Seriously, pinpoint the fucking sweet spot. Get a jpg of a rink and point out exactly -where- it happens. Then replicate it repeatedly.
"Around the blue line" is not good enough. I'm not trying to be a dick here, more info is needed to really get a grip on what's going on. It could just be the goalie's stats combined with some random occurance.
Never mind the fact that I've played 3 games in this league, and 4 in another on AS, and the subject hasn't come up once. I didn't just change how I play for you, so I'd think that someone else would have had some words about it if it were a problem.
I looked over at operation sports and on the 2k5 boards and found nothing about this at all, so I think you're blowing this way out of proportion.