This was important.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Federal appeals court maintains suspension of Trumps immigration order
- Thread starter bangbang i'm a timpani
- Start date
- Status
This was important.
How About No
Member
Frick yes dude!
Our so-called President can get fucked
Our so-called President can get fucked
Skyball Paint
Member
Suck on a turd you orange bastard
Netherscourge
Banned
Trump better be careful - if he keeps losing he might not know how to win anymore.
So they'll appeal to SCOTUS, discover that having 8 judges mean there's 0 chance of overturning the 9th, and that'll be that.
I wonder if the odds of SCOTUS overturning it would be higher if the Senate had done their jobs and approved Garland. He was very much a compromise candidate and there would have been a non-zero chance he would have sided with Trump.
I wonder if the odds of SCOTUS overturning it would be higher if the Senate had done their jobs and approved Garland. He was very much a compromise candidate and there would have been a non-zero chance he would have sided with Trump.
McCain should fire back on the loser comments
the_firewithin
Member
His buddy putin has probably given him advice on how to poison the SC to get rid of them if this really goes there
This is what I expected, at least with the TRO.
The decision on the actual lawsuit is a tougher question.
The Supreme Court decides whether or not they take a case. Unless the various suits on this order turn out wildly differently (or they think one of the appeals courts got it badly wrong), I wouldn't be surprised if they just let the circuits handle it. Roberts probably doesn't want to throw himself into a political minefield if he can help it.
The decision on the actual lawsuit is a tougher question.
The Supreme Court decides whether or not they take a case. Unless the various suits on this order turn out wildly differently (or they think one of the appeals courts got it badly wrong), I wouldn't be surprised if they just let the circuits handle it. Roberts probably doesn't want to throw himself into a political minefield if he can help it.
m_shortpants
Member
I hope he keeps tweeting bullshit undermining the justice system, building more and more material for the inevitable impeachment.
Of course, that's even assuming that the spineless GOP controlled Congress would do what they're supposed to in that kind of a scenario.
Of course, that's even assuming that the spineless GOP controlled Congress would do what they're supposed to in that kind of a scenario.
Yep. Use Trumpspeak, that's all he seems to understand.
Ziltoidia 9
Member
Going 3-0 is a good sign that it won't get OK'd later on, as it moves up.
If they spit on ideological lines it'll be 4-4 which means the ninth districts order stands.
I think the odds are higher that the scotus refuses to hear it
You mean 3am
whyamihere
Banned
ha ha ha ha ha ha
Fuck you, Rudy. Fuck you, Trump.
More likely than not, Kennedy would be on the right side of this case even with the 9th judge. Garland definitely wouldn't have overturned it. He was nowhere near a bad judge.
SymbiantXenos
Member
Good, get fucked Trump.
Felix Lighter
Member
I'm hoping for some juicy bits in the opinion.
Regulus Tera
Romanes Eunt Domus
So he's pushing this to the Supreme Court isn't he?
SlickShoesRUCrazy
Member
Excellent.
Ready for the tweet storm you orange sack of shit.
Ready for the tweet storm you orange sack of shit.
Even as a conservative I knew that was going to happen, it was poorly written, with more holes then Swiss cheese. Here's a tip have some fucking evidence that terrorists were actually coming in. Or maybe have a viable plan to screen people before closing the gate. It's like a child having a tantrum.
RPGCrazied
Member
So now its going to the supreme court to totally repeal it, you know republicans are going to ram Gorsuch as fast as possible through to make it a 5-4 decision in Chump's favor.
Yeah I think its so obviously in violation of the establishment clause that they may not even bother taking it.
EnlightenedMint
Member
Great news, fuck Trump.
andythinkpad
Member
Whine more orange turd.
whyamihere
Banned
This isn't on the merits though. Just on the stay.
The case will work its way through the court system on the merits, and by then it'll be a 9-person court, but my guess is there probably aren't 5 votes to say that this is a constitutional EO.
Nydius
Member
While this is great news, we must remain vigilant because the GOP has also been pushing to break up the 9th Circuit specifically because it's too big (and, of course, too liberal). Since January 22nd, at least three separate Congressional proposals have been brought up to bust up the 9th Circuit, all from Republicans: Senator Flake from Arizona, Senator Sullivan from Alaska, and Senator Daines of Montana.
Yep.
If someone like Romney implemented this it would have stood. Trump and his cohorts own stupid remarks sunk it.
Do you think Trump has that kind of patience?
And I'd half expect that to be unanimous too even with him on board.
Advocatus Diaboli
Member
Probably. And Gorsuch will probably vote against in favor of affirming the decision of the Ninth Circuit. (I'm calling it now.)
Yeah, I agree with that. It's coming, anyway. Judicial economy and all that.
Kyleripman
Member
Great news!
Also, how did I miss Easy D until now? That's pretty good.
Also, how did I miss Easy D until now? That's pretty good.
You assume Gorsuch would rule in favor of Trump.
If the racist piece of shit is really nutso, he could remove all three judges from the Ninth Circuit (he did remove Sally Yates for standing up for America) and appoint new judges or declare martial law indefinitely and keep the travel ban in place anyway.
Still, get fucked Trump.
Still, get fucked Trump.
Technically originalist conservative judges should be against it too.
Pretty sure they can only be removed via impeachment from the Senate
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked