LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I just wanted to know if Ouro needed to die or not.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 2: The Bride of Gafia |Mafia OT| One Wedding, Many Funerals
- Thread starter RetroMG
- Start date
You're just mad that our unspoken townie bond has been fractured.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Also, fortunately for us, since we've seen this role before, we can do better in corralling it.. right?
I'm fine with going back to scumhunting, I just have a slightly more pressing matter at hand.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I'd like to get to the arsonist hunting, because one more confirmed non-scum surviving is not a bad thing in my book as long as it's contained.
Hmm, I still suspect launch and his invisible power. Would be a good play as an arsonist, we will not lynch him and since he is out of shots, scum will not night kill him.
Both absolute and Tim fall in the low activity blendy category, which is where I would expect an arsonist to be. I doubt they will go completely afk though, so AbsolutBro is a bit more suspicious.
If the arsonist can target cross table : rip us ;__;
Yeah...ditto.
I still have AB at the top of my list, with Tim and Launch roughly tied for second. I explained why I think Tim might not be the arso based on how my drinks were received on N2, but it's nothing concrete.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
You guys give me way too much credit. The fact that RNH never received a glass should be telling.
But why wouldn't the new receiver claim? Even if you are scum, that is easy town points. I got town points by immediately claiming my gorlak mark in hp. Then again, the same is true for rnh, so I think he really didn't receive anything. It's all quite bizarre.
Look, I'm not saying it didn't happen. I still think you were able to switch the table, but I don't have any clue where the second drink went. I think it's highly unlikely that an arsonist would ALSO be able to swap a table at night before everyone else's actions occurred. But I've been wrong before, and Palmer was involved with this game, so who knows?
PALLLLMMMMEEEERRRRRRRR
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I honestly have no idea where the drink could have gone or why they didn't come forward. Roy is right, it doesn't really mesh. Why wouldn't they come forward? Hmm.
AbsolutBro
Member
@underlined what exactly no longer constitutes low activity? Im 7th in posts out of 18 active living players. Im ordinary town so I have to go on what is in thread and only what is in thread. Ive put forward theories, Ive questioned others, Ive answered questions.
@bolded BS, apparently going afk completely is the best way to not be lynched in gafia games
You no longer need to be blendy. You are now a top arsonist candidate, and with a town and neutral doused, scum wouldn't kill you. You no longer need to fear a nk and thus can be more active.
AbsolutBro
Member
Thats it. That is the totality of Czar's posts this day phase.
His vote on me came after the arsonist short lists were discussed
His second post is a response to someone asking his (and my) thoughts on the arsonist. (which he of course doesnt want to get side tracked on!)
Xam and "oreo" are his top scum, but we 'know' now that Ouro is neutral and while xam could be scum, he is definitely not the arsonist.
then a joke about Bronx's role
and a final clear up post about Bronx already being confirmed as a gossip.
but yeah, I am totally more suspicious and going afk is totally not what someone whose role seems to function during the night phase only would do.
AbsolutBro
Member
No one needs to fear the NK due to activity. Not when we have a confirmed town in Bronx, something scum should ever want walking around. Between Bronx and now TWO trackers, scum would be borderline mental to go after someone for posting rates. It's unbelievable this is even a thing bearing discussion.
Xamtheking
Member
I think Kalor is a good vote
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
Hmm. Kalor is a good vote. I mostly just don't want to get doused, tbh, but also roytheone is a strong town read for me and Ouro is pro-town. Then again, I've outlived my usefulness...
Ok.
VOTE: Kalor
Ok.
VOTE: Kalor
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
I don't want any last minute shenanigans if possible, please. And no turbo.
Xamtheking
Member
remember what happened the last time we had shenanagins
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
That's not really the point and you know it.
If your so up for arsonist hunting why did you just switch to Kalor? I mean, I agree, Kalor is my top scum, too. But he's not even on my radar for arsonist.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
That second post is me reasoning maybe scum is better. To be honest, I don't know. I guess it really depends if Roy is ok with possibly dying. :|
Yeah, fair enough. What do you think, roy?
It was nice knowing you, Roy.
Did I miss something? Why would the arsonist ignite tonight? With only two people doused? I doubt his quota is only two. That would be to easy.
I honestly have no idea - he may have a quota, or he may just have to kill as many as possible and survive (probably unlikely). He could also possibly ignite more than once. Just theorizing.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
He douses someone else > we don't lynch him again next phase > ignite > 3 people dead.
I think most arsonists can ignite more then once, but getting everyone in one big move is more beneficial since you only spend one night igniting instead of multiple.
Technically true, but if we're completely off-base with the table-specific dousing, then we've potentially got a situation where we aren't going to catch them any time soon.
AbsolutBro
Member
Or lynch Czar and be done with the whole arsonist thing.
Just sayin.
Just sayin.
He's next on my list!
Ugh, on the one hand I want to switch my vote to absolut bro to prevent me from burning, but I fear that if we hunt for the arsonist we will end up misslynching twice which will leave us with two wasted days that tell us nothing about who is scum. With the arsonist igniting that would put us in a very bad position, few mislynches left with two unusable days for scum hunting. I think I will keep my vote on Kalor.
TBF we may end up getting a scum in the arsonist hunt. It's not like scum is free of suspicion.
Maybe, but scum tend to have an easier time hiding in a neutral hunt.
AbsolutBro
Member
He should be first on your list!
But wait, that spot is currently filled by...oh, oh...you almost had me there
I honsetly don't think AB is either scum nor arsonist, I read him as town and I really hope I am not wrong in this one.
Right now all my top suspects have been "cleared" in a few ways, ouro by his drink claim and RNH by terra.
I also don't feel the Kalor lynch, for reasons I have talked about before. I won't be above voting him out if there is no other suspect, but I'll rather pick someone else.
Someone like Camjo-Z.
Vote: Camjo-Z
Right now all my top suspects have been "cleared" in a few ways, ouro by his drink claim and RNH by terra.
I also don't feel the Kalor lynch, for reasons I have talked about before. I won't be above voting him out if there is no other suspect, but I'll rather pick someone else.
Someone like Camjo-Z.
Vote: Camjo-Z
AbsolutBro
Member
You'll find out shortly that you're not.
wow I fell asleep in the middle of the day that was weird
but it did give me some time to consider what to do today, so:
I'll back off of Ouro. I guess maybe he could be the harmless drink guy, and tbh if he's bad then it's taking ages for something bad to actually happen so whatever. You're off my radar friend.
UNVOTE
That said, I think this Kalor vote is hilarious and transparent. Killing him is literally doing the dirty work of both mafia and arsonist. He claimed commuter, which means he's the one role neither of them are going to want to touch since he could easily be lying about which day he picked - or heck, just be totally lying and be something even worse for non-townies. What better way to eliminate the unknown threat than by lynching?
And so, I am updating my MAFIA RADAR to remove ouro and nin (whose claim I believe) and adding Burbeting, who apparently moved N1 (sup killer) and who I suspect is pushing Kalor as the lynch because he knows he can probably get away with it. You and Fireblend are my TOP NUMERO UNO SUSPECTS
VOTE: Burbeting
thanks mate
but it did give me some time to consider what to do today, so:
I'll back off of Ouro. I guess maybe he could be the harmless drink guy, and tbh if he's bad then it's taking ages for something bad to actually happen so whatever. You're off my radar friend.
UNVOTE
That said, I think this Kalor vote is hilarious and transparent. Killing him is literally doing the dirty work of both mafia and arsonist. He claimed commuter, which means he's the one role neither of them are going to want to touch since he could easily be lying about which day he picked - or heck, just be totally lying and be something even worse for non-townies. What better way to eliminate the unknown threat than by lynching?
And so, I am updating my MAFIA RADAR to remove ouro and nin (whose claim I believe) and adding Burbeting, who apparently moved N1 (sup killer) and who I suspect is pushing Kalor as the lynch because he knows he can probably get away with it. You and Fireblend are my TOP NUMERO UNO SUSPECTS
VOTE: Burbeting
thanks mate
Xamtheking
Member
I can definitely see Burb being scum
But I'd much rather get rid of Kalor today
But I'd much rather get rid of Kalor today
Burbeting just posted a huge list of all the claims a few pages ago, so... that.
Fair enough. Both of them are next to motion detectors tonight, so I'm not particularly concerned about either one slipping through the cracks.
Why Burb?
What makes Burb a good target? Nin and Terra's powers are quite vague.
Call it a hunch.
But enough about my back problems. Burb just reads to me like a guy trying to take control of the narrative. I'd rather not let him.
Just in general control the narrative, or in any specific direction?
What do you make of his vote on Wee? That vote came from Salva even so without it Salva's lead would have been even bigger.