT SUSPECTS
- Flame_AC
Lone_Prodigy- Neuromancer
- Sorian
- Never Forever
- ultron87
- Timeaisis
- nin1000
- Coppanuva
- Sorian
- ultron87
- Timeaisis
- GreatCharleston
- Rats Off To Ya
Fireblend- Droplet
Tucah- Lord of Castamere
- RetroMG
- ScraftyDevil
- Coppanuva
- TheWorthyEdge
- johnnyquicknives
- Vylash
MEDDLING KID (x1)
- Matt Attack
- Blargonaut
- Darryl
---
*puts hand up*
No breeze. No storm. All doldrums. Is this how you're all going to escape the Isle? Waiting for the wind to come to topple the dominoes for you? Pathetic.
I'm giving you the chance to use these fingers. Fuck the sea. None of us are swimming out there and making it alive. Our best option is to go deeper. Deeper into the island.
Innocents will die. Innocence will die. They don't care.
Let's make them.
I usually hate doing lists, because all it does is conveniently put words into people's mouths for them to manipulate to their own ends and hide behind, instead of allowing people to speak up for themselves. It's too direct a conversation piece for everyone involved. No, Sorian. I prefer the indirect approach of abstractly teasing people to see what their priorities are.
But, I'm choosing to sell-out for once. If you want more of this corporate-ordered direct-to-home-DVD list shit straight from me, let's go Plan 800 Feet. Lynch someone else today.
Or, kill me now and take the easy reward from my death; fine, I don't care about losing. I never have. I care about "winning". I care about COURAGE.
Follow me, sightseers; follow me to the heart of dankness. Do you know who I am? I'm fucking H.P. Lovecraft. We arrived here on a cruise. Now let's depart on the Love Boat.
I'm the one who fucks the tentacles.
S'MAKE YOUR CHOICE, NERDS.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A:- Play the main quest with Sorian, who is sworn to carry to your burdens. (Lynch Blargonaut today, and I shall bestow my Blessing upon you, no ire.)
OR
B:- Take my fucking side-quest to the heart of the Shivering Isles. (Don't lynch me today, because I'm a known quantity; instead, lynch an unknown quantity to gain 100% unknown info, and gamble with the fact that I may or may not survive to Day 3 for you to use me. It's entirely a cosmic gamble that relies on power role distribution and blind faith in the stars. Let's fuck. REMEMBER: My Blessing's damage output scales the higher the level/Day you are when you claim me, but only to a point. Lynch me on Day 3. It's the sweet spot.)
Day 1 is more for gambling than day 2 is and by what seems like luck, we came out ahead by the start of day 2. This game is tuned around power roles so I have to take everything people have been saying into account based on the assumption that someone may have found something interesting last night. Gut reaction is no, I am not convinced at the moment that you are cult but, as an arbitrary gauge, I think you are more likely to be a cultist than Coppa is. I do think there is a cultist between the two of you and that's why my interest is squared more on your shoulders, I gain the benefit of Rats being so sure on Coppa that he will make sure to apply the appropriate pressure there so my time was better spent helping Scrafty with you.
I fully expect to be dead tonight or tomorrow night. I've become a nuisance for too many people that I'm sure to have kicked over a bee's nest at some point and that's fine. While I'm still here, I'll keep digging up dirt and when I get killed, congratulations, you'll have flipped over a tourist who's only power was his ability to apply pressure during the day. This is also why I want each day phase to last as long as possible, my time is ticking and my death will most likely come with a night phase.
Blargonaut
Banned
That typo was intentional
Blargonaut
Banned
Pass, I still truly believe that killing you today is our best bet to end up with the most amount of information. I'll continue with the main quest.
Blargonaut
Banned
THE BEST LOOT IS ALWAYS IN A SIDE-QUEST
WRONG CHOICE, SORIAN
WRROOOOOOOOOOONNNNGGGGGGGGGGG
Lord of Castamere
Member
VOTE: Coppanuva
Thank you for helping us take the time to question Charleston.
I'm not ready to change my vote yet, but damn if you aren't persuasive, Blarg.
Also, I hadn't considered the idea that my infrequent posts are being seen as "visiting the side forum." I've been hanging my hat between here, Destiny-GAF and Metal Gear GAF. I don't post super often because my opinions either haven't changed, or I'm waiting for the crazy to die down before I speak.
I'll try to be in here more often, though, so you won't have to worry about me.
Also, I hadn't considered the idea that my infrequent posts are being seen as "visiting the side forum." I've been hanging my hat between here, Destiny-GAF and Metal Gear GAF. I don't post super often because my opinions either haven't changed, or I'm waiting for the crazy to die down before I speak.
I'll try to be in here more often, though, so you won't have to worry about me.
Werewolf Jones
Member
Thank you for giving me a free pass on the behalf of your fellow players.
Lord of Castamere
Member
No no no. I want you dead, but at this point I feel Coppanovo is a better choice.
I would've changed my vote last night, but I didn't think it counted.
Blarg, you are so fixated on those who call for your lynching in calling them all cult. Myself, Ultron, Sorian, etc. Blarg, and I'm speaking for the others here too: we don't care about you. We just want you gone so we can start focusing on things that actually matter like actually finding cultists and rooting them out. You are an obstacle in that path, and have been for the entirety of the game.
Hey man, at least spell it correctly...
But fair enough, I wouldn't have it any other way.
Blargonaut
Banned
That's exactly what a follower of the Old Ones would say. You worship insignificance and promote indifference. You're a Cultist. I feel it.
And if you're not Cult, then you're "Cult".
So, for myself and those just now joining us, (Hi, Danganronpa and Archer players!) Here's where we stand:
(Carry On Wayward Son plays)
Blargonaut is a third-party player. His role is H.P. Lovecraft. If he is lynched, the town gets a night without Mafia lynches. If he outlives three cult lynches, he wins. As far as we know, (according to info from Blarg and Matt Attack,) nothing happens if the cult sacrifices Blarg.
Matt Attack is also a third party player, who is apparently the kid from Neverending Story. (How this makes sense, I have no clue.) His goal is to kill Blargonaut before three cult lynches have occurred.
The majority of the current votes favor lynching Blargonaut, since it would give us a night free of Mafia kills. However, since there were two kills last night, there might still be a kill tonight even if we lynch Blarg. Also, some fear a power going to the cult if they lynch Blarg. Just because Matt and Blarg are not aware of any such power, does not mean that it doesn't exist. Thus, they hope to deny them that power by lynching Blarg today.
Finally, there are also those who are tired of Blarg's antics, and want to move on to the "real game."
Another group argues that killing Blarg tonight is not a wise move. Their arguments break into a variety of groups. Some say that we should do our best to protect Blarg, and use his ability when it would be more useful. (This would be difficult, as the town lost it's Doctor on night one.) Some argue that the Mafia will surely lynch Blarg tonight, which will effectively prevent the mafia from night-killing anyone else, so is there really a difference between us killing Blarg and them killing Blarg? Better then to use that lynch on someone they find suspicious - Like Coppanuva, who is that group's primary target.
A handful of players have followed Scrafty Devil to vote for GreatCharleston, in order to make him speak up on his opinions. Since he has now spoken, a few of those votes have fallen off, but some still find him suspicious.
Oh, and Neuromancer wants to kill Sorian, and Sorian expects the Mafia to kill him any night now.
Did I miss anything?
(Carry On Wayward Son plays)
Blargonaut is a third-party player. His role is H.P. Lovecraft. If he is lynched, the town gets a night without Mafia lynches. If he outlives three cult lynches, he wins. As far as we know, (according to info from Blarg and Matt Attack,) nothing happens if the cult sacrifices Blarg.
Matt Attack is also a third party player, who is apparently the kid from Neverending Story. (How this makes sense, I have no clue.) His goal is to kill Blargonaut before three cult lynches have occurred.
The majority of the current votes favor lynching Blargonaut, since it would give us a night free of Mafia kills. However, since there were two kills last night, there might still be a kill tonight even if we lynch Blarg. Also, some fear a power going to the cult if they lynch Blarg. Just because Matt and Blarg are not aware of any such power, does not mean that it doesn't exist. Thus, they hope to deny them that power by lynching Blarg today.
Finally, there are also those who are tired of Blarg's antics, and want to move on to the "real game."
Another group argues that killing Blarg tonight is not a wise move. Their arguments break into a variety of groups. Some say that we should do our best to protect Blarg, and use his ability when it would be more useful. (This would be difficult, as the town lost it's Doctor on night one.) Some argue that the Mafia will surely lynch Blarg tonight, which will effectively prevent the mafia from night-killing anyone else, so is there really a difference between us killing Blarg and them killing Blarg? Better then to use that lynch on someone they find suspicious - Like Coppanuva, who is that group's primary target.
A handful of players have followed Scrafty Devil to vote for GreatCharleston, in order to make him speak up on his opinions. Since he has now spoken, a few of those votes have fallen off, but some still find him suspicious.
Oh, and Neuromancer wants to kill Sorian, and Sorian expects the Mafia to kill him any night now.
Did I miss anything?
Not sure how I feel about the bolded list considering that I currently distrust the two of you. Ultron more so than you but I thought I'd throw it other there. That being said, yes, the distraction is just going to keep cutting away at what we are actually here to do, kill cultists.
This still bothers me. It's almost like you are trying to goad us into voting for you. If you flip tourist, it won't mean much. Yes, it will discredit Rats predictions but it doesn't actually cast suspicion on anyone. He would just be making a bad call like I did with Tucah. Regardless, of whether you are an ordinary tourist or a power role, you should always be fighting with everything to stay alive, any time we lose a tourist, it's a small victory for the cultists.
At this point, I either think you are going to flip cult or ordinary tourist and I'm hoping I have more time to figure out which way it will go since we have a Blarg power to activate today.
Neuromancer
Member
Well at least I know you're totally full of shit now, so that's helpful to me.
ScraftyDevil
Banned
I'm no judge. Just an observer who thirsts for truth and sactimony.
Ahem, well, I guess there ain't much more we can glean from ya today. But keep in mind that alla my beliefs are wholly unironic, an' one-hundred percent genuine. Irony is so blasé in this day an' age, don't ya think?
Werewolf Jones
Member
Is it the other 50% that lead you to vote for me that one time?
Really, though, if I'm killed and nothing comes up, what are y'all gonna do just be like "Well... Damn." Because if that's all then I DEMAND JUSTICE.
As the days tick by and more roles are revealed, it'll be good to look back and see what connections were made and what they could mean. If you really are going to flip as "nothing" then you won't get much justice because you keep skirting issues and not forming those connections that we would need to investigate.
Blargonaut
Banned
How can I possibly fight this
He's too big and strong for me
Please don't kill me
I'm begging you
Don't kill me
Please