Yep, and I honestly think we saw locke in Halo 4. I wish with every bone in my body that this guy interrogating Halsey in this scene, especially with the degree of interest he showcased in the Chief, ends up being Locke.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKanxNE-FT4
Who else is with me!? I want this interrogator to end up being Locke.
Made a similar guess a while back in the Halo 4 OT, but I'll link it here. I was convinced that's who it was, but the skin thing definitely throws it off. However, Halsey did recognize that he was something other than ONI in the cutscene. That clever Dr.
While that would be cool, would it really make sense in the timeline? Halsey was being interrogated, then was later kidnapped. MC was with the UNSC after that interrogation took place, so if Locke was looking for MC then surely he would've found him already.
Interesting though if they connect that.
More speculation: I don't think he was looking for Chief at this point, rather, trying to glean information about him from Halsey. Or force some sort of admission from her.
This part stands out especially, when you listen to the intonations and reaction:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GbjA6rB98Yk#t=135
Interrogator: "Do you believe the Master Chief succeeded because he was, at his core, broken?"
Halsey: "What does John have to do with this? …you want to replace him."
Interrogator: "The Master Chief is dead."
Halsey: "His file reads 'Missing in Action'."
Interrogator: Catherine, Spartans never die?
He challenges her, almost angrily when he says the word broken - and immediately Halsey recognizes something weird about that question, and deduces his intent.
He says the Master Chief is dead... seems almost sombre-like.
Now in the timeline, at this point, everyone believes Chief is dead - even this character. So when Halsey says he's MIA, he sort of challenges the adage of "Spartans Never Die" in a pretty condescending tone.
I think he wants to be the "next" Chief. The new beacon of humanity, the celebrity. He seems almost jealous, as if trying to specifically discredit Chief (at first seems like he's trying to discredit the Spartan II program, but his fishing tips Halsey off). This could also just be her first finding out about the Spartan IV program, and this guy is one of the designers.
Now Chief coming back during Halo 4 makes it kind of weird... though he didn't have all that much down time, really. Wild theory? This Agent Locke guy tries to kill Chief after Halo 4, when he goes to investigate New Phoenix, hence the broken armour and cloak in the reveal trailer. Maybe under instruction of Osman at ONI, maybe under his own volition. Chief takes off after finding something... maybe a message from someone. I guess that next Escalation comic vol. 8[7-9] would debunk this.
Arbiter seems to not trust the guy, based on what he says in the teaser, but he also seems to think that he is the only hope in finding Chief. Arbiter is responsible for "turning" Agent Locke.
Halo 5 Guardians[of the Mantle]. Chief, Arbiter, Agent Locke.
--
Well she says the others were naval Intel and you aren't. Doesn't Locke have the ONI tag on his armour? So he would be naval Intel... Not saying he couldn't have joined after this took place.
More wild speculation: She assumes as much. Halsey is incredibly perceptive, she clues in right as the guy asking: "...do you think the... Spartans' lack of basic humanity helped?" She says, body language suggesting quite surprised or confused: "What are you after? The others before you were Naval Intelligence... but you... you're
something else." Doesn't necessarily mean he isn't ONI. I imagine only ONI would be allowed to even interrogate Halsey. I take it as her seeing through that, as him being something "more", with an ulterior motive not directly aligning with the previous ONI interrogations. Was the Spartan IV program hidden from ONI? Not that I know. So why would this guy be asking questions like this?
He's trying to get her to admit that the Spartan II's, and Chief specifically are flawed due to their lack of basic humanity. Why? Because he is obsessed (maybe "brainwashed" by ONI). Because he wants to be Chief (Halsey: "You want to replace him"). Though Halo 4's story, and ending, shows us that Chief is discovering his humanity, so we know that that isn't true.
Also, he is in shadows the entire time. Why wouldn't they show the interrogator? What would that accomplish? Who is this guy? Why is he being hidden from us, when no one else related to the Spartan IV program or ONI itself was. They're hiding him for a reason. Insurrectionist? Top-secret Covie informant? I can't really think of a good reason other than we aren't supposed to know yet.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mui5LuTQReg
We see Locke in a Covenant-looking room somewhere, maybe Sanghelios[probably Vadam Keep], observing floating video holograms of Chief, from scenes in previous Halo games (and the Halo 5 reveal teaser).
If you pause the video at just the right time (about 1:32), you see he is with the Arbiter standing right next to him, and also a couple seconds later reflecting in his visor.
Arbiter's message to Locke in the teaser:
To find him, you have to forget the stories, forget the legends.
You have to do more than walk in his footsteps, for he is more than the sum of his actions.
I tell you this, not because I trust you, Agent Locke, but because ALL our lives are at stake. Because the seeds of our future are sewn in his past.
Arbiter is being pretty poetic here. [First, we know they are looking for him.] Telling him to forget the stories (his preconceived notions of who and what Chief really is[?]). That he is more than the sum of his actions (succeeding at saving humanity, which the interrogator presses Halsey is due to his lack of humanity). Arbiter doesn't trust him. Why? Because he, or ONI, tried to kill Chief. But this guy is so good, "do more than walk in his footsteps" (not just replacing Chief, live through Chief's exploits via Halo MC Collection, Prologue and Epilogue[snip]). Arbiter seems to fear some greater threat, and that they must work together to find Chief, because "the
seeds of our future are s[o]wn in his past". (maybe a geas of some kind? possibly related to Cortana? Maybe related to the Librarian's little enhancement that she gave to Chief? I don't know what this means...).
I'm going too crazy in this I think, lol. But that's my theory.
/wildspeculation
The questions he is asking don't really make much sense if he was another Spartan but you do have me wondering who that guy is now, I never really thought about it before now.
I definitely he has shared interests with the Agent Locke (not convinced anymore that he is the same person), or the entity overseeing Locke [Osman?], at least that will have been the case at some point.
Either way, there's clearly a hell of a lot more going on here than we think. I'm working on this to near obsession, lol... more musings incoming soon.