• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Cyberpunk 2077 - Review Thread

Should we lock this thread?

  • Yes

    Votes: 196 23.8%

  • No

    Votes: 628 76.2%
  • Total voters
    824
P

PontiusFeeb

Member
On one hand, I should wait for the Series X/PS 5 enhanced versions, because lots of bugs will also be fixed by then. On the other hand, I want to piss off ResetEra types NOW by buying the game. Decisions...
 
B

B0xel-new

Neo Member
ethomaz said:
The review thread there is like the one here... 10/10 first... 7-6/10 bottom.
I really didn't see any issue there.


I don't believe it is real.

www.resetera.com

Cyberpunk 2077 reviews/impressions thread

Windows Central: 10/10 M3: 10/10 The Gamer: 10/10 VG274: 10/10 VGC: 10/10 GameSpew: 10/10 Stevior: 9.5/10 Press Start: 9/10 GameInformer: 9/10 RPG Site: 9/10 Screenrant: 8/10 Trusted Reviews: 8/10 PCGamer: 7.8/10 Gamespot: 7/10 Gamesbeat: 6/10 GiantBomb: Unscored...
www.resetera.com www.resetera.com
Click to expand...
The thread you linked is locked. This is the only open thread currently. Open your own link ya lazy fuck

gJhOoqm.jpg



gJhOoqm.jpg


gJhOoqm.jpg
 
Last edited:
Kuranghi

Kuranghi

Gold Member
CaptainConlock said:
I think the criticisms of representation are valid, be it gender or race, but I don't think it should be the deciding factor in the game's review. People aren't buying this game to see how certain groups are represented, they just want to know how the RPG experience is. I think the game is pretty juvenile and immature when it comes to the representation, but maybe that was the intention. It's difficult to know with CDPR. Aside from that, this looks like a solid game overall.
Click to expand...

I just want artists to make the art they want in whatever form it takes, if thats a white person making only exclusively white characters then thats their choice, or a black person making only black people, or an asian person making only white characters, etc etc. If it doesn't make sense in the context of the world it will stand out and be less well received and people won't buy it.

I just don't know why any fictional world needs to abide by the race ratios of the real world. Not attacking you mate, just I don't know why people NEED to represented in a totally equal way, in fictional work. I would never dream of telling a <person of X race> to stop making worlds filled exclusively with people of their race, thats strange to me.
 
cr0w

cr0w

Old Member
Monsterkillah said:
Why do those Resetera hate this game?

I mean this game have fukin genitals cutomization to appease trans people, imagine that

Isnt that what they always dream of ?

If thats still not good enough they can kindly feck off and make their own transmania game
Click to expand...

Well their complete misunderstanding of what being transgender is boils down to what genitalia a person has, so they’re latching on to certain marketing that makes them think trans people as a whole are being made fun of.

They also don’t actually understand the meaning of the word transphobia. No one involved is afraid of transgender people, they’re just not coddling them and apparently that’s a crime.
 
M1chl

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
What the fuck they were doing all those years when it's so short for RPG? I know sidequest and shit, but damn... Seems more like akin to Deus Ex: Mankind divided. Well I am pre-loaded already, so I am going to play it anywhere, however:

7 years in development, no next-gen patch, short main quest. W H Y
 
ruvikx

ruvikx

Banned
These scores do give hope that the game will become a very good open world shooter once the patches have fixed everything, as they did with The Witcher 3. At least the core of the game is sound & that's good enough for me to be confident I'll eventually play this thing.

TintoConCasera said:
That Resetera thread... Holy shit.

It's like a modern version of the nazis burning books which they didn't find suitable to their tastes.
Click to expand...

Nazis?

Okay. How about call them what they are: degenerate communists, Marxists & far left nutjobs. It's totally absurd to label them "Nazis". What the fuck do you think Heinz Guderian & co would do with the reset sodomites?
 
ethomaz

ethomaz

Banned
B0xel-new said:
The thread you linked is locked. This is the only open thread currently. Open your own link ya lazy fuck
Click to expand...
"Staff is re-evaluating how Cyberpunk 2077 threads will be handled. Until a decision is made, this thread will be locked."
That is the actual review thread... I believe it should be opened, no?

I mean what there is even to be evaluated... that is crazy.
 
Trickster

Trickster

Member
Shame it won't achieve the dream of 95+. However at least it seems like the things it's getting dinged for are mainly bugs, which don't really matter much to be personally unless it's straight up game breaking or constant. I don't remember having any issues in Witcher 3 when that launched, and Bethesda games are some of my favourites of all time.

Then again it's hard to take a lot of review scores seriously these days


B0xel-new said:
Guys guys guys, check out the review thread on Era. They're only allowing negative reviews and it's fucking hilarious. Maybe I'm getting too old ( I'm 27 jesus fucking Christ) but this is world is starting to scare me
Click to expand...

It's pretty funny how they closed the normal review thread because - "Staff is re-evaluating how Cyberpunk 2077 threads will be handled. Until a decision is made, this thread will be locked. ". Which was all of 38 minutes ago, when they were clearly already doing what they're continuing to do with the review thread, which is only allow negatively charged threads about the game.

But yeah, ERA in it's current form is what you get when you spend years cultivating an echo chamber that leans far left politically. I genuinely do wonder how long it can last the way it's going. I can't imagine that ERA is growing it's user base at this point.
 
Last edited:
Irobot82

Irobot82

Member
Does any of the review cover the following?

1. Choices, Do they have any? Do they matter at all in the story (like Obsidian Games)
2. Graphics.
3. Sound
4. RPG elements. Leveling up, Skill trees etc.
5. Gameplay. Does driving the cars suck, is shooting fun.
6. Can I roleplay into side content/exploration (like Skyrim, I had 100 hours in that game before I ever went up the fucking mountain).
 
CaptainConlock

CaptainConlock

Member
Kuranghi said:
I just want artists to make the art they want in whatever form it takes, if thats a white person making only exclusively white characters then thats their choice, or a black person making only black people, or an asian person making only white characters, etc etc. If it doesn't make sense in the context of the world it will stand out and be less well received and people won't buy it.

I just don't know why any fictional world needs to abide by the race ratios of the real world. Not attacking you mate, just I don't know why people NEED to represented in a totally equal way, in fictional work. I would never dream of telling a <person of X race> to stop making worlds filled exclusively with people of their race, thats strange to me.
Click to expand...
I feel like the reviews are taking issues with how certain groups aren't portrayed in a realistic or even respectful light, which is why I think it's appropriate to point out and critique. Cyberpunk is a world about transhumanism and whatnot, so for the game to view trans people primarily in an aesthetic or pornographic light, then the game doesn't do a good job at portraying them within the context of the world. There should be some nuance when depicting minority/marginalized people in a world like Night City, and CP2077's getting criticized for not doing that, and I think that's fair criticism.
 
Rikkori

Rikkori

Member
Dampf said:
Nah, the game has nice AO and GI, it is evident in many screenshots without RTX and even in the console footage. It's just that its hard to have perfect GI and AO everywhere in a giant open world, that's the negative of pre-baking light. It happens automatically with RTX so every possible scene is perfectly lit.
Click to expand...
Nice? Mate it's not fucking there at all! There's a big difference between not perfect and shit. The comparison you've shared has the game non-RTX look like dog crap, I'm not discussing other screens.
 
Ribi

Ribi

Member
MiguelItUp said:
I'm not surprised at all. Polygon and Kotaku LOVE that stuff. They constantly go off on these weird tangents that hardly have anything to do with the game anymore. Or anything with games period. It's pretty embarrassing to me.

None of these reviewers have had access to THAT patch. They received another patch. But that particular patch is not available until launch. The fixes it will have are nothing but an assumption at this point.

They have told reviewers to use their stock footage in videos and won't allow them to use their own until launch and when that patch is available. So, I'm hoping it's because the patch will fix a lot of it, but we'll see.
Click to expand...
Strange, pcgamer outright said it was the "day 1" patch but even I doubted it.
 
GaviotaGrande

GaviotaGrande

Banned
M1chl said:
What the fuck they were doing all those years when it's so short for RPG? I know sidequest and shit, but damn... Seems more like akin to Deus Ex: Mankind divided. Well I am pre-loaded already, so I am going to play it anywhere, however:

7 years in development, no next-gen patch, short main quest. W H Y
Click to expand...
Building the city so we can burn it, obviously. I bet we will get some nice juicy story DLCs so it's all good.
 
Coolwhhip

Coolwhhip

Neophyte
Trickster said:
It's pretty funny how they closed the normal review thread because - "Staff is re-evaluating how Cyberpunk 2077 threads will be handled. Until a decision is made, this thread will be locked. ". Which was all of 38 minutes ago, when they were clearly already doing what they're continuing to do with the review thread, which is only allow negatively charged threads about the game.

But yeah, ERA in it's current form is what you get when you spend years cultivating an echo chamber that leans far left politically. I genuinely do wonder how long it can last the way it's going. I can't imagine that ERA is growing it's user base at this point.
Click to expand...

They will end up with a few hundred hardcore losers and they will all follow the rules on what to think on every topic. So all replies will basically be the same. Doubt whoever is raking up the ad money there will be happy with that though.
 
M1chl

M1chl

Currently Gif and Meme Champion
JeTmAn81 said:
Criticisms of transphobic imagery are fair, but Era takes performative wokeness to Oscar-winning levels. It's a real horror show.
Click to expand...
Can you elaborate what is transphobic about that imagery? I mean, to me it seems like it celebrates "openess" in future society.

GaviotaGrande said:
Building the city so we can burn it, obviously. I bet we will get some nice juicy story DLCs so it's all good.
Click to expand...
Well I would welcome some Gaas type added content, because DLC is probably going to take a lot of time. But that's just me. I think I payed a lot for the game already, if it's on the RPG short side...
 
Last edited:
Shifty1897

Shifty1897

Member
Holy shit I thought posters were being bombastic when saying Resetera wasn't allowing a reviews thread but they really went there, the only reviews allowed are ones that complain about the trans issues in the thread 😂.
 
TintoConCasera

TintoConCasera

I bought a sex doll, but I keep it inflated 100% of the time and use it like a regular wife
ruvikx said:
Nazis?

Okay. How about call them what they are: degenerate communists, Marxists & far left nutjobs. It's totally absurd to label them "Nazis". What the fuck do you think Heinz Guderian & co would do with the reset sodomites?
Click to expand...
Relax buddy, I wasn't calling them nazis, I was just comparing that thread to the book burnings because both represent extreme ways of censoring.
 
missiles

missiles

Member
Bugs sound completely gamebreaking according to Laymen Gaming - amazing game but still feels rushed out despite the delays. Gonna wait for the next gen update for sure.
 
Threeshotgamer

Threeshotgamer

Banned
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

  • Poll
CDPR CEO Thinks The Company's Reputation Might Never Recover From Disastrous Cyberpunk 2077 Launch
News Poll 2 3 4
159
7K
apocaliptic replied
CyberPunk 2077 update 2.2 was outsourced to another studio, more updates could be coming in this fashion
Game Dev
26
2K
GinSama replied
CDPR: Rectifying Cyberpunk 2077's Disastrous Launch Was CD Projekt Red's Biggest Achievement
Game Dev 2
59
4K
RickSanchez replied
The Witcher 3 modders datamine a quest where Geralt would have teleported to Night City from Cyberpunk 2077
19
1K
Zathalus replied
Cyberpunk 2077 Still Has Easter Eggs Players Haven't Found, says CDPR
Game Dev
32
3K
The_Observer replied
Top Bottom