Support NeoGAF

[Kyoufu]

You could debate it, but you'd be wrong. Keeper's aren't infallible remember. Well, not since Van De Sar retired.

I'm pretty sure I can debate it and I wouldn't be wrong (or right). I'd just have a good argument.

Joe Hart is pretty overrated. He's very good yes, but he's still overrated because people don't realise goalkeepers can only do so much, the responsibility of clean sheets lies on the defenders too and City have a great back four. You can't give him all the credit and you can't say he's the best in the league unless you give other keepers equally capable defenders to back him up.

 

[The_Hitcher89]

lololol

Someone should make one for the Sterling goal against reading when Suarez celebrates with him

 

[dc89]

Holy shit. Gwahaha

 

[Yurt]

Lol at Roma's keeper! 1-1.

 

[Arnie]

I have to disagree. It's straight at him with his entire body behind it. He literally could have just let it hit him and it would have stayed out, but he pushed it into his own net.

Obviously they shouldn't let it get to that point, if it was either side of him, or low, or above him, I'd agree, but it was the perfect height and in the middle of his body.

Fair enough. I think the quality of the position and the header was why the ball ricocheted into the net, not some glaring error from hart, personally. I like to give keepers the benefit of the doubt there, two seasons of mediocre Reina have made me soft, and accepting.

 

[LegoArmo]

So he shouldn't had positioned his hands to the sides to save it if it came there instead?

You dive to the sides. If you can't get to the ball, fair enough.

 

[Zabojnik]

VIOLAAAAAAAAA

Milan 0 - 2 Fiorentina

 

[dc89]

Right, one more goal in the AC game and two in this.
Lazio and Roma done!

Edit: oh! Ac Milan game done! Two goals in this please City

 

[Fry]

 

[The_Hitcher89]

Fair enough. I think the quality of the position and the header was why the ball ricocheted into the net, not some glaring error from hart, personally. I like to give keepers the benefit of the doubt there, two seasons of mediocre Reina have made me soft, and accepting.

I want 09/10 Reina back

He basically saved us about 10 points that season


Another dead accumulator. Fuck this, its a mug's game

 

[TheLucifer]

Fiorentina is leading 2-0. Pato missed a penalty.

 

[Arnie]

I'm pretty sure I can debate it and I wouldn't be wrong (or right). I'd just have a good argument.

Joe Hart is pretty overrated. He's very good yes, but he's still overrated because people don't realise goalkeepers can only do so much, the responsibility of clean sheets lies on the defenders too and City have a great back four. You can't give him all the credit and you can't say he's the best in the league unless you give other keepers equally capable defenders to back him up.

You've made two posts disagreeing but you haven't suggested an alternative. Forgetting whether he's overrated or not, who's a better keeper in the league, currently?

 

[Slizz]

 

[Cuddler]

Lazio goal, Candreva. And second goal for Fiorentina, Borja Valero, poor Milan.

You could debate it, but you'd be wrong. Keeper's aren't infallible remember. Well, not since Van De Sar retired.

Van Der Sar infallible?!? Sarcasm?

Spoiler

Juventus fan here...

 

[Meier]

Fuuuuuu so much possession there for nothing. Nice idea by Kun and Silva. Need our shooting boots on..

 

[Jeff Albertson]

Where's Jeff? Hart gaffe is right up his alley.

Atrocious keeping really (obviously not helped by the defence) but Its not a shock, when on form there aren't many better shot stoppers than Hart but he is inconsistent and dodgy

City will get a cheap penalty this half after the ref will have seen his mistakes at half time

 

[Arnie]

Van Der Sar infallible?!? Sarcasm?

Spoiler

Juventus fan here...

:lol you've got a point.

United Van Der Sar was fucking godly, I'm sad to say.

 

[Salvadora]

WoodenLung you missed the black guy after that gif that Terry put his arm around!

 

[dc89]

Atrocious keeping really but Its not a shock, when on form there aren't many better shot stoppers than Hart but he is inconsistent and dodgy

City will get a cheap penalty this half after the ref will have seen his mistakes at half time

No we won't! We should have had two penalties already in this game!

 

[The_Hitcher89]

You've made two posts disagreeing but you haven't suggested an alternative. Forgetting whether he's overrated or not, who's a better keeper in the league, currently?

While he's not as good as he was, Cech has been decent recently I think

At their best:

Cech>Reina=Hart

At the moment:

Hart=Cech>>>Reina

 

[Blablurn]

VIOLAAAAAAAAA

Milan 0 - 2 Fiorentina

damn, what happened to milan

 

[LegoArmo]

To be fair, I think 80% of the keepers in the league would have saved that, but I also think Hart would have saved it 9 times out of 10 as well. He won't be happy with himself.

Aguero's been a bit rubbish so far this season.

 

[Yurt]

Van Der Sar infallible?!? Sarcasm?

Spoiler

Juventus fan here...

Yeah I couldn't help but laugh reading that.


CMON LAZIO

 

[Meier]

Another shit corner. Where's the height?! Round 2 was a bit better.

 

[The_Hitcher89]

lolguero


#worldclassmyarse

 

[WJD]

:lol you've got a point.

United Van Der Sar was fucking godly, I'm sad to say.

I can remember one mistake against West Brom and then maybe against Messi in the CL final but other than that he was perfect.

 

[dc89]

Come on Kun!!!

 

[LabouredSubterfuge]

AGUEEEEEEEEROOOOOOOOOOOOOOO.

 

[Manager]

damn, what happened with milan

They shipped away Ibra (and Thiago)

 

[Arnie]

While he's not as good as he was, Cech has been decent recently I think

At their best:

Cech>Reina=Hart

At the moment:

Hart=Cech>>>Reina

Cech's improved massively after coming under a lot of criticism early last season. Minolet's currently having a brilliant season, too. But other than those two I don't see many contenders. Krul's been out injured so it's hard to call that one.

 

[Freewheelin']

Kunt

lol

 

[K1LLER7]

While he's not as good as he was, Cech has been decent recently I think

At their best:

Cech>Reina=Hart

At the moment:

Hart=Cech>>>Reina

De Gea will be up there.

Oh yes Maicon coming on, Bale v Maicon round 2

 

[Meier]

Oh no, Kun..

Then he wasted another right after. Sub him off. Terrible today...

 

[dc89]

Maicon. Oh Lordy Lord.

 

[The_Hitcher89]

MAICON

 

[LabouredSubterfuge]

:lol

Brilliant by Mancini.

 

[Jeff Albertson]

No we won't! We should have had two penalties already in this game!

And the ref knows that he'll have seen it back at half time and will play on his mind

 

[Freewheelin']

Bale will have fun now

 

[Manager]

3-5-2 fuuuu

 

[Kyoufu]

You've made two posts disagreeing but you haven't suggested an alternative. Forgetting whether he's overrated or not, who's a better keeper?

Like I said in my post, it wouldn't be fair to judge others because they don't have City's defense.

That's why my argument isn't right or wrong. Put Krul, De Gea (even though he's horrible with aerial balls) and Cech with City's back four in front of them and then we can see who is truly the best in the league.

 

[Slizz]

Lol, City mad.

 

[dc89]

Tevez is not offside. This Lino man, inconsistent is putting it lightly.

 

[K1LLER7]

Trademark Mancini sub.

 

[Zabojnik]

MIROSLAAAAAAAAV!!!! It begins! AVALANCHE OF GOALSSSSSS

 

[The_Hitcher89]

18 certificate slow-motion shot there

 

[Wilbur]

Mancini's a fucking turnip. Pep will be there by mid June

 

[Yurt]

Hernanes and Klose is such a fucking DEADLY partnership. 2-1.

 

[LegoArmo]

Should be hoping they put this frustration and anger into scoring an equaliser.

 

[3Sixty]

18 certificate slow-motion shot there

3 match ban and fine please.

He is a role model!!!

 

[Meier]

Another awful corner directly at the defender on the near post. Insanity.