It's a completely irrelevant poll that is most likely filled out by a graduate assistant. Isn't Mccarron a game manager, though?
How many top NFL QB's have come from Saban at Bama? His "process" just needs a QB that understands his system and can complete passes. The real stars on their offense are the OL and RB's, year in and year out. We went over this a few weeks ago.
Which ones? The 2 QB's who were here when he got here (JPW and GMAC) or the one Saban Recruited (McCarron). Could also point towards Phillip Sims as one that didn't turn out, and then there were a few 3 star QB's who have been processed in the last few years.
McCarron is the first of the Alabama QB's with prototypical size for an NFL QB, and has enough arm strength to be beyond claims of "Noodle Arm" that GMAC has taken over for Pennington (GMAC still the best QB on the Jests
). I've not seen official records, but I want to say that AJ's 2012 season, was the single best QB season Alabama's ever had. 5 years ago, the record for most TD passes in the season was something like 15 or 16.
Now, back to LSU years, depends on how much input you believe he had with J. Russell or Matt Flynn (I don't think he had much beyond recruiting them,
if he did.)