Well think about what happened on D1. Rats midway through D1 posts to say that he wishes to be lynched because (I'm paraphrasing) that he did not wish to possibly hurt anyone on Town. He never really explained why beyond that and he never said he was actually a Death Eater, yet almost immediately, people began to lynch Rats off and eventually, would be enough to lynch him.
And as a result of that, he was telling the truth that his role did involve a way that he could kill off a towns person, but he wasn't a Death Eater either. In fact, he was against them.
I guess what I'm saying is, we shouldn't rush to lynch someone or anybody no matter what role they claim to be. While yes I understood completely that SOMEONE had to be voted on Day1 to get lynched because we need as much information and as early as possible, but to lynch someone that we think is NOT a Death Eator, is in my opinion, not a great idea.