• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Halo |OT 23| Thruster is Love, Thruster is Life

Hey guys,

What colour is this sword? My friends say white but I say its blue!!!
Cv0Ch2D.jpg

I also see blue.
 

daedalius

Member
Great impromptu customs tonight guys. Maybe more tomorrow?

I tried to join, but I think you were full.

Played halo 4 instead.

Upload decided to go to shit tonight, so had a bit of jank, worse in UT4 tho. Need to call the damn ISP again... why can't google fiber just be here??
 
It wasn't just some random E-book is was an amazing short story, Which was very well written and an incredible story at that. The character didn't die is some stupid way, and is quite essential to the story. Also the rookie as a character was ans is always been an empty shell even stated so by bungie, So its not like he was a developed character. But even with that you feel for him in what is going on with in the context of the story.

I'm more so just bitter about it.
 

-Ryn

Banned
Happy Bday Monkey!!

What the fuck is this bull 343i

Spoiler regarding a new EU "piece".
You've just gone and killed off the Rookie from ODST? The main character of a series installment and you wrote him off in some damn throwaway E-book? An installment which despite not having any of the main franchise characters still managed to carve out a following and you just killed him off in one of your disappointing EU offerings?

Yes, I am mad.
angry-panda-smash-o.gif


WHAT THE FLYING ASS FLAKES IS 343 DOING WITH THE EU!?? Why are they killing off important or main characters in little side stories most people aren't even going to READ!??????
 

Mix

Member
Happy Bday Monkey!!


angry-panda-smash-o.gif


WHAT THE FLYING ASS FLAKES IS 343 DOING WITH THE EU!?? Why are they killing off important or main characters in little side stories most people aren't even going to READ!??????
Seems to me that, unless there was ever going to be a direct sequel, then he was never going to be brought back up so why not just give his story an ending.
 

jem0208

Member
I never knew a character who's only dialogue was grunting could be considered so important...

Seriously, the Rookie is barely a character. Even less so than the other bloody ODSTs. He's an empty vessel to allow the player to fill his shoes. He is literally only a suit of armour. Kill off an actual character like Halsey or Lasky and then being annoyed makes sense. The Rookie would not have had any effect on the future installments of Halo, his death is meaningless.

Also the main character of ODST is definitely not the Rookie.
 

-Ryn

Banned
EU SPOILER DISCUSSION

Seems to me that, unless there was ever going to be a direct sequel, then he was never going to be brought back up so why not just give his story an ending.
I mean... I get that he didn't really have a character, but I liked him nonetheless (vessel for myself aside lol). Something about silent protagonists make me curious and I want to know more about them. I was hoping if the Rookie did show up again, he would get some proper development. So hearing that he just died, not even in his own game which could've been a kickass sequel, really sucks. I don't see why they had to kill him off. Why is everyone getting killed off?

I never knew a character who's only dialogue was grunting could be considered so important...

Seriously, the Rookie is barely a character. Even less so than the other bloody ODSTs. He's an empty vessel to allow the player to fill his shoes. He is literally only a suit of armour. Kill off an actual character like Halsey or Lasky and then being annoyed makes sense. The Rookie would not have had any effect on the future installments of Halo, his death is meaningless.

Also the main character of ODST is definitely not the Rookie.
His death being meaningless is exactly the problem imo. It brings up the question of why did they do it in the first place?

As for his character (or lack thereof), I think it's a case of character where the space around them creates the shape. Their small reactions and little bits of dialogue sort of made implications about the character. Naturally that allows everybody else to create their own interpretation of the Rookie's character but I think it could've been cool for the Rookie to return in the mainline games as one the more level headed and competent Spartan IV's.
 

jem0208

Member
EU SPOILER DISCUSSION
His death being meaningless is exactly the problem imo. It brings up the question of why did they do it in the first place?

As for his character (or lack thereof), I think it's a case of character where the space around them creates the shape. Their small reactions and little bits of dialogue sort of made implications about the character. Naturally that allows everybody else to create their own interpretation of the Rookie's character but I think it could've been cool for the Rookie to return in the mainline games as one the more level headed and competent Spartan IV's.

By meaningless I meant in the context of the overarching storyline. His death will have no effect on the future story; just as his living would not (had he survived). In the context of a short story based around that troupe of ODSTs, his death can have an impact.

Had he survived, any inclusion in a future installment would have elicited nothing more than a "heh, that's cool". His impact on the story would be no greater than a brand new character. A better suit for any role he could take would be one of the other ODSTs who already have some established character and role, such as Buck.

Another issue with including of the Rookie as a character in a future game would be that you would break that illusion that he was a vessel for the player to fill.


All of that said, I would have liked to see him in a ODST 2. Maybe we can play throught the events leading to the Rookie's death?
 
EDIT DEEPEST LORE SPOILERS

Oh, okay, Rookie died in New Blood. I was worried he was relegated to getting killed off-panel in Escalation or something.

Hey guys,

What colour is this sword? My friends say white but I say its blue!!!
Cv0Ch2D.jpg

I see off white and a muted verdigris masked by the seafoam cyan hues of the magnetic waveform emitter
 
Anyone interested in doing custom matches around 11am eastern time (1 hour after this post)? Mainly hoping to get some objective game types in besides standard slayer. Respond here or pm me.
 

-Ryn

Banned
ODST would've been rad

Thank God none of y'all are writers, those would be some shitty ass books. I'm lookin at you jem.
All I'm asking is that the rookie turns out to be the bestest in the series as the true Space Jesus and saves everyone as Chief looks at him and says "Ya done good kid". Then they make out
helmets on of course
with Cortana watching in the background.
 

Mix

Member
So they are killing Bungi.. everyone offscreen? First the remaining
Spartan II's
and now the
Rookie
?

Also where is Palmer
What?
the only Spartans they killed off were black team. Blue team is still alive.

I wonder when they're gonna stop the escalation series, if they continue for too much longer way too much time is going to have past since Halo 4.
As of Escalations 15, a full year has past since chief landed on Requiem.
 

Booshka

Member
Great advice from the all knowing Twitch chat.

When you pre-order Halo 5 you get a prescription written for Addy. Pick up your Halo 5 and a bottle of Addy, ready to game.
 
People actually care? Completely blank slate character, lol.
I kind of understand, when a main character of any game gets killed of in the EU stuff, you kind of feel cheated, but yeah, it was a complete blank slate anyway, I'd rather play as Buck if they were to do another ODST.
C9 or noble black? What do you guys think? #HCS
Isn't Noble Black the Sudd's team? Lol, my boy Ninja all the way.
 
Top Bottom