Khalifa Jayy
Banned
WELCOME TO THE OFFICIAL PIXEL [AND PIXEL XL] REVIEW THREAD.
ArsTechnica [ArsTechnica Approved; The best Android phone, even if it's a little pricey]
WIRED [No score; positive review] || [WIRED PIXEL CAMERA PHOTO GALLERY]
The Wall Street Journal [No score; positive review]
The Verge ["Home Run" apparently means 9; positive review]
TechCrunch [No score; positive review]
FORBES [No score; positive review]
9TO5GOOGLE [No score; positive review]
ChipChick [No score; positive review]
TechnoBuffalo [Mostly positive review; "Wait and see" verdict]
CNet ["Pure Android at its absolute best" = 8.8]
Engadget [86; Other Android phone makers should be worried]
Gizmodo [The Google Pixel Is Too Dumb and Ugly to Replace Your iPhone]
NYTimes [Neutral, somewhat negative review]
Will update when more are linked or shared.
___________________________________________________________________
Overall impressions seem positive. Anyone here getting one? What phone are you leaving behind?
ArsTechnica [ArsTechnica Approved; The best Android phone, even if it's a little pricey]
The Good
•Android from Google. This is a cohesive, consistent software package instead of being a branding battleground between Google and a third party.
•The Assistant is fun, fast, and useful. A great evolution of Google's already great voice command system.
•The only 2016 Android phone with fast OS updates.
•One of the best cameras on a smartphone. Great low light shots and speedy performance.
•Has a headphone jack. Won't explode.
The Bad
•The sky-high price feels more like a marketing ploy ("We're just as good as the iPhone!") than a justifiable price point.
•The single speaker is a big downgrade from the Nexus 6P. Google is charging more and delivering less.
•A rear glass panel adds fragility and ugliness in exchange for... nothing? Just use metal.
•Other devices at this price point from Samsung and Apple are "dunkable" in water with IP68 rating. The Pixels are not.
•Still no SD card slot even though Google made SD cards much more usable in Android 6.0.
•Google's two years of major OS updates can't compare to Apple's iPhone support, which is often 4+ years of OS updates.
The Ugly
•Google's flagship smartphone design is a bland iPhone clone. Do better.
WIRED [No score; positive review] || [WIRED PIXEL CAMERA PHOTO GALLERY]
But I’m switching. For real. I’m turning off iMessage, re-buying apps, and warning friends that I probably won’t get their texts for a few days. I am a little worried about Google’s long-term commitment to this new hardware push (and the customer support that comes with it), given its propensity for killing products that don’t get billions of users. But I’m totally in love with the Pixel. I love this camera, I love Google Assistant, I love that I’ll get to use it with a comfy VR headset, I love that I finally get a version of Android that is both powerful and attractive. I love that there’s a kickass Android phone that (probably) doesn’t explode.
The immediate joke everyone, including me, made on Twitter after the Pixel launch was that Google made an iPhone. Well, that’s true. As it turns out, an iPhone running Android is exactly what I’ve been waiting for.
The Wall Street Journal [No score; positive review]
Google Pixel Review: The Android iPhone You’ve Been Waiting For
Google yanked a page from Apple’s playbook and created the best Android phone
Android people, please step forward. Good news! Your next phone-buying decision just got a heck of a lot easier. The Google Pixel is now the best Android smartphone you can buy. The other leading contender was disqualified due to spontaneous combustion.
iPhone people, it’s your turn. Ask yourself: Why do I have an iPhone? Is it because of its software, services and privacy policies? Or is it because it’s a very good phone for things like Google Maps, Gmail, Spotify and Facebook Messenger? If you’ve answered yes to the latter, the Pixel may be for you, too.
The Verge ["Home Run" apparently means 9; positive review]
Both Pixel variants have a Qualcomm Snapdragon 821 processor, 4 gigs of RAM, and flat-out gorgeous OLED screens with deep blacks and vibrant, punchy colors. And that’s important: at some point next month, Daydream VR will finally get released and you’ll want high-quality screens for that.
The Pixels are fast — noticeably faster than Samsung’s Galaxy S7. On performance alone, these are easily the best Android phones you can buy. For a phone made by Google, that’s absolutely the expectation — it’s just good to note that at its first time at bat, Google hit a home run.
Good Stuff:
• Long battery life
• Fast and powerful
• Google Assistant
Bad Stuff:
• Not waterproof
• Pedestrian design
• Google's take on Android needs more polish
TechCrunch [No score; positive review]
When yours is the only name on a handset, you’d better put your best foot forward. Sure, the company got manufacturing help from its friends at HTC, but the message is clear — sink or swim, it’s all on Google. And on just about every count, the company delivers. It’s a well-designed (if aesthetically neutral) handset with robust specs and a killer screen and camera.
Most importantly of all, it’s a demonstration, much like Apple’s output, of what happens when the same company is involved in the design of an end-to-end hardware and software solution. It feels natural and works together like a charm — and, unlike a number of competing Android handsets, nothing feels tacked on after the fact. An arguably ironic message for a company that’s been so supportive of third-parties up to this point.
And with the first seeds of pieces like Assistant being sowed, the Pixel XL also feels like a bridge to the future of the company, as Google sets its sights on your home and beyond.
FORBES [No score; positive review]
The 32GB Pixel XL retails for $769 for the Google Store, which puts it on par with the prices of the Apple iPhone 7 and the Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge. It’s clear that Google is aiming for the premium Android smartphone market and not toward budget-oriented consumers. However, if you’re someone who uses the camera function a lot, the phone could just be worth the price since it takes professional-quality photos with ease. And if you just need to have a premium smartphone, the XL can certainly go toe-to-toe with its closest competitors, and is a worthy option to consider.
9TO5GOOGLE [No score; positive review]
The elephant(s) in the room, I think, are the Chinese-made budget offerings like the OnePlus 3. In terms of raw specifications, the OnePlus 3 is very comparable to the Pixel — and in some ways better. It’s also a whole 2 or 3 Benjamins cheaper. Honestly, it’s a difficult situation. The Pixel really is great. And in some ways it’s one of the best phones ever. Early — and perhaps exclusive — access to Google’s latest software features is hard to pass up for some. It has near-stock Android with valuable software additions on top and reliable performance. It has the Snapdragon 821. But is it worth the extra cash?
I can’t answer that question for you. I think for me, the answer is yes. I would pick this phone over most Android phones. But I’m also a big fan of Google software, and I prefer to use Android the way Google intends it. None of the other OEMs can offer this flavor of Android that has this degree of Google’s mark and influence. All things considered, these phones aren’t perfect. But no phones are, and if you’re one who loves Google’s software and services as much as I do, they might be the imperfect phones for you.
ChipChick [No score; positive review]
There’s no doubt that the Pixel XL is a phenomenal phone and a worthy successor to past Nexus devices. Being Google’s very own flagship, it’s the yardstick by which all future Android handsets will be measured. We love the materials and craftsmanship, the beautiful display, the snappy performance, and the pure user experience. The camera is top notch, despite the lack of OIS, and we’re looking forward to many shake-free videos. That being said, it’s an expensive device, the design is somewhat generic, and Google Assistant still feels like a bit of a gimmick. Is it a buy? Yes, absolutely — if you can afford it. Make no mistake: the Pixel XL represents the cream of the Android crop. It immediately puts Google in the rarefied company of Samsung and Apple at the top of the smartphone game, and that’s no small feat.
The Good: Great build quality, gorgeous screen, excellent camera, top notch performance, pure Google.
The Bad: Pricey, bland design, lack of OIS, not water-resistant.
TechnoBuffalo [Mostly positive review; "Wait and see" verdict]
I have too many questions about the focus of the Google Pixel and not enough confidence in its future. It’s a fine phone, sure, but there are plenty of devices that offer similar performance and, in some cases, more features, for the same price or less.
You want an Android phone? Buy a Galaxy S7 Edge. You want an Android phone that doesn’t break the bank? Buy a OnePlus 3. You want an Android Phone with Google Assistant? Buy a Nexus 6P and hack it on. Want something unique? Buy a Moto Z. You want an expensive Android phone with 24/7 support, unlimited Google Photo backup and the chance at getting the latest software first? Then get the Pixel. I suggest waiting to see what Google’s grander plan for the Pixel is before diving in, however. With the glaring hole left by the Galaxy Note 7 in my arsenal, I’ll personally be switching over to the Moto Z.
PROS:
•Decent battery life
•Great camera
•First dibs on Android software
CONS:
•Uninspiring design
•Expensive
•Not water resistant
•No wireless charging
•No expandable storage
CNet ["Pure Android at its absolute best" = 8.8]
But the Pixel is a beaut. It runs fast and comes at a time when the largest Android phone-maker, Samsung, is hitting some rough luck. Save for its Lens Blur feature, the Pixel's camera exceeded my high expectations and gives the iPhone a run for its money. Google Assistant feels more natural than other voice search systems, and it's handy for organizing your daily life (if you remember it's there).
Now that many are justifiably cautious of Samsung phones, the Pixel is a great option for Android users wondering where to go next. Its brand cachet already rivals Samsung and Apple. Unlike the Nexus models of years past, you don't have to be an Android enthusiast to appreciate it. The only thing you'll have to be enthusiastic about is owning a phone that's beautiful, takes awesome photos and has smooth performance. If you are, the Pixel's for you.
The Good
The Google Pixel has a fantastic camera, especially in low light. It's elegantly designed. Google Assistant takes one of the most natural, human approaches to answering your voice.
The Bad
The phone's display is dim in outdoor sunlight and its camera's Lens Blur feature is shoddy. It's splash-resistant rather than dunkable, and it's pricey compared to previous Google Nexus devices.
The Bottom Line
If you're wary of Samsung or looking for a worthy iPhone alternative, the Google Pixel is the high-end Android phone to get
Engadget [86; Other Android phone makers should be worried]
As the story goes, Google only really got to contribute to Nexus phones once they were 90 percent done. That's crazy, isn't it? I loved the Nexus line from day one, but it always felt clear that Google was just experimenting with things while its hardware partners took on most of the risk. Now Google is sticking its own neck out there, and the market -- no, the people -- won't stand for mediocrity.
Thankfully, the Pixels are much, much better than that. They certainly have their share of shortcomings, like a drab design, wimpy water resistance and some hefty price tags. The thing is, Google had to start somewhere, and the foundation it built with these two phones is a surprisingly strong one. These aren't just great first attempts at smartphones; these are great smartphones, period, and every other Android device maker out there should be a little worried.
Pros
Excellent build quality
Fantastic camera
Smooth performance
Cons
Expensive
Yawn-inducing design
Less water-resistant than rivals
Gizmodo [The Google Pixel Is Too Dumb and Ugly to Replace Your iPhone]
README
·The first truly homegrown Google phone
·The Pixel XL is somehow chunkier than last year’s Nexus 6P
·Holy crap, this phone is super fast
·Smart burst photo mode is great for capturing the perfect moment
·Google Assistant is a promising feature, but ultimately not full baked
·The glass on the back of the phone feels sticky and kind of gross to hold in your hand
·How is this better than my Nexus 6P again?
NYTimes [Neutral, somewhat negative review]
Based on features alone, the Pixel is decent compared with Apple’s iPhone 7 and Samsung’s Galaxy S7.
...
Using Pixel with Project Fi may also end up saving you money: If you picked, for example, a plan with two gigabytes of data, you’d pay $40 a month for cellphone and data service that works all over the world. In contrast, Verizon charges $55 a month for a similar plan that doesn’t include free international roaming.
If you are uninterested in Project Fi and are not deeply invested in Google’s ecosystem, there is another route: Try an iPhone. Apple’s iPhone 7 and 7 Plus outperformed the Pixel in every way in terms of hardware features.
And so far, to my knowledge, Apple phones haven’t blown up.
Will update when more are linked or shared.
___________________________________________________________________
Overall impressions seem positive. Anyone here getting one? What phone are you leaving behind?