Support NeoGAF

[roytheone]

Huh, two people claiming the exact same power. And it is also a power that would make sense for a scum player to have (to find PR). So my current guess is that either Nin or Terra are actually scum, and the other is town.

 

[Ty4on]

Huh, two people claiming the exact same power. And it is also a power that would make sense for a scum player to have (to find PR). So my current guess is that either Nin or Terra are actually scum, and the other is town.

I've already pointed it out, but so far one confirmed difference is that Nin only knows motion happened while Terra knew after N1 that he only detected motion in one seat.

 

[nin1000]

And it is really specific that you observe both motion from targeting and being targeted? The motion and tracker bit makes it sound like you only detect people targeting and not people being targeted.

I KNOW when someone nearby is using or being targeting by an ability.

At the end of each night phase i will beinformed if one of my immediate neighbors used or was targeted by an active night action but i wont be informed who it was.

That is as close as i can come without quoting mate.

The PM i recieve each night says that there was activity nearby.

 

[Ty4on]

Thanks.

Just wanted to reiterate in case the PM was a little vague and you misread. Weird how similar your and Terra's abilities are while being slightly different and being called something different in the PM.

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

Hey, uh, I need to say that's possible I read too much into the flavor on night one, because my night to flavor text changed to a more vague ANY seat arround you rather than night one's "One seat arround you." Just so I don't go killing this line of thought.

 

[Ty4on]

Hey, uh, I need to say that's possible I read too much into the flavor on night one, because my night to flavor text changed to a more vague ANY seat arround you rather than night one's "One seat arround you." Just so I don't go killing this line of thought.

Clarify with the mod if you're not sure.

 

[Ty4on]

I know this is edging on quoting PMs (so don't do that), but why did the second night PM say "any" when you detected no motion?

 

[nin1000]

Huh, two people claiming the exact same power. And it is also a power that would make sense for a scum player to have (to find PR). So my current guess is that either Nin or Terra are actually scum, and the other is town.

That would also be one option. I wanted to make things clear as soon as possiblesince i already soft claimed far too often to survive tonight. Might aswell get every info out there while its fresh.

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

Clarify with the mod if you're not sure.

I would like to, but if Retro did talk to me, that would essentially be mod confirming my role, wouldn't it?

 

[AbsolutBro]

I know this is edging on quoting PMs (so don't do that), but why did the second night PM say "any" when you detected no motion?

I suspect a wording like "any seat around you" could just as easily have been "either seat around you".

Always best to PM the game runner though

 

[nin1000]

I know this is edging on quoting PMs (so don't do that), but why did the second night PM say "any" when you detected no motion?

I did detect motion by you and/or Camjo-Z

 

[Ty4on]

I would like to, but if Retro did talk to me, that would essentially be mod confirming my role, wouldn't it?

I obviously meant in private. Shoot a PM and ask if you get to know whether motion happened in just one seat or if it's ambiguous. Ask what the D1 PM means and why it is worded that way etc.

 

[nin1000]

Hi

 

[Ty4on]

I did detect motion by you and/or Camjo-Z

I asked Terra who claimed no motion next to him N2.

 

[nin1000]

Hey, uh, I need to say that's possible I read too much into the flavor on night one, because my night to flavor text changed to a more vague ANY seat arround you rather than night one's "One seat arround you." Just so I don't go killing this line of thought.

i dont know if that is allowed ?

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

I know this is edging on quoting PMs (so don't do that), but why did the second night PM say "any" when you detected no motion?

Because I didn't detect activity from any of the seats arround me.

 

[Ty4on]

I suspect a wording like "any seat around you" could just as easily have been "either seat around you".

Always best to PM the game runner though

Just seemed weird for the PM mentioning no movement (Terra N2) to be ambiguous about that.

Like, "You detected no motion in any seat next to you" seems a little clunky.

 

[nin1000]

I asked Terra who claimed no motion next to him N2.

whoops , my bad

 

[Ty4on]

Because I didn't detect activity from any of the seats arround me.

Well, there it is.

Keep us informed if you get a clarification from Retro.

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

i dont know if that is allowed ?

Did you just... Edit your post?

 

[nin1000]

Did you just... Edit your post?

i did, since i dont know if the above you did was even allowed.

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

i did, since i dont know if the above you did was even allowed.

Well, I know for sure editing your posts isn't.

He should be able to confirm that in private, or at least ask and not get an answer.

 

[Sorian]

Anything said on this page is fine.

Don't edit posts.

Move on.

 

[nin1000]

ok here is the initial post

Hey, uh, I need to say that's possible I read too much into the flavor on night one, because my night to flavor text changed to a more vague ANY seat arround you rather than night one's "One seat arround you." Just so I don't go killing this line of thought.

I can confirm, since i got the same message as he did.

That does mean that Timeaisis is NOT cleared. Initially Terra claimed he got a message saying that ONE seat moved but since he got another PM from Retro being more vague it means that the other seat could have moved aswell.

 

[Burbeting]

Can we have a votecount, please?

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

Ok, can someone (preferably not Nin) succinctly tell me what's going on?

Does the role PM say you'll get a message when someone around you moves, or was it a response to the action PM? Doesn't Terra get a number of the seats that have moved? I'm so confused.

 

[nin1000]

Ok, can someone (preferably not Nin) succinctly tell me what's going on?

Does the role PM say you'll get a message when someone around you moves, or was it a response to the action PM? Doesn't Terra get a number of the seats that have moved? I'm so confused.

I KNOW when someone nearby is using or being targeting by an ability.

At the end of each night phase i will be informed if one of my immediate neighbors used or was targeted by an active night action but i wont be informed who it was.

That is as close as i can come without quoting mate.

The PM i recieve each night says that there was activity nearby.

as said above

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

Ok, can someone (preferably not Nin) succinctly tell me what's going on?

Does the role PM say you'll get a message when someone around you moves, or was it a response to the action PM? Doesn't Terra get a number of the seats that have moved? I'm so confused.

Until further notice, assume that Nin and I have the exact same role in terms of power.

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

Ok, so let me get this straight. You guys can just nod in agreement.

Terrabyte20xx has a role PM that says he will be told how many of his immediate neighbors have been the target of an action or have targeted another player with an action. His result PM refers to players “nearby”.

Nin1000 has a role PM that says he will be informed when any of his immediate neighbors have been the target of an action or have targeted another player with an action. As in, it’s either yes or no. His result PM refers to players “nearby”.

I'm not sure why you guys are having difficulty expressing yourselves.

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

Okay, I have received clarification. I read too much into the flavor, I don't know how many had activity, just that it happened.

 

[nin1000]

Ok, so let me get this straight. You guys can just nod in agreement.

Terrabyte20xx has a role PM that says he will be told how many of his immediate neighbors have been the target of an action or have targeted another player with an action. His result PM refers to players “nearby”.

Nin1000 has a role PM that says he will be informed when any of his immediate neighbors have been the target of an action or have targeted another player with an action. As in, it’s either yes or no. His result PM refers to players “nearby”.

I'm not sure why you guys are having difficulty expressing yourselves.

*nod*
You are the one having difficulties understanding us

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

So it is exactly like Nin, a yes/no.

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

Where did you even get the number thing from Terra? :|

Ok, so, Time and Burb are both still on the board.

 

[nin1000]

Okay, I have received clarification. I read too much into the flavor, I don't know how many had activity, just that it happened.

Well, that means that we have the same role lol

 

[nin1000]

Where did you even get the number thing from Terra? :|

Ok, so, Time and Burb are both still on the board.

yep

Night 1

Timeaisis
Burbeting

Night 2

Ty4on
Camjo-z

 

[Burbeting]

Is it likely that two members of town have the exatly same role, though?

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

Is it likely that two members of town have the exatly same role, though?

Yes, there is a precedence too. Anyone remember Animal Crossing?

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

So, Terra and nin, I have a question for you both.

What do you think of the people sitting next to you this phase?

 

[Burbeting]

If nin tells the truth either one of us (me or time) targeted someone, or that someone targeted us. That leaves things really, really vague.

 

[Burbeting]

Yes, there is a precedence too. Anyone remember Animal Crossing?

What bothers me is that Xam and Launch have both claimed a very similar role as well, although only Xam has been mostly verified.

 

[nin1000]

So, Terra and nin, I have a question for you both.

What do you think of the people sitting next to you this phase?

Camjo-Z and Ty4on no read at all atm.
Burbeting is of course trying to be a good town player , he even initiated the kill for Weemad. but i dont want to go as far and say he is town since we are talking about Burbeting a experienced Bear.
Timeaisis is a good player aswell who did not poke out too much but did his fair share of posts.

Will have to read through most of their posts now.

 

[LaunchpadMcQ]

What bothers me is that Xam and Launch have both claimed a very similar role as well, although only Xam has been mostly verified.

Why does it bother you? Having mirrored roles isn't that surprising.

 

[Terrabyte20xx]

So, Terra and nin, I have a question for you both.

What do you think of the people sitting next to you this phase?

Burb is leaning town to me.

You are a null read. Sometimes you seem town, others it feels like coasting from your previous claim.

 

[Burbeting]

Why does it bother you? Having mirrored roles isn't that surprising.

I guess I just assume that 1 role that is mirrored to be more normal and several.

 

[nin1000]

Oh, almost forgot

UNVOTE

meaning that those other suspects are faar more important for my money than you kalor atm.

 

[nin1000]

Burb is leaning town to me.

You are a null read. Sometimes you seem town, others it feels like coasting from your previous claim.

Thats the thing. There could be a wolf hidden in that bear coat.

 

[Fireblend]

I don't know about pursuing Burb. How is Timeasis any less suspicious than him? And does everyone agree to just drop the previous candidates and follow nin's suspicions? I feel like this is dragging us away from progress. I'll keep my vote on Ouro for now. How long til the day ends?

 

[RetroMG]

Announcement

Please note that since AbsolutBro has broken his primary hand, he may be slower to respond. Please be patient with him in this regard.

Thank you.

 

[Burbeting]

Thats the thing. There could be a wolf hidden in that bear coat.

You really think I would swap my vote from Salva to weemad, and ask for weemad to be lynched, if I was scum?

 

[Fireblend]

Announcement

Please note that since AbsolutBro has broken his primary hand, he may be slower to respond. Please be patient with him in this regard.

Thank you.

These gambits are getting out of hand.