CrimsonFist
Member
Correct, the role also wasn't RNG'd.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Danganronpa 3 Mafia |OT| Side: Scum
- Thread starter CrimsonFist
- Start date
Correct, the role also wasn't RNG'd.
Since votes need still to be on a separate line even in poetry it makes it hard to target players with short names, so StanleyPalmtree, I thought I would use unvote to get myself an extra syllable.
To be fair, the general sentiment seemed like we shouldn't force a mass claim.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
its like this is your first time watching a death game story, there always has to be an immediate sacrifice to prove the consequences of breaking the rules.
really gotta get the tension going so that everyone has an excuse for their terrible decision making.
c'mon man learn the tropes.
OceanicAir
Member
Ehhhh, just be sure if you want to lynch me or not if the time comes, I don't want to spring it on people if the time arises and it would be markedly more distracting at day end or if there is a turbo.You can pretend it isn't there if you want though!
I misunderstood this post. The unvote line is part of the poem which is a limerick in AABBA structure with the last line reading "unvote flux wave zed"
Zed of course being the correct pronunciation in Her Majesty The Queen's Most Britannic English.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
I don't care at the moment, it makes sense as a forbidden action, I'm just hoping it isn't a constant topic through the day.
Is your game going to be doing your FA then spending the next 3 posts explaining why it worked then repeat?
With the little bit I have to go on? Yes
StarSketch
Banned
Blarg is in an 'odd' timezone so he'll probably show up later.
I was going to wait a little longer to prod someone but seeing as we have a pretty good turn out so far I'll go ahead and
VOTE: nin1000
Nin seems really hard to get a grasp on anyways, may as well try and get some early discussion from him. Lets see what nin 3.0 is all about.
Odd
This seems like a pain in the ass to police, to the point where the claim seems...dubious.
If you are supposed to die when you break this rule, someone has to constantly go through your posts, count your posts, and make sure your 4th post counts as a poem? Moderator shot themselves in the foot.
No
I don't know? Can't you search the thread for all posts by user and they come up in order. Plus it was bound to come up so other posters in the thread can police it.
That's kind of a double edged sword though. If we spend the time checking and catch you on it - pointing it out would be a bad choice unless we have reason to suspect you're lying about it in the first place.
OceanicAir
Member
Hardly. Those are two different things, so i don't know what you're getting at.
One means that they're lynch immune and the other means that whether i have the most votes (duh) or the second most (my forbidden action) I'll die.
AbsolutBro
Member
I mean, I was in the first Danganronpa mafia game and there were no FAs to deal with. Just
@Everyone that clarified Sophia's thing: thank you
What if there's a tie?
You're just jealous that I'm talking to OA and you're not
Cricketing intensifies
Really not much to work off of currently and I don't want the day to just devolve into FA discussion when we have no clue how or if they correlate to anything whatsoever yet.
It feels a bit pointless to go after FAs when scum could have them to.
I feel bad about Sorian. That's good I think... I said to myself a town read would be worrying and reading closer - while I don't have a great sense of scum!Sorian - no tells are coming through.
Terra is sort of solvey. He sticks out a bit and it looks like he's genuinely curious.
Splinter is kind of townie too.
Faddy feels too bandwagony and jumping to conclusions. Could just be playstyle.
VOTE: Faddy
Why did you post so much fluff early game knowing you had to "claim" at the fourth post and that it'd be a bit of a pain in the ass to write? If you wanted to claim, why not spam so you can claim right away?
/goes after FA
My point is I don't think the FA themselves have to be alignment indicative as it'd make sense to give scum some if some/all townies have one. It looks like a general mechanic and not town only.
I feel bad about Sorian. That's good I think... I said to myself a town read would be worrying and reading closer - while I don't have a great sense of scum!Sorian - no tells are coming through.
Terra is sort of solvey. He sticks out a bit and it looks like he's genuinely curious.
Splinter is kind of townie too.
Faddy feels too bandwagony and jumping to conclusions. Could just be playstyle.
VOTE: Faddy
Why did you post so much fluff early game knowing you had to "claim" at the fourth post and that it'd be a bit of a pain in the ass to write? If you wanted to claim, why not spam so you can claim right away?
/goes after FA
My point is I don't think the FA themselves have to be alignment indicative as it'd make sense to give scum some if some/all townies have one. It looks like a general mechanic and not town only.
Keep it, I like it.
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
So far it looks like the only one who hasn't at least checked in is Blarg.
I don't really have as strong of feelings as you do so far Ty, so that may be contributing to it. OceanicAir's FA claim sticks out the most of anything because it's the only one so far that seems to have much actual impact on the game. Then again it seems like something scum wouldn't want to claim for no reason, if there is a role that can investigate FA's then Oceanic must know he'd be attracting their attention. Due to that I'm inclined to think they're telling the truth. Unfortunately we don't know what a scum FA would look like so this isn't really indicative of his actual alignment.
Sorian and Kark have both been fairly active and of anyone have at least some amount of posts to try and infer from, but at this point I'm not confident enough that my feelings on them aren't influenced by my previous experience with them. The only game I played in with Sorian he was town and his play feels the same as before, but considering I don't know what the opposite side of his play would look like that doesn't mean much. Kark on the other hand does not seem much like he was in Quarantine in which he was town, but that could just be because he's not making crazy gambits
.
Sorian and Kark have both been fairly active and of anyone have at least some amount of posts to try and infer from, but at this point I'm not confident enough that my feelings on them aren't influenced by my previous experience with them. The only game I played in with Sorian he was town and his play feels the same as before, but considering I don't know what the opposite side of his play would look like that doesn't mean much. Kark on the other hand does not seem much like he was in Quarantine in which he was town, but that could just be because he's not making crazy gambits
yet
I bet forbidden actions are universal based on the premise of this game, but I do wonder if there are any significant differences between the types townies have and the types scum have. I'm guessing probably not, since that could make for an easy tell and that'd be lopsided in the favor of Town.
Then again, scum might have more lenient forbidden actions, since it'd make for one hell of a game if they all ended up getting themselves killed from them.
Nin has not either.
I would like to know this too.
I don't see much wrong at this early stage in Day 1 for Kark to do some minor probing over an interesting forbidden action claim.
Asking questions that are obvious/already have been answered smells more of trying to stay busy. I'm all for probing but Karl was just asking questions for the sake of it.
What's obvious about "what happens in a tie"? I haven't seen it addressed anywhere
Seems fairly clear cut to me. Being tied for second is still being within the top two.
It would actually be tied for first, not second. That could technically be argued as not being in violation of his FA if it is specifically worded to not finish the day second in votes. I can see Why Kark feels it is a grey area, but I just don't know that it merits discussion. This isn't going to get us closer to finding scum.
I find it more interesting that we have a few people that haven't appeared since day start and several more that haven't actually tried to participate in a meaningful way.
Hello Natiko, My name is nin and i am here.
What is it you want to know ?
Who am i you might ask ?
well i am first and foremost:
good looking
great at this game
even better at winning
decent to average in scum hunting
and most importantly
FUN
please elaborate further.
exactly. If you want to say something to me, just to it *splinter.
I dont know how i feel about you.
I will not tell you something.
You can a good or a bad person.
Seems to be a 50/50 chance
What is there to react to? It's the softest vote I've ever seen
Tbf , you voting on someone is not really something extraordinary.
Then what would you like to talk about, or are you going to pussy foot with nin some more
I'm quite happy pussyfooting thankyouverymuch