• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

HANNA |OT| Adapt or Die

Status
Not open for further replies.
yikes, i didnt care for this at all

it was a lot slower than i expected. i was completely uninterested in everything that was going on. when it picks up steam it's just a bunch of boring chase scenes
 
brianjones said:
yikes, i didnt care for this at all

it was a lot slower than i expected. i was completely uninterested in everything that was going on. when it picks up steam it's just a bunch of boring chase scenes
-_-
 
Just got back from it awhile ago. Wrote a review on FB:

This film was the most satisfying non foreign film I've seen in quite a long time. How refreshing it is to see a director who places confidence in his choreography and photography instead of the soporific reliance upon sloppy, choppy, rapid fire editing. Yes Paul Greengrass, I'm looking at you, and your powers of lenticular obfuscation. There is a shot midway through the film where Eric Bana fends off some assailants that reminds me of the hallway sequence of Old Boy sandwiched into the 360 degree panoramic shot that Alfonso Cuaron utilized in Children of Men. Yes, the car shot. You know the one. It was a concise and brief shot, but I nearly let out a cheer when that occurred, because finally, someone out there got it. The action in Hanna is not drawn out and indulgent, it is like the title character - quick, and efficient.

The Chemical Brothers supplied a marvelous soundtrack to supplement the pitch perfect visuals. Daft Punk delivered a good, serviceable soundtrack for Tron; it ebbed and pulsed, and it was even groovy, but it felt a tad safe. Hanna's ditches the commercialism as it twists, modulates, and distorts. There is even some Arab flamenco thrown into the mix. It'll make you hold your breath, and impress you with its eclecticism, though it's not A.R. Rahman, but then again, who is?

The supporting cast executes their roles as you might expect: Blanchett is cold and steely, and Bana is alternatively fatherly and intense. There is a family that Hanna encounters at the beginning of the film. Her newfound friend Sophie is roughly her age, and chatty and rather vacuous. Juxtaposed against Hanna, we wonder if Hanna herself might not have turned out the same way if not for her Bushido-esque upbringing. Which brings us to Saoirse Ronan. She's the clear eyed, girlish type of beauty I wish we'd see more of in films, reminding me perhaps of Evan Rachel Wood. She first caught my eye in Atonement, where she handled her role with emotive finesse. With Hanna, well, let's make that two for two. Ronan's character is adept at neutralizing foes and adapting to hazardous situations. She is a polyglot with an encyclopedic knowledge, but she has difficulty navigating social terrain, coming across as anything but natural in her interactions with others. Is this a stealth critique on the hazards of homeschooling? Perhaps. Ronan tiptoes the line between La Femme Nikita and fragile, feral child adroitly.

These aren't characters we haven't seen before, nor is this an original plot. This isn't "I Saw the Devil", so unhinged and unrestrained that it sears itself into your conscience. It is, however, the best American made thriller I've seen in some time. Do catch it.
 
Slashfilm cast has some extremely good discussion on the themes and structure of Hanna. I think anyone who enjoyed or even didn't enjoy the movie but has an interest in film would really enjoy the very diverse opinions on display here. This is probably one of the best shows I've heard from them in terms of people really getting into it but also acknowledging and appreciating the opinions that the other members have.

I thought especially that Adam's reading of the way camera is used in regards to Marisa vs Hanna is really sharp.

http://slashfilm.com/filmcast/?p=350
 
I went to watch this today with some friends. I had no clue about the film so I really didn't know what to expect but at the end I must admit that I enjoyed it immensely, save for the ending which was a bit abrupt in my opinion.
I wanted to see what happened to the family and the friend of Hanna.
 
polyh3dron said:

I love these type of elaborate and intelligent responses, it really says a lot about your opinion of the film, keep posting bullshit like this for every response in any topic, it's great. Now I really want to go and see this film.
 
I saw this, thought it was definitely enjoyable. Very well shot, some very cool sequences; overall one of the more visually interesting movies I've seen in a while. The end lets it down just slightly I feel, but overall a really solid enjoyable action film.
 
akira28 said:
I wanted to do a take on this someday. :(

With my non-existent production company and my lack of any film experience whatsoever.

I wonder if few years ago, in some pretentious film forums somewhere someone said this exact same thing you did about the Bourne movies, but they also added that the "twist" would be a young teenage girl, instead of a "Jason Bourne"

I guess finally that filmmaker had enough budget to do his take on the Bourne movies and thus this lackluster action flick was made.

Do yourself a favor and don't bother wasting your time on a take of a movie that is a take of every other chase, action cliche' films out there.
 
Really enjoyed the film. I appreciated that it never got too over the top. No ridiculous Matrix-esque sequences with Ronan fighting 20 dudes or anything. Overall, I loved it. My wife only liked it.
 
Damn, what a bummer - both of the first two big films I was anticipating this year were fairly decent sized letdowns. First Source Code, and now Hanna. Now, the latter wasn't a letdown to anywheres the degree that the former was, because I actually did like Hanna. It was good, but it wasn't great. Saoirse Ronan was fantastic in it, as she has been in everything I've seen her in so far. She is going to be a big star for many years. She really anchored the movie, but unfortunately there wasn't much around her and the movie never amounted to more than the sum of its scattershot parts. There were a few nice shots and a couple of nice sequences, but none of the characters had much meat to them and the plot was kind of non-sensical.

Atonement, this is not.
 
icarus-daedelus said:
I sincerely hope that Saoirse (I hope I've spelled that right, lol) has a bright future ahead of her and doesn't tank like your average child/teen star, because she's positively mesmerizing even in shit films (hello, Lovely Bones...) and has a uniquely ethereal quality to her appearance that carries into her performances.

This is an excellent way of describing her. Really captivating to watch.
 
Just got back from this. Found it very satisfying and genuinely thrilling. It carried on that juicy core of what I liked about Run Lola Run and the Bournes: running around European/North African locales with an intense protagonist and frenetic action and great music. Saoirse was intense and the soundtrack was extremely effective. Sure, you can pick apart its originality (Daughter of Bourne is what it is), but everything about the execution just worked.

Oh, and I loved that lipstick-wearing ponce of a mid-boss and his skinhead hench-boys right out of 1988 West Germany.
 
petethepanda said:
It was awesome, but it unfortunately ran out of steam late in the game. The movie had some freaking badass sequences in it, so it's too bad they didn't save one for the end. Thought it could have used some more of one main thread at the end as well.
Considering the amount of time spent on Hanna getting to know that family and the outside world - some of my favorite parts of the movie - it's strange that they didn't pay off any of that at the end. They didn't even resolve her feelings about her "father." She gained information but we never saw her actually react to any of it.
I'm fine with everything that ultimately happened, but it felt like it ended a scene or two early.

I was loving it, it's always a bummer when something you're incredibly into kind of fizzles out a bit at the end. Still great, though, definitely worth seeing.

Agreed. A very good film. However, I was also disappointed at how
little resolution there was between her and Erik. They were probably going for a minimalistic approach, but, yeah, it didn't work for me. Still, when you see that Eric Bana is starring you should be prepared to watch his character get fucked over and all.
 
Saw this earlier tonight with some friends, I thought that it started off really strong and interesting but started to fizzle out near the end. The soundtrack was what really caught a lot of my attention, though. Any recommendations on where to start off for the Chemical Brothers?
 
Saw it earlier tonight.

Probably my favorite film of the year so far.

Beautiful Locations, Beautifully shot, Awesome action, Great story.

The Chemical Brothers soundtrack topped it all off, I think it hit every note.

Highly recommend it.
 
Juanadams said:
Saw it earlier tonight.

Probably my favorite film of the year so far.

Beautiful Locations, Beautifully shot, Awesome action, Great story.

The Chemical Brothers soundtrack topped it all off, I think it hit every note.

Highly recommend it.
Yeah. I haven't seen much this year (not even the top Oscar movies from last year) and I really dug this.

The locations and music absolutely blew me away. Ronan was great. Thought Blanchett's twang was a bit off though.
 
Saw this last week what a great film. I hadn't watched any trailers beforehand so my expectations were kept in check from reading the thread it seems some people expected a action movie.

The pace was lovely and the characters were great.
 
brianjones said:
yikes, i didnt care for this at all

it was a lot slower than i expected. i was completely uninterested in everything that was going on. when it picks up steam it's just a bunch of boring chase scenes
pretty much.

edit: i already posted :S
 
MikeTyson said:
This and "Source Code".
I just saw my first Hanna trailer and it looks pretty good. I loved Source Code so I'm curious if you (or anybody else) could help me decide whether to see this or not.
 
i didn't like it much. it was slow, but mainly just dumb cliched stuff rather than actually being dramatic, interspersed very occasionally with some people punching each other a lot in a way that makes very loud thudding noises. plus one of the fight scenes at the end i literally laughed out loud at because it was so hammy and over the top.
 
It was probably the most atonal movie i have seen for a long time, which i found interesting. I liked Hanna, and the Bana character. Blanchett's character reminds me of Tilda Swinton in Michael Clayton, who I prefer and was more developed as a character.

It is very strange how it starts off serious, become ridiculous and somewhat funny; try to be Bourne in places, then a fairy tale in others. The weakest elements for me are the fights, they are well shot, but the choreography felt lacking. As CIA agents, they feel incompetent, they fight light thugs with wild swings at nothing.

The feeling I got from the film is the director coming onto the set everyday and say, 'You know what would be interesting...' and then shoot whatever idea comes into his head. That isn't really a bad thing, mind you, but it does feel undercooked in parts.
 
Just finished watching it and thoroughly enjoyed the film, if only because of Ronan. Best young actress working today, bar none.

Oh, and the soundtrack. Damn, that soundtrack. First film OST I'll be purchasing since... forever.
 
I didn't epect there to be so much hate for this movie!

I thought it was excellent, the soundtrack was BRILLIANT! Some of the acting was a bit overdone, but other than that I really enjoyed it.

Would watch again!
 
Fucking awesome. Best action movie I've seen in a while and I love that despite following a young girl, its a globe-trotting film. I especially loved how unforgiving the film was in its action, yet how heart-warming it was in terms of certain character interactions. Major Leon vibes throughout.

Excellent soundtrack by the Chemical Bros. Saiorse Ronin is my favourite young actress and has been since Atonement and Lovely Bones.

Blanchett was great and I loved seeing Bana as in a good movie again, not to mention as a fucking badass.

Joe Wright did an excellent job and some sequences are really goddamn impressive in terms of how much he's able to hide from the viewer and how he moves through the space. The cleverly frenetic editing really added to it.

After a weak start to the year, the movies seem to be amping up big time now.
 
In fact, I'm just going to say right now that it's my favourite Wright film.

It doesn't come near the highs of Atonement's first half, but it shits all over Atonement's second half and due to the consistency with which I enjoyed the film, I have to give it the edge.
 
Scullibundo said:
Excellent soundtrack by the Chemical Bros. Saiorse Ronin is my favourite young actress and has been since Atonement and Lovely Bones.

internethighfive.jpg

Joe Wright did an excellent job and some sequences are really goddamn impressive in terms of how much he's able to hide from the viewer and how he moves through the space. The cleverly frenetic editing really added to it.

Although Wright seems to have retreated to familiar territory (IMDb is wrong about Ronan being attached), I'd most definitely like to see him tackle the action/thriller genres again.
 
Tim the Wiz said:
Agreed. A very good film. However, I was also disappointed at how
little resolution there was between her and Erik. They were probably going for a minimalistic approach, but, yeah, it didn't work for me. Still, when you see that Eric Bana is starring you should be prepared to watch his character get fucked over and all.

Just finally got around to seeing it, and I really don't mind the way it turned out.

I like that not everything is wrapped up neatly with a bow at the end, just that little pause she does when she hears the shot is all you need to know about how she feels about Erik. It's nice and subtle, and really all she would have realistically had time for given the situation. Part of me thought the viciousness of their fight was a bit off(like they really wanted to murder each other), but then I realized that that had been established as normal interaction for them in the first act of the movie. Only part of the movie I thought was off was the google montage, which was clearly not needed, as both she and the audience already had all the information they needed to suspect that she was the result of genetic experimentation, and the very next scene confirms it. Not to mention it makes her electricity induced freakout in morocco seem strange and out of place. I understand why they did it, they had to make sure even the slowest audience members are keeping up, but I'm just disappointed that they had to pander to the lowest common denominator like that. I don't think it was really needed.

I have no complaints about the ending though, sometimes things like that just happen, you get in a fight with someone you care about and you never get the chance to make amends. Harsh, but kind of fresh for an action movie like this.
 
I just watched this and holy shitballs that was one of the greatest movies I've seen in a while. Dat sound design, makes me wish I saw it in theaters. It all felt so delightfully retro.

I don't get how anyone can say a single negative thing about this film.
 
Qwomo said:
I just watched this and holy shitballs that was one of the greatest movies I've seen in a while. Dat sound design, makes me wish I saw it in theaters. It all felt so delightfully retro.

I don't get how anyone can say a single negative thing about this film.

Is it already out on blu?
 
Only 3 pages? For shame GAF. Saw it today, loved it. That girl is a really good actress as it turns out and Eric Bana was a badass.

Also, Cate Blanchett was scary.
 
saw this on vudu the other night. technically amazing, really fantastic shots and great use of sound, but the story is so boring/predictable.
 
Neuromancer said:
Only 3 pages? For shame GAF. Saw it today, loved it. That girl is a really good actress as it turns out and Eric Bana was a badass.

Also, Cate Blanchett was scary.
I think I posted my thoughts somewhere else here (maybe the Sucker Punch thread of all places), but I can definitely see this movie gaining a cult following over the years until everyone looks back and pretends they appreciated it when it came out, like Leon.

I couldn't put my finger on it but this movie hit all the right buttons with me. Even though it had major issues I was able to look past them as there was just something that resonated with me. I've always been a Bana fan, so maybe that was it. But truly, I have the feeling it's a combination of the cinematography adding to the exotic feel of the movie combined with the awesome soundtrack. Mostly the latter. Seriously this soundtrack is Tron levels of show-stealing. "Devil is in the Details" just stays with you.

I think put this out there wherever I first posted my thoughts on the movie, but
when Bana takes shots at Blanchett's character in her room, doesn't that kind of make the entire movie pointless? He trains Hanna her entire life with some elaborate plan to kill her, but it was as easy as knocking on her door? She seemed pretty easy to get to. Or was the mission Hanna was on all a smoke screen to flush her out? Doesn't seem very likely considering everything that happened after she pressed the button. He seemed as though he legitimately had the intention of meeting her in Germany until Blanchett's agents caught up with him.
 
dralla said:
I think once the original plan went to hell it was basically kill her by any means necessary.
But it was still mad easy to do it. Why wasn't that plan A is what I'm saying? Let's see elaborate scheme involving girl I raised as my daughter or lay low for a number of years, track this evil chick down and do the job myself. Which one sounds the most feasible to you?

That was just one of the problems I had with the movie. There were a couple of other parts that made it hard to suspend belief*, but, like I said, I like the movie all the same.

*
Hanna escaping the camera-less super-secret CIA/military facility. Well not camera-less... but may as well have been. I had more issues, but they escape me right now.
 
Dali said:
But it was still mad easy to do it. Why wasn't that plan A is what I'm saying? Let's see elaborate scheme involving girl I raised as my daughter or lay low for a number of years, track this evil chick down and do the job myself. Which one sounds the most feasible to you

That was just one of the problems I had with the movie. There were a couple of other parts that made it hard to suspend belief*, but like I said, I like the movie all the same.

*
Hanna escaping the camera-less super-secret CIA/military facility. Well not camera-less... but may as well have been. I had more issues, but they escape me right now.
I was under the impression Bana's character was fine living in the woods with the girl. It was her choice to go out into the world when she wanted to with the caveat that she would have to take care of this woman, otherwise she'd be hunted for the rest of her life. That just happened to be the plan they came up, could have been anything really.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom