I've made a decision:
1) ICO (My first PS2 game)
And my second game will be an RPG.
And strangely, Gamestop doesn't seem to have many of those Atlus RPG's everyone likes. I think I'll get Phantom Brave or Dark Cloud 2. I looked up the highest rated ones on IGN, and I have actually seen the FF games played. What I saw didn't really appeal to me as a gamer. I would buy more games, but I'm making a pretty big investment in the system itself. Maybe some other time. :/
Sorry if bumping this thread is annoying. I just want to make the right decisions.