• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

GAF Mafia/Werewolf |OT| A forum game of secrets and treachery - sign up to play!

  • Thread starter Deleted member 231381
  • Start date

Gorlak

Banned
Oooww, come on Ourob why have you set the night phase to end in x days and 8 hours? Can't you do us Europeans one favor?
 

cabot

Member
Pretty big, but personally I found it funnier when Visualante came with that big ass post.....10 minutes AFTER the deadline and didn't realize he was already dead :)

That was bizarre.

There was no sniff of a power role mention in it as well if I remember correctly?

It was such a weird end.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
maxresdefault.jpg
 

cabot

Member
Haly, was the 3P neutral cop thing straight out of tales from your ass or is that a legit thing in mafia?

I didn't see the point of it at all
 

El Topo

Member
You shouldn't have lynched someone without giving him the chance to defend himself.
We shouldn't have lynched someone without giving him the chance to defend himself.

It was convenient for me, but it wasn't right.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Haly, was the 3P neutral cop thing straight out of tales from your ass or is that a legit thing in mafia?

I didn't see the point of it at all
3P?

Ass. I had fun designing the role and didn't realize it'd be totally useless as a defense. Weak cops are a real thing though. It's a limit to make them more balanced. Any number of roles can have the "weak" prefix attached to it like weak doctor, weak tracker and so on.

I thought about it over and there were more claims I could make but I never thought of them because I was trying to fit it into the flavor.

I didn't expect squidy's kamikaze attack either.
 

cabot

Member
3P?

Ass. I had fun designing the role and didn't realize it'd be totally useless as a defense. Weak cops are a real thing though. It's a limit to make them more balanced. Any number of roles can have the "weak" prefix attached to it like weak doctor, weak tracker and so on.

I thought about it over and there were more claims I could make but I never thought of them because I was trying to fit it into the flavor.

I didn't expect squidy's kamikaze attack either.

3P = third party.

That squidy, he craycray
 

El Topo

Member
The problem with a powerful role claim - even a weak cop is still a cop - is that it requires you to deliver useful information. No useful information ("XYZ is mafia") means death.
I thought it was a pretty clever attempt to twist Jakov as a neutral role though. Very well done, flavor-wise.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Perhaps I overthought it but "Alright, you guys, I get it, but, hey, look at all this conveniently useful information I have to extricate myself out of this." is pretty much the most suspicious thing I can think of for a claim.
 

Ourobolus

Banned
I'm going to quote you because I don't think any of the game runners noticed. Once one of them does then they will toss you on the replacement list.

I saw it this morning actually, I just was on the way to work and forgot once I got here. Whoops.

Royal_Flush
Christina Mackenzie
Lone_Prodigy
Zubz

Haly, you want on the list or a link to the dead thread?
 

El Topo

Member
Hey Ouro, please remove me from the replacement list and give me a link to the dead thread. Thanks.

Perhaps I overthought it but "Alright, you guys, I get it, but, hey, look at all this conveniently useful information I have to extricate myself out of this." is pretty much the most suspicious thing I can think of for a claim.

It's very suspicious, but it might just work. People don't behave rationally. That said, it's a very fine line to walk and after squidy's attack there was no (or very little) way out for you.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
I saw it this morning actually, I just was on the way to work and forgot once I got here. Whoops.

Royal_Flush
Christina Mackenzie
Lone_Prodigy
Zubz
El Topo

Haly, you want on the list or a link to the dead thread?

Dead, I think I pm'd you.
It's very suspicious, but it might just work. People don't behave rationally. That said, it's a very fine line to walk and after squidy's attack there was no (or very little) way out for you.
It was very much a forced suicide pact from my point of view. Any thing I could claim they'd want to verify by killing me and not him.

I'm just boggling over where I messed up my tells to get him on my ass like this on... day 4.
 

Ourobolus

Banned
Hey Ouro, please remove me from the replacement list and give me a link to the dead thread. Thanks.



It's very suspicious, but it might just work. People don't behave rationally. That said, it's a very fine line to walk and after squidy's attack there was no (or very little) way out for you.

Done.
 

Zubz

Banned
Hey Ouro, please remove me from the replacement list and give me a link to the dead thread. Thanks.

Me too. I hate to be a burden, but between work/classes/Internship starting up, and recent circumstances in Archer blowing my mind, I think I'm better off hooting and speculating in private, instead of hopping back into a new game. Thanks, Boss!
 

Ourobolus

Banned
Me too. I hate to be a burden, but between work/classes/Internship starting up, and recent circumstances in Archer blowing my mind, I think I'm better off hooting and speculating in private, instead of hopping back into a new game. Thanks, Boss!
Will do.
 

El Topo

Member
Me too. I hate to be a burden, but between work/classes/Internship starting up, and recent circumstances in Archer blowing my mind, I think I'm better off hooting and speculating in private, instead of hopping back into a new game. Thanks, Boss!

One of us. One of us.
 

roytheone

Member
Me too. I hate to be a burden, but between work/classes/Internship starting up, and recent circumstances in Archer blowing my mind, I think I'm better off hooting and speculating in private, instead of hopping back into a new game. Thanks, Boss!

Yeaaaah, the GOAT wolf duo will fuck some shit up in the death thread!
 

Zubz

Banned
Zubz will make a ridiculous claim setting off a series of traps leading to someone else's death. And there will not be much rejoicing :(

Nah. I save that stuff for the games. Man, I hope we get to match wits again some day. I can be the Moriarty to your Magnum P.I., or something!
 

Swamped

Banned
Ourobolus' flavor posts never fail to crack me up! When the Archer game ends you should just compile them all into a novella or something.
 

Sorian

Banned
Ourobolus' flavor posts never fail to crack me up! When the Archer game ends you should just compile them all into a novella or something.

I've already asked him to novelize the entirety of the archer game but for a completely different reason.
 
Top Bottom