• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Chip Yields are the problem with 360 supply shortage

Chiggs said:
:lol

Sorry guys, I was just being sarcastic there (mocking anecdotal evidence, and the fact that everyone seems to have a friend who's a Gamestop manager). When I read Dr_Cogent's response to my original post, I thought he was being sarcastic, too.

Sarcasm in writing is sometimes difficult. I didn't pick up on it myself.
 
Chiggs said:
:lol

Sorry guys, I was just being sarcastic there (mocking anecdotal evidence, and the fact that everyone seems to have a friend who's a Gamestop manager). When I read Dr_Cogent's response to my original post, I thought he was being sarcastic, too.

...it's not very hard to know someone who's a gamestop manager... and considering the forum you're in right now... again... not exactly a surprise.
 
Are they sure didn't use faulty capacitors? I mean overheating, hard drive problems... all symptoms of faulty capacitors.

In case you couldn' tell I was speaking in jest. Although anyone who has owned a Dell system probably knows what I"m talking about. Fucking maxtor drives.
 
I dont see how reports from someone who knows the supply chain is "anecdotal evidence"
 
Chiggs said:
I have a friend who is on his eleventh Xbox 360. Something's definitely wrong here. And that's saying something.



THEYRE ALL BROEKN.

Wow is Microsoft using a 1986 Delorean as their shipping vehicle? :lol :lol

edit: too bad you weren't serious :(
 
sp0rsk said:
I dont see how reports from someone who knows the supply chain is "anecdotal evidence"

There was comment earlier from someone stating he was on his second defective Xbox, and that he's "not the only one." This, of course, was taken by certain members of the forum as further evidence that the Xbox 360 is highly defective. I don't believe that for a second, but whatever...

As far as Gamestop managers go, what they say can easily be anecdotal evidence, considering that a lot of them don't see the bigger picture. Now, if they're involved in sales trending or defective units trending reports, then I'll shut my mouth.
 
I have five friends and relatives who also purchased the 360. Out of the six of us, only two of us have had bad units.
How does a failiure rate of 30% warrant the word "only"?
 
teiresias said:
How can there be major issues with the HDD manufacturing in this day and age - of a 20G harddrive at that? Who are they getting them from?

yeah, that rumor has got to be bullshit for a number of reasons. One, there's more HDD drives out there than there are consoles (you can finally find a seperate HDD relatively easily, whereas consoles are extremely scarce). Two, they're using a standard laptop HDD with a special connector (modified USB or SATA connector IIRC), so it's not like the actual parts themselves are scarce either.
 
elostyle said:
How does a failiure rate of 30% warrant the word "only"?

Come on, now - that's still a 70% success rate! If you were going in for experimental heart surgery, and they told you that you have a 70% chance of surviving, you'd probably be somewhat optimistic.
 
Goreomedy said:
BULLFUCKINGSHIT!


Why don't you call up Best Buy and ask them why the hell they're holding their shipments in the back of the store for Dec. 18th.

Ask Gamestop why they're selling expensive online bundles, yet they've got customers who pre-ordered and still haven't gotten theirs yet.

Ask the other retailers who we've been hearing about that are selling their shipments on ebay for double the price instead of putting them out for customers.

After all the shitty games retail is playing, I think people need to get off Microsoft's nutsack a little bit. Obviously Microsoft isnt' sending enough out to fill demand, but I don't have any doubt that they're sending them out to stores, but they seem to be getting lost somewhere in the abyss of greed once they hit retail and they don't seem to be finding their way onto shelves.
 
Well they lost there chance to get my money. I woulda picked one up day 1 but after playing a bunch at work To me the console is not worth the current asking price. I bought into the hype and they coulda had me if they had more units available.
 
elostyle said:
How does a failiure rate of 30% warrant the word "only"?
This is true.. 'cause I asked two people returning their 360s if they were faulty. Both were.

This just in: x360 failiure rate is 100%!
 
Chiggs said:
Come on, now - that's still a 70% success rate! If you were going in for experimental heart surgery, and they told you that you have a 70% chance of surviving, you'd probably be somewhat optimistic.
You pay $400 for a heart surgery with a 70% chance of survival that you don't even need? ;)
 
Are these the same Gamestop managers who got a secret company memo that said that the PS3 was pushed back to 2007 because the dev kits were melting?

Just curious, because these guys have a lot of inside info for being retail employees.
 
The supply for both XBox 360 and PS3, once Sony launchs it, will be tight for quite some time. Both consoles have very large and fast CPU's and GPU's. It's going to be hard for both Microsoft and Sony to make enough to satisfy demand.
 
bill0527 said:
Why don't you call up Best Buy and ask them why the hell they're holding their shipments in the back of the store for Dec. 18th.

Ask Gamestop why they're selling expensive online bundles, yet they've got customers who pre-ordered and still haven't gotten theirs yet.

Ask the other retailers who we've been hearing about that are selling their shipments on ebay for double the price instead of putting them out for customers.

After all the shitty games retail is playing, I think people need to get off Microsoft's nutsack a little bit. Obviously Microsoft isnt' sending enough out to fill demand, but I don't have any doubt that they're sending them out to stores, but they seem to be getting lost somewhere in the abyss of greed once they hit retail and they don't seem to be finding their way onto shelves.


This is one thing I've been curious about as well to. I'm quite sure that the guys that work the shipping and warehouse at a lot of these major retailers are far beyond skimming a few units off the top and selling them at hack pirces for profit. [/sarcasm]. I have no evidence that is happening, but if I were warehouse staff, making a little more than minimum wage, I'd be tempted to skim a couple for for especially with all the news surrounding the console shortage.

And there have got to be a cache of consoles somewhere? I know of a few people who are getting faulty consoles replaced in a hurry. So M$ customer support is doing a great job, but somebodys got a stash somewhere.
 
Brimstone said:
The supply for both XBox 360 and PS3, once Sony launchs it, will be tight for quite some time. Both consoles have very large and fast CPU's and GPU's. It's going to be hard for both Microsoft and Sony to make enough to satisfy demand.
It was the same deal with PS2 so I dont know why anyone would be surprised by shit like this. GAF just likes to "run with the meat" so to speak. Especially when it concerns Xbox.
 
Only slightly offtopic...

http://news.yahoo.com/s/nm/20051208/od_uk_nm/oukoe_uk_microsoft_ballmer

Microsoft Corp.'s Chief Executive Steve Ballmer will have to shop around for an
Xbox 360 game console this holiday season just like the rest of us -- it doesn't come with his job.

"The Ballmer children do not have their Xbox 360 yet. I'm in the same boat as many of you," Ballmer said. "Thanks to the wonders of Sarbanes-Oxley, management does not get a free Xbox 360," he quipped at a meeting of technology industry executives.

The Xbox 360 debuted in North America on November 22 and Microsoft estimates that it will sell 5.5 million units worldwide by the end of next June.
 
PhatSaqs said:
It was the same deal with PS2 so I dont know why anyone would be surprised by shit like this. GAF just likes to "run with the meat" so to speak. Especially when it concerns Xbox.
Brushing aside your renewed attempts to play the victim card here, there's certainly some meat that should be run with here given the fact that had MS not been so intent to launch early AND to launch in all three major regions within weeks of each other, they very likely would have been able to reduce some of these issues.
 
AirBrian said:
SOX has absolutely nothing to do with if management can get a free X360 or not.

It's possible. SOX made our company take away the Employee of the Month's paid day off, and lowered the amount of the bonus check, as well.
 
kaching said:
Brushing aside your renewed attempts to play the victim card here, there's certainly some meat that should be run with here given the fact that had MS not been so intent to launch early AND to launch in all three major regions within weeks of each other, they very likely would have been able to reduce some of these issues.
And had you not posted this MS would still be in the predicament they are. Not saying I dont agree, just that it doesnt mean much right now. And it also doesnt change the fact that GAF loves MS meat, despite your attempts to brush the issue aside :p.
 
Chiggs said:
It's possible. SOX made our company take away the Employee of the Month's paid day off, and lowered the amount of the bonus check, as well.

Sounds like your company made an excuse to screw their employees! :lol

On July 30, 2002, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (Public Law 104-204) went into effect, and changed the corporate landscape in the United States in regard to financial reporting and auditing for publicly traded companies. Written The law establishes stringent financial reporting requirements for companies doing business in the United States.
 
Chiggs said:
It's possible. SOX made our company take away the Employee of the Month's paid day off, and lowered the amount of the bonus check, as well.
SOX doesn't seem to have stopped MS from giving special X360s to the X360 team itself though...

PhatSaqs said:
And had you not posted this MS would still be in the predicament they are. Not saying I dont agree, just that it doesnt mean much right now. And it also doesnt change the fact that GAF loves MS meat, despite your attempts to brush the issue aside :p.
Oh gosh, you mean we're having a discussion that doesn't necessarily create action items? How silly of us!

And GAF likes all kind of meat - whenever it's offered, GAF sinks its teeth in.
 
Chiggs said:
It's possible. SOX made our company take away the Employee of the Month's paid day off, and lowered the amount of the bonus check, as well.
I doubt it. This sounds like your company used it as an excuse. SOX does not take away the rights to employee gifts, etc., it just makes the reporting and auditing of these transactions stricter. MS can give whatever it wants to its employees, it just must be reported in a timely fashion and be taxed appropriately. After SOX, corporations are significantly reducing the number of expense-side employee gifts and shifting them to HR where they can be tracked and audited easier for income tax purposes.
 
maynerd said:
Sounds like your company made an excuse to screw their employees! :lol

On July 30, 2002, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (Public Law 104-204) went into effect, and changed the corporate landscape in the United States in regard to financial reporting and auditing for publicly traded companies. Written The law establishes stringent financial reporting requirements for companies doing business in the United States.

AirBrian said:
I doubt it. This sounds like your company used it as an excuse. SOX does not take away the rights to employee gifts, etc., it just makes the reporting and auditing of these transactions stricter. MS can give whatever it wants to its employees, it just must be reported in a timely fashion and be taxed appropriately. After SOX, corporations are significantly reducing the number of expense-side employee gifts and shifting them to HR where they can be tracked and audited easier for income tax purposes.


Well, I've been lied to again by my company. :lol
 
The reason you don't see any 360s in stores is because all the new ones are going to people who have had to return theirs :(

:)
 
Mine's worked perfectly so far, but a few days after launch I purchased the $50 Best Buy 2-year replacement plan as an insurance measure. With the amount of heat this thing puts out and the constant (loud) spinning of the DVD drive, I can almost foresee it wearing out from the stress before that time period ends.
 
puck1337 said:
Know what system won't have yield problems at launch? That's right, Revolution!


Of course not. if the chip fabrication is having poor yields Nintendo can just grab a bunch of chips out of some old TI-83 calculators. :)
 
For what its worth, our store 360 just died today after working perfectly fine yesterday. We've also had 3 out of launch 34 that are dead, that I know of.
 
Nerevar said:
yeah, that rumor has got to be bullshit for a number of reasons. One, there's more HDD drives out there than there are consoles (you can finally find a seperate HDD relatively easily, whereas consoles are extremely scarce). Two, they're using a standard laptop HDD with a special connector (modified USB or SATA connector IIRC), so it's not like the actual parts themselves are scarce either.
It's not really a modified SATA connector. It's just a normal SATA connector. The enclosure has a proprietary connector, though I believe.
 
Wasn't chip yields the presumed reason (being the most plausible after all)?

Unless you believed TXB forum rumours they were so good they were going to up the clockspeed...
 
kaching said:
Brushing aside your renewed attempts to play the victim card here, there's certainly some meat that should be run with here given the fact that had MS not been so intent to launch early AND to launch in all three major regions within weeks of each other, they very likely would have been able to reduce some of these issues.
QFMFT.
 
Top Bottom