LordBritish
Member
pumped...
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
fudgybrownie
Member
It's only available for current generation consoles so would that even matter?
ResurrectedContrarian
Suffers with mild autism
fugly corporate-friendly, badly rendered cheerleaders incoming, it seems, to the surprise of no one
Michigan cheerleaders in game:
Actual Michigan cheerleaders, current year:
Georgia Tech cheerleaders, in game
actual Georgia Tech cheerleaders on the wagon
So it's not just that they diversified a little... it's more that in every shot of every team, they have roughly the same setup of 90% "diverse" (vaguely asian, mostly black, etc), maybe one white girl (with mannish, badly rendered face), and zero resemblance to the actual locations and people.
I mean, I don't really care since this seems to be like Madden in general which means it has trash gameplay to begin with. But they go on and on in these trailers about capturing the campus / cultural feel of each team... while in every shot of cheer teams, you have exactly the same "corporate diversity" and un-feminine cheer faces, regardless of location. It's just so fake.
Michigan cheerleaders in game:
Actual Michigan cheerleaders, current year:
Georgia Tech cheerleaders, in game
actual Georgia Tech cheerleaders on the wagon
So it's not just that they diversified a little... it's more that in every shot of every team, they have roughly the same setup of 90% "diverse" (vaguely asian, mostly black, etc), maybe one white girl (with mannish, badly rendered face), and zero resemblance to the actual locations and people.
I mean, I don't really care since this seems to be like Madden in general which means it has trash gameplay to begin with. But they go on and on in these trailers about capturing the campus / cultural feel of each team... while in every shot of cheer teams, you have exactly the same "corporate diversity" and un-feminine cheer faces, regardless of location. It's just so fake.
Last edited:
ManaByte
Gold Member
fugly corporate-friendly, badly rendered cheerleaders incoming, it seems, to the surprise of no one
Michigan cheerleaders in game:
Actual Michigan cheerleaders, current year:
Georgia Tech cheerleaders, in game
actual Georgia Tech cheerleaders on the wagon
So it's not just that they diversified a little... it's more that in every shot of every team, they have roughly the same setup of 90% "diverse" (vaguely asian, mostly black, etc), maybe one white girl (with mannish, badly rendered face), and zero resemblance to the actual locations and people.
I mean, I don't really care since this seems to be like Madden in general which means it has trash gameplay to begin with. But they go on and on in these trailers about capturing the campus / cultural feel of each team... while in every shot of cheer teams, you have exactly the same "corporate diversity" and un-feminine cheer faces, regardless of location. It's just so fake.
It's a college football game. I'm sorry but there are going to be non-white people in it.
ResurrectedContrarian
Suffers with mild autism
way to misread
The goal is to have each locale and fanbase/cheerleaders/sideline etc look different and like the actual people -- so, people in Boston vs South Carolina vs Michigan vs Mississippi should be recognizable as their places, instead of a weirdly santized mush of diversity filters over every face to where it looks like an alternate universe. And also, the goal is to not have the StarField effect of weirdly ugly faces everywhere that seem to have been built to avoid visual appeal, that I already see happening in the trailer.
LordCBH
Member
ManaByte
Gold Member
I'm just worried about the balancing on the in-game wear and tear injuries.
ResurrectedContrarian
Suffers with mild autism
Madden is NFL, no way they'd get rid of that (even if it does suck, and I'd take even the worst 90s football games over it).
This is college, so it will be a different series in parallel. But it looks way too much like Madden's engine to me. I wish they'd have given the license to anyone but EA.
Mattdaddy
Gold Member
This series used to run alongside Madden and came out every year and was wildly popular on its own back in the day. Madden is the NFL, this is college football so they actually cover different territory and can coexist.
About 10 years ago, this series had to stop due to legal issues with college players not getting paid but their likeness was getting used anyway. Thats all been sorted now and the series is making a return. I think the special edition is actually bundled with Madden
You used to be able to import your college players from this into Madden and then draft them to your favorite team, so they actually kinda compliment each other in a way if youre a football fanatic.
Last edited:
ManaByte
Gold Member
It's due to the NIL contracts. I know someone who's son plays div 1 and he signed one (which means he'll likely be in the game).
The $100 Deluxe of CFB and the $100 Deluxe of Madden are being sold in a MVP bundle for $150. So you save $50 buying them together, and most people will buy both since you can then draft your seniors into Madden.
Mattdaddy
Gold Member
I wonder how many players didn't take the deal to be in the game and what happens if theyre like a starter.
Are they completely out, like I wonder if they replace them with the backup if he took the deal? Or do they just generate a random character with similar stats?
Haha will be curious if any big names didnt do it. I think most did, but not totally sure.
Thats actually a pretty good deal for NCAA and Madden together if youre wanting to go all in
Last edited:
ManaByte
Gold Member
I don't see why someone wouldn't sign a NIL contract. It's pretty good money for someone in college. Especially if they aren't likely to be drafted.
AJUMP23
Parody of actual AJUMP23
I think there are only 2. The Manning kid in TX and one other.
Mattdaddy
Gold Member
Yeah agree, I thought originally they only got $600 to be in the game... I was wondering if any bigger names were holding out like "nah Im worth more."
But I just looked it up it actually says "a minimum of $600" plus they are free to earn money doing promotional work. So the more recognizable names might still be getting paid well.
It also says players that say no will be completely excluded and blocked from being manually added
ManaByte
Gold Member
Yeah agree, I thought originally they only got $600 to be in the game... I was wondering if any bigger names were holding out like "nah Im worth more."
But I just looked it up it actually says "a minimum of $600" plus they are free to earn money doing promotional work. So the more recognizable names might still be getting paid well.
It also says players that say no will be completely excluded and blocked from being manually added
It covers way more than just the game. Some of the deals are in the thousands of dollars. They make good money off them.
One year of NIL: How much have athletes made?
Social media remains the most common way for college athletes to benefit from name, image and likeness compensation.
www.nbcnewyork.com
Last edited:
Zero_Karisma
Neo Member
Yeah but if it is balanced well this is an excellent addition and really adds to the importance of the toughness of the players you recruit and how you use them.
Mattdaddy
Gold Member
It covers way more than just the game. Some of the deals are in the thousands of dollars. They make good money off them.
One year of NIL: How much have athletes made?
Social media remains the most common way for college athletes to benefit from name, image and likeness compensation.
Is NIL completely all inclusive though? Like take it or leave it for everything? Maybe it is I honestly dont know. I knew some guys are making millions but I thought if you wanted to individually opt-out of the EA game you could, and still get paid in other ways. But maybe it doesnt work like that.
AJUMP23
Parody of actual AJUMP23
You do not have to take the NIL deal EA offered, but you will not be in the game.
It is like NBA games use to have everyone but Jordan because he was not covered under the NBA licensing agreement.
ResurrectedContrarian
Suffers with mild autism
Hudo
Member
Thanks for clearing that up for me. I did not know that college football and NFL were two separate things. Now I know. Just one more stupid question: Do college football and NFL share the same rules? I assume so because, in the end, football is football.
ManaByte
Gold Member
No there are a lot of differences.
How NFL and college football are not the same
The college game has its charms, but for those who love the strategy of the game, NFL football—thanks to roster sizes, familiar names, uniforms, overtime rules and, most of all, field dimensions—is unbeatable
www.si.com
High School football is played on Fridays, College on Saturdays, NFL on Sundays (and Mondays and Thursdays).
Hudo
Member
Ah, OK. Thanks again! Will read it when I'm on the shitter.No there are a lot of differences.
How NFL and college football are not the same
The college game has its charms, but for those who love the strategy of the game, NFL football—thanks to roster sizes, familiar names, uniforms, overtime rules and, most of all, field dimensions—is unbeatable
High School football is played on Fridays, College on Saturdays, NFL on Sundays (and Mondays and Thursdays).
ResurrectedContrarian
Suffers with mild autism
College can be more entertaining due to the variability of the game... instead of your QB and stars being multi-million dollar assets that you protect, and the whole team being a strictly monetary enterprise, there are rivalries and crazy out-of-the-box risky plays happening everywhere. Or even just busted plays that turn into a surprise.
I watch NFL too, but it's a little too streamlined now, as happens with many high level competitions. Sometimes upper-mid level is more intense.
I watch NFL too, but it's a little too streamlined now, as happens with many high level competitions. Sometimes upper-mid level is more intense.
MarkMe2525
Gold Member
It will undoubtedly suck, which is a shame. Better off finding an old copy of NCAA for a Gen 8 or 9 system.
ResurrectedContrarian
Suffers with mild autism
Or even better, try one of these hacks
Tecmo Super Bowl - NCAA 2K24 Edition
The classic NES sports title, updated with 32 NCAA Division One teams from the 2023-24 season! Enjoy
.thumb.jpg.8faa0377110efe03494a98af1b3703b8.jpg)
TECMO NCAA 2023: NATIONAL CHAMPION EDITION
•28 team base ROM •all 3 seasons now pushed to 16 games (as opposed to 10 on last year's release) •updated graphics include: mini helmets, large helmets, end zones and team logos •CSP sprites that match the cut scenes and look great on the two tone turf •select teams with multiple end zones depen...
tecmobowl.org
Teh Chosen Juan
Member
it'll never end. the pussies won.
Mattdaddy
Gold Member
it'll never end. the pussies won.
Im not actually sure what you're referring to, but Im gonna assume it was everything around Horns Down getting cancelled and Im gonna completely agree with you. And then Ill take the opportunity to post this in solidarity:
Last edited:
Topher
Gold Member
The crux of the game is the same. There are variations in the rules at each level.
StereoVsn
Member
Yeah, basically the cheer teams look samey and unified now. That’s weird because the comparison is super easy to do as you just have to turn on the TV on a random Saturday during the season.
ManaByte
Gold Member
They did exactly that and got sued.
Why did EA Sports stop making College Football? Exploring the potential reasons behind game's decade-long hiatus
EA Sports announced on Feb. 15 that the fan-favorite football video game, College Football, will return in the summer of 2024.
www.sportskeeda.com
thanks.They did exactly that and got sued.
Why did EA Sports stop making College Football? Exploring the potential reasons behind game's decade-long hiatus
EA Sports announced on Feb. 15 that the fan-favorite football video game, College Football, will return in the summer of 2024.
They did exactly that and got sued.
Why did EA Sports stop making College Football? Exploring the potential reasons behind game's decade-long hiatus
EA Sports announced on Feb. 15 that the fan-favorite football video game, College Football, will return in the summer of 2024.
EA used to use the players likeness and not use the name. Had same number, build, hometown, etc. Once EA lost the suit, schools pulled out on the licensing agreement with EA to have the schools in the game. EA could have made a game with random players to start with, but without the schools, it was a moot point. Unlicensed football games typically do not sell as well. The schools at that point were trying to figure the whole new landscape of NIL as it was just starting.
Teh Chosen Juan
Member
lol meant the libs, DEI and all the rest of the bullshit in that vein that has ruined entertainment/games/movies/tv/life. but you know me, i can't complain.Im not actually sure what you're referring to, but Im gonna assume it was everything around Horns Down getting cancelled and Im gonna completely agree with you. And then Ill take the opportunity to post this in solidarity:
starfire1978
Neo Member
No band or cheer. So not in the game, rental like usual.
Lumpyoatmeal
Member
Probably the best work I've seen in a sport game in a long time. The last sport game that impressed me was NFL 2K5. This College Football 25 actually addresses visual fidelity where it matters which is the gameplay, the animation work is the best I've seen even though there's still a little issues with the cameramen on the sideline but overall man there are still so many moving parts in how the game is animating on the football field, it looks amazing.
Spearheadz
Member
AJUMP23
Parody of actual AJUMP23
Here are the top 100 players.
- Will Johnson - Michigan (CB, 96 overall)
- Will Campbell - LSU (OT, 96 overall)
- Ollie Gordon II - Oklahoma State (RB, 96 overall)
- James Pearce Jr. - Tennessee (DE, 95 overall)
- Caleb Downs - Ohio State (FS, 95 overall)
- Travis Hunter - Colorado (WR/DB, 95 overall)
- Malaki Starks - Georgia (FS, 95 overall)
- Mason Graham - Michigan (DT, 95 overall)
- Quinshon Judkins - Ohio State (RB, 95 overall)
- Tate Ratledge - Georgia (RG, 95 overall)
- Luther Burden - Missouri (WR, 94 overall)
- Benjamin Morrison - Notre Dame (CB, 94 overall)
- Kelvin Banks Jr. - Texas (OT, 94 overall)
- Tetairoa McMillan - Arizona (WR, 94 overall)
- Barrett Carter - Clemson (OLB, 94 overall)
- Jay Higgins - Iowa (MLB, 94 overall)
- Shedeur Sanders - Colorado (QB, 93 overall)
- Carson Beck - Georgia (QB, 93 overall)
- Emeka Egbuka - Ohio State (WR, 93 overall)
- Mykel Williams - Georgia (OLB, 93 overall)
- Deone Walker - Kentucky (DE, 93 overall)
- Omarion Hampton - North Carolina (RB, 93 overall)
- TreVeyon Henderson - Ohio State (RB, 93 overall)
- Aireontae Ersery - Minnesota (OT, 93 overall)
- Jaydn Ott - Cal (RB, 93 overall)
- Walter Nolen - Texas A&M (DT, 93 overall)
- Quinn Ewers - Texas (QB, 92 overall)
- Xavier Watts - Notre Dame (FS, 92 overall)
- Jack Sawyer - Ohio State (DE, 92 overall)
- Dillon Gabriel - Oregon (transferred from Oklahoma) (QB, 92 overall)
- Harold Perkins Jr. - LSU (LB, 92 overall)
- Parker Brailsford - Alabama* (transferred from Washington) (C, 92 overall)
- Colston Loveland - Michigan (TE, 92 overall)
- Tacario Davis - Arizona* (CB, 92 overall)
- Malachi Moore - Alabama (FS, 92 overall)
- Tahj Brooks - Texas Tech (RB, 92 overall)
- Clay Webb - Jackson State (LG, 92 overall)
- Sebastian Castro - Iowa (FS, 92 overall)
- Jonas Sanker - Virginia (SS, 92 overall)
- Quincy Riley - Louisville (CB, 92 overall)
- Jonah Monheim - USC (OT, 92 overall)
- Devin Neal - Kansas (RB, 92 overall)
- Tyler Booker - Alabama (OG, 91 overall)
- Ashton Jeanty - Boise State (RB, 91 overall)
- Tory Horton - Colorado State (WR, 91 overall)
- Donovan Jackson - Ohio State (OG, 91 overall)
- Abdul Carter - Penn State (LB, 91 overall)
- Dylan Fairchild - Georgia (OG, 91 overall)
- Donovan Edwards - Michigan (RB, 91 overall)
- Jason Henderson - Old Dominion (LB, 91 overall)
- Denzel Burke - Ohio State (CB, 91 overall)
- Danny Stutsman - Oklahoma (LB, 91 overall)
- Luke Kandra - Louisville (OG, 91 overall)
- Tyleik Williams - Ohio State (DT, 91 overall)
- Kenneth Grant - Michigan (DT, 91 overall)
- Kaimon Rucker - North Carolina (DE, 91 overall)
- Kevin Winston Jr. - Penn State (S, 91 overall)
- Landon Jackson - Arkansas (DE, 91 overall)
- Tez Johnson - Oregon (WR, 91 overall)
- Jaeden Roberts - Alabama (OG, 91 overall)
- Maxwell Hairston - Kentucky (CB, 91 overall)
- Ricardo Hallman - Wisconsin (CB, 91 overall)
- Logan Parr - Texas (LG, 91 overall)
- Nicholas Singleton - Penn State (RB, 91 overall)
- Jabbar Muhammad - Oregon (tranferred from Washington) (CB, 91 overall)
- Dorian Strong - Virginia Tech (CB, 91 overall)
- Damien Martinez - Miami (transferred from Oregon State) (RB, 91 overall)
- RJ Harvey - UCF (RB, 91 overall)
- Oronde Gadsden II - Syracuse (TE, 91 overall)
- Dontay Corleone - Cincinnati (DT, 91 overall)
- Jalen Milroe - Alabama (QB, 90 overall)
- Ashton Gillotte - Louisville (DE, 90 overall)
- Jaxson Dart - Ole Miss (QB, 90 overall)
- Mitchell Evans - Notre Dame (TE, 90 overall)
- Cobee Bryant - Kansas (CB, 90 overall)
- Deontae Lawson - Alabama (LB, 90 overall)
- Howard Cross III - Notre Dame (DT, 90 overall)
- Rueben Bain Jr. - Miami (DE, 90 overall)
- Jalon Daniels - Kansas (QB, 90 overall)
- Nick Martin - Oklahoma State (LB, 90 overall)
- Tre Harris - Ole Miss (WR, 90 overall)
- Wyatt Milum - West Virginia (OT, 90 overall)
- Dillon Thieneman - Purdue (FS, 90 overall)
- Hunter Wohler - Wisconsin (SS, 90 overall)
- Evan Stewart - Oregon (transferred from Texas A&M) (WR, 90 overall)
- Nick Jackson - Iowa (LB, 90 overall)
- Patrick Payton - Florida State (DE, 90 overall)
- Nic Scourton - Texas A&M* (transferred from Purdue) (DE, 90 overall)
- Jonah Savaiinaea - Arizona (OT, 90 overall)
- Kaidon Salter - Liberty (QB, 90 overall)
- Peter Woods - Clemson (DT, 90 overall)
- Emery Jones Jr. - Cincinnati (OT, 92 overall)
- Xavier Restrepo - Miami (WR, 90 overall)
- Billy Bowman Jr. - Oklahoma (SS, 90 overall)
- Josh Conerly Jr. - Oregon (OT, 90 overall)
- Kyle Monangai - Rutgers (RB, 90 overall)
- Xavier Nwankpa - Iowa (SS, 90 overall)
- Mason Taylor - LSU (TE, 90 overall)
- Oscar Delp - Georgia (TE, 90 overall)
- Quinton Cooley - Liberty (RB, 90 overall)