Well, let's see... your points seem to be that (paraphrased) "it's not as bad as you say it is", "Japan needs to deal with the issue internally", and "I don't think it was all that offensive and you shouldn't get all up in arms over it".
To which I say: No, I obviously disagree; I don't live in Japan and this is a thread specifically about Dragon Ball Super so I will criticize all elements from my perspective and my perspective alone; I am thoroughly disappointed by absolutely everyone who tries to downplay this kind of depiction and refuse to not get up in arms over it.
Also, it should be noted that Dragon Ball Super is an international franchise at this point, and so everything is fair game. Whether or not our words will ever reach this is an open question, but I don't think they can completely ignore us if there's a big enough reaction.
Your post at the top of the page is literally you trying to normalize what happened. You basically said the sexual assault is okay because he paid for it by getting kicked in the nuts and talisman possessed.......wow..
Thanks for proving my point...
Well, let's see... your points seem to be that (paraphrased) "it's not as bad as you say it is"
I was saying A) the actual content was tame compared to DB and other anime and B) if people are going to be upset about something they should do themselves a favor and use the right label. As someone who has
actually been a victim of sexual assault I'd prefer it if people didn't label something with zero touching as assault.
"Japan needs to deal with the issue internally",
I don't know where the hell you got that from, I said that it's part of a larger issue in Japan that needs to be addressed, nowhere did I say that Japan has to deal with the issue internally.
"I don't think it was all that offensive and you shouldn't get all up in arms over it".
Because it really wasn't that bad, they didn't show "parts" of Yurin for the viewer's "enjoyment" and Roshi's actions were not painted in a positive light. But I also said that it was not done well and that it's a dumb and shitty trope. As for me saying I don't think people should get up in arms about it, I immediately followed that up by saying that it is part of a larger issue in Japan that DOES need addressed. I don't think people should get their feathers all ruffled by this scene in particular because as far as gross sexual shit in Japanese media this barely even registers, but as I said it IS still part of a large issue with Japan.
To which I say: No, I obviously disagree; I don't live in Japan and this is a thread specifically about Dragon Ball Super so I will criticize all elements from my perspective and my perspective alone; I am thoroughly disappointed by absolutely everyone who tries to downplay this kind of depiction and refuse to not get up in arms over it.
Also, it should be noted that Dragon Ball Super is an international franchise at this point, and so everything is fair game. Whether or not our words will ever reach this is an open question, but I don't think they can completely ignore us if there's a big enough reaction.
I'm guessing you decided to just ignore this sentence then.
The show being Japanese doesn't excuse it, but it does provide context as to why something is the way it is and I think that's something people should understand.
It's an issue ingrained in many Japanese people, but just as I said above that doesn't excuse, but it is also important for people to understand the context of WHY. It's all part of a larger issue in Japan that is not just restricted to their media, but how they view sex and sexual activities culturally, and like I said, it is an issue that needs to be addressed. Nobody is telling you you can't voice your criticism, I myself didn't like it and think the episode would have been better without it, but this particular thing is not really worth getting majorly upset about. The discussion about and how it is part of a larger issue is fine, but we also don't need to exaggerate what actually happened in this episode.
Your post at the top of the page is literally you trying to normalize what happened. You basically said the sexual assault is okay because he paid for it by getting kicked in the nuts and talisman possessed.......wow..
And this is just... ugh. Talk about completely ignoring what was said and putting words in my mouth.
You're the one who put controversy in quotation marks and tried to whitewash what happened by asking that people not call it sexual assault despite the overt rapey imagery and Yurin screaming for him to get his hands off of her. You dismissing posters' concerns telling them to not be offended "because Japan", some of whom might have suffered sexual abuse or have a loved one who has or simply those who have the moral decency to be repulsed regardless is gross as hell.
I put controversy in quotes because it's just a few people that are really upset about it.
Sexual assault is forced touching, Roshi only touched her when picking her up and didn't grope her then, what Roshi was doing was sexual harassment, I also didn't say harassment is okay, I was asking people to use the right label.
The rest of your post is just more ignoring what I said and pretending I said something else to fit your narrative of me being an opposing force.
Also hi, I was molested at the age of 4, tell me more about how I have no moral decency when it comes to sexual assault.
Apparently people would rather just be upset than have an actual discussion, otherwise why would there be THREE people here trying to completely change the meaning of a post of mine because it doesn't fit perfectly with their argument.