The same point I started off with - the one you quoted... For most (non-modders) the Edge would be a no-brainer if it gets Hall Effect sensor modules.
Don't know why you're trying to go off-rails, but most (non-modders) would like to keep their warranty in case something goes wrong with their controller.
Youre talking to yourself at this point. You don't need to be a "modder". I charge people 15$ to replace both joystick modules on broken/out of warranty dual sense controllers including parts (around 2$). Replacing the haptic trigger or caps I do for free if somebody brings the parts because both can be replaced without soldering.
Do you disagree with my assertion that replacing the old joysticks in an existing dual sense will be cheaper than buying a dual sense edge + modules? Because that's my original point. You tried to tell me how to fix a stick and brought warranties up on your own.