• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Chipotle's "300 Calorie" Burrito Lawsuit

Status
Not open for further replies.

Kaladin

Member
In a lawsuit, filed November 16 in the Superior Court of Los Angeles, three nutrition-conscious patrons claim they were tricked into eating high-calorie Chorizo burritos after seeing Chipotle advertisements that suggested the swaddled meals were merely 300 calories. One plaintiff, David Desmond, realized he had been duped when he felt “excessively full” after eating the burrito, according to the lawsuit. Along with the other two plaintiffs, Edward Gurevich and Young Hoon Kim, Desmond is seeking unspecified damages and a class action-status for the complaint.

Their suit stems from one sign in particular, seen independently by the plaintiffs in Chipotle restaurants around Los Angeles. The advertisement shows a picture of a brimming burrito and says: “CHORIZO BURRITO: Try our new deliciously seasoned, perfectly grilled spicy chicken and pork sausage in a burrito with white rice, black beans, fresh tomato salsa, and sprinkle of cheese.” The bottom of the sign reads “300 Calories.”
The trio claim they understood the sign to mean that the whole burrito was 300 calories, given the picture and the detailed description. However, according to Chipotle’s own nutrition information, a single serving of the chorizo alone is 300 calories. When it’s wrapped into a burrito with all the fixings listed on the sign, the total calorie count comes out to 1,055—more than half of a standard 2,000 calorie per day diet.


The plaintiff’s say the signage amounts to an “unfair, unlawful and/or fraudulent and unconscionable practice of grossly misrepresenting the nutrition values of its food products,” which breaks local health and safety codes, plus business codes. In addition, the three claim that because Chipotle has marketed their Mexican Grill restaurants as serving “food with integrity,” customers are “lulled into a false belief that the items they are eating are healthier than they are, and thereby encouraging repeat patronage…”

CvQInptWYAAPUdx-300x400.jpg


Seriously? That really looks like the whole burrito is 300 calories. Who is going to log onto the website to double check in a restaurant when you're making a decision on what to order? What would even be on a 300 calorie fast food burrito?

http://arstechnica.com/science/2016...customers-sue-over-misleading-nutrition-info/
 

bigkrev

Member
Id take that to mean that the Chorizo itself was 300 calories, but yeah, that's a really bad sign and I could see people thinking the while burrito was 300 calories
 
Yeah, that sign is definitely misleading. I'm someone who focuses pretty strongly on calorie counts for most meals and this kind of signage does make you think that the burrito is 300 cal
Edit: for me personally I think I would figure it out right up front, but I can see someone who is just getting started and isn't used to translating caloric values into real world food estimates getting fooled
 

LakeEarth

Member
Clearly all that food in the description couldn't possibly just be 300 calories. But the sign is most definitely suggesting that it is.
 

Eidan

Member
They were "tricked" into thinking the entire burrito was 300 calories? If they're as nutrition conscious as the article suggests, they must have had a burrito at Chipotle before. Hell, they would have likely used Chiptole's own nutrition calculator. Then they'd know there was no chance in hell the whole damn thing was 300 calories.
 
I know its false advertising, but just looking at the ingredients and the size of the burrito, how could you honestly think that was 300 calories.
 

NervousXtian

Thought Emoji Movie was good. Take that as you will.
Whoever made the sign should be fired.

..but who thought that'd be 300 calories?

The tortilla itself is 300 calories.
 
I believe their arguement was "The burrito's construction is a la carte, the only guaranteed part (the meat) comes out to 300".

Which is bullshit which probably doesn't even account for the tortilla since that is technically optional as well. They are burritos, Chipotle, everyone knows that they are bad for you. Stop trying to pretend.
 

New002

Member
I was at Chipotle with my GF recently and pointed that sign out to her because I thought it was super misleading since it was only the chorizo topping that was 300 calories.

I've recently started counting all my calories which is why it hit me right away, but I could certainly see people being misled by that sign.

Terrible signage.
 
I know its false advertising, but just looking at the ingredients and the size of the burrito, how could you honestly think that was 300 calories.
If you are new to the calorie counting game, then I could see that happening. I could also see someone who is hungry and is counting calories on a diet being lulled into wishful thinking that convinces them that it's really 300calories.
 
Yeah this sign is garbage. I spotted this the moment they put it up and pointed it out to my friend. It makes it look like it might be a mini burrito or something.

Chorizo is great though. Get a bowl to save on calories.
 

Rockandrollclown

lookwhatyou'vedone
Its obviously not 300 calories, but signage should be clear. If just the chorizo is 300 calories there should at least be fine print stating *Chorizo only.
 
People are really, really bad at estimating calories. The act of taking just one week out of your life to do a food journal and calorie count, even if you don't explicitly want to lose weight, is a great way to increase your familiarity with the real caloric content of what you eat.

That being said, Chipotle is constantly engaged in shitty business practices (our food is healthy because no GMOs! ... also please don't be bothered that we ignore basic food safety and engage in wage theft with our employees), so I fully support this lawsuit.
 

LakeEarth

Member
Do you have that much faith in the American public tho ��

Yeah, Subway's success is owed to their advertising campaign which convinced people that eating a loaf of bread was healthy for you. A masterful pivot from "we have much less fat than fast food" to "we are healthier than fast food" to "we are healthier".
 

Big Blue

Member
I understand FITGaf would be able to see that it was an obvious mistake, but to someone just starting to count calories, that is sign is extremely misleading.
 

Guevara

Member
A single tortilla, by itself, is like 150 calories.

A big one for a burrito is probably 300 calories or more already.

220px-NCI_flour_tortillas.jpg
 

Corpekata

Banned
They are going to get hurt for this. Yeah, common sense and all that, but judges love throwing the book at defendants for things like this just to teach a lesson.
 

Zukkoyaki

Member
I can't believe somebody approved that sign. I mean, I know what they're going for (chorizo serving is 300 calories) but when you're in mass marketing like that and developing materials you have to assume that people are stupid and a half. I work in graphic design and community relations myself and I showed this to some people. Got a hardy round of laughs!
 

Iksenpets

Banned
Like, anyone claiming to be health conscious should know there's no way that's 300 calories, but at the same time, that really is what the sign seems to be saying. It says "Chorizo Burrito" "300 calories", not "Chorizo" "300 calories".
 
Id take that to mean that the Chorizo itself was 300 calories, but yeah, that's a really bad sign and I could see people thinking the while burrito was 300 calories

You don't really think that, unless you also think only the chorizo itself is $7.73. The sign clearly and unambiguously states that the burrito is 300 calories. Maybe, maybe, you could interpret it another way, if it only said "Chorizo" at the top.
 

New002

Member
I can't believe somebody approved that sign. I mean, I know what they're going for (chorizo serving is 300 calories) but when you're in mass marketing like that and developing materials you have to assume that people are stupid and a half. I work in graphic design and community relations myself and I showed this to some people. Got a hardy round of laughs!

Yeah I can't help but feel like they bypassed their legal team on that one. When I worked for a big company doing graphics we had to get all our in-store signage approved by legal. It was a huge pain, but can't be getting sued.
 

NewFresh

Member
As someone who has worked in food labeling and calorie declarations.... You dun goofed Chipotle.

Someone's going to loose there job over this.
 

Kaladin

Member
There is no way to interpret that sign as being chorizo only. It says CHORIZO BURRITO up top and it describes the burrito with a picture of the burrito on the side. Nowhere does it state that a single serving of chorizo is 300 calories. It just says 300 calories.
 

mm04

Member
As someone who counts his calories and uses MyFitnessPal, is there small print that says "*Tortilla not included"? Because no way is it 300 calories.
 

Minyobi

Member
I don't work at Chipotle, but I have to walk customers through awful signs like that every day. It is annoying, to say the least.

Thankfully, said customers clarify things first before suing the damn place.
 

Hazmat

Member
You don't really think that, unless you also think only the chorizo itself is $7.73. The sign clearly and unambiguously states that the burrito is 300 calories. Maybe, maybe, you could interpret it another way, if it only said "Chorizo" at the top.

Yep. This sign feels like someone fucked up when laying it out and nobody in the approval process noticed. It clearly says that the burrito is $7.73 and 300 calories.
 
I'm pretty sure that its just a case of someone calling them out on a misleading sign, which it definitely is.

The marketing dept fucked up and theyre most likely gonna have to pay something. But chipotle makes nutrional menus readily available and its very obvious how many calories is in a burrito.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom