GhaleonEB said:
One of my many frustrations with the trilogy was that Guilty Spark's dialogue was never ultimately explained. ("Last time you asked me....")
Like Cortana's babbling all through Halo 3, it was just cryptic crap that never amounted to anything. Very disappointing.
Well it was sort of explained in Halo 3 through the terminals. Guilty Spark thought Chief was a forerunner because of the biological makeup. So for e.g. where he says "Last time you asked me..." a forerunner must have asked him a question. Though the problem with this is that the AI could not tell forerunners apart given that he didn't realize Chief wasn't the same person that probably asked him a question.
The part with the Mjolnir doesn't make sense. It means the forerunners also wore Mjolnir armour. But what're the chances that the humans would end up making the armour as well? Unless they were genetically altered during the indexing process to behave a certain way down history in order to be ready for the flood (I think I recall reading something about that happening at AJ).
What bothers me though is that Guilty Spark was saying things to you that even the casual gamer would question because it happens directly during the game. But the casual gamer never finds out the answers in Halo 3 simply because the casual gamer probably doesn't bother with the terminals.
Edit: If Bungie brought up the whole Guilty Spark part during gameplay, it should have resolved what he was saying during gameplay and not in terminals. It's lazy development.
Cortana's babbling left me very very disappointed. Ends not with a bang, but with a whimper. But it sort of did end with a bang. It really just was pointless babbling. Instead of going up against the a.i that has helped you through out and force you to kill her, making the gamer feel all sorts of moral implication, we simply...pick her up and run? So much potential it hurts.