How's The Wicked Library?
I've heard that sentiment about the NoSleep reddit, what changed? I've listened to the pod for the last 2 years, I've only read a handful of actual stories on the sub. I still think NoSleep has some of the best VAs, sound mix and does a great job of adding more life to the stories. I'd say the latest season is actually pretty good.
I've listened to four episodes of The Wicked Library and it hasn't been anything special so far. Knifepoint is still the best standalone horror story podcast I've heard.
As for the Nosleep subreddit, it started out being self contained horror stories, and the subreddit's premise was "everything posted here is true [even if it's not]". And that was fine, and enjoyable when the stories were mostly one-offs or campfire type things where the person typing the story is relating something that he heard happened.
As the subreddit grew, the stories became too ridiculous to sustain the subreddit's premise. We'd get things like "I Think My Son is Possessed", and the story would have the son commit multiple murder attempts, and then at the bottom, "CONTINUED IN PART 2", and then in the next part "CONTINUED IN PART 3", yet somehow the story is supposed to be happening to the author?
Why is the author taking the time to write this stuff to a subreddit if this stuff is happening in real time?
Any way, my general feeling is that the majority of the subreddit has jumped the shark.
I'm sure there are still some great pieces of standalone horror in there, and I'm definitely not saying that all multi-part stories are bad (Penpal and The Spire in the Woods on nosleep were awesome, for example).
When does Magnus start kicking in? I gave the first couple of episodes a listen and find the narrators voice to be oddly annoying.
Mm, well, if you don't like his voice I don't know if it'll ever click for you. I was hooked from episode 1.