Manmademan
Member
Any way you slice it
Steve Rogers has been a fascist his whole life. That is his story now, that is how cosmic cubes work
Nope. People seem to be struggling with this one, but what happened was made clear in Captain America: SR #2.
The same thing that happened to Rogers happened to Selvig. Memories were changed, not history. Selvig THINKS he's been serving the Red Skull his entire history and he's always been Hydra. Skull thinks he's batshit insane, until Kobik tells him what she did to him.
Skull is able to look within Selvig's mind and see memories that "could not have possibly" happened, because Skull and everyone else is perfectly aware of ACTUAL history. Selvig isn't Hydra and never was- he just thinks he is, and the Hydra he remembers serving is the rose tinted fictional version that Red Skull made up to influence Kobik, not the ACTUAL one that was basically Nazis and murderers. Marvel history was not changed by the cube.
This is different than say...telepathic mind control (which skull can do, because of the xavier's brain thing) because with telepathic mind control the original mind and memories will eventually reassert themselves. In this case the memories aren't "false", they're the only ones that exist. There is no "original" memory or personality to reassert itself.