I'm curious to see if Jeff posts his FO4 review soon or waits for a patch. With all the negative news regarding the framerate on consoles, surely Bethesda is working quickly to release a patch. Jeff seemed to love the game itself. Maybe enough to give it a 3 or a 4, with the current state of affairs on console. A patch that improves the framerate could possibly make it a 4 of a 5.
Personally, I think the current review systems for most sites need to be overhauled. Games are becoming more and more fluid and reviews quickly become outdated. It shouldn't be this way, but it is. As controversial as they are, Polygon adjusts their reviews (negatively or positively) if it is warranted. Their Driveclub review (for instance) went down (when the found it was broken) and then up again (when the game was fixed).