Support NeoGAF

[Deleted member 231381]

Actually, thinking about it, switchers are on Blarg tonight and we don't seem to have a doctor, so I die tonight anyway, so me keeping Umbridge secret is kind of pointless.

Umbridge is Gorlak.

 

[Miracle]

Well...I guess I could be wrong. It's good that you claimed Crab. I don't think I would have been pushed otherwise. But I'm still very suspicious however.

VOTE: Hyperactivity

Way to draw out some Deatheaters!

...really man?

Unvote

Vote: TheWorthyEdge

 

[Flame_AC]

Worthy is 2 away from having the majority by the way.

 

[Retroid]

I'm on mobile just chiming in to say I'm sticking with TWE.

 

[TheWorthyEdge]

You guys...poor Blarg.

 

[Sawneeks]

I was thinking it may have had something to do with switchy mc switchy action.

Day 3: Revenge of the Switch.

No. My role says the presence of dark magic sets it off. I think I am the bad investigator that Burbeting's role hints at it, in that I return some false guilties. It would make sense with Filch in the books.

Hmmm. I'm going off of sheer trust but

Vote: Hyperactivity

Crab and LoC are telling the truth. If I'm right about what happened Night 1 then Hyper is Scum.

 

[Flame_AC]

We need to lynch Gorlak tomorrow then assuming Crab is telling the truth.

Worthy is 1 away now.

 

[Kawl_USC]

Day 3: Revenge of the Switch.



Hmmm. I'm going off of sheer trust but

Vote: Hyperactivity

Crab and LoC are telling the truth. If I'm right about what happened Night 1 then Hyper is Scum.

Care to expand on your thoughts as a dead person walking in about 20 minutes?

 

[MagnumBoy20xx]

Just great! I wake up late to find us in one of THESE situations. I don't feel comfortable in voting for the worthy edge, and because of what crab just said, I don't want to vote him or LoC either so I guess I'll just keep my vote on retroid. speaking of crab:

For what it's worth, I think from the description of my role that it can be triggered by the presence of Horcruxes and maybe other things; Salva said my role wasn't as simple as inno/guilty but won't clarify. I assume that means I can get false guilties (e.g., I'd have got one N1 on Blargonaut if I'd visited him). However, I don't know because I haven't tested it on anyone who has owned up to having a Horcrux.

If we keep TWE alive, then you could test it on him, right?

 

[Kalor]

Actually, thinking about it, switchers are on Blarg tonight and we don't seem to have a doctor, so I die tonight anyway, so me keeping Umbridge secret is kind of pointless.

Umbridge is Gorlak.

I think Blarg said he had a one time heal so we sort of have one.

 

[Deleted member 231381]

As soon as I'm dead, lynch Gorlak, yes.

 

[Deleted member 231381]

oh total shitballs I forgot Blarg's doc role

ugh, sorry I played that really badly. :/

 

[Flame_AC]

Just great! I wake up late to find us in one of THESE situations. I don't feel comfortable in voting for the worthy edge, and because of what crab just said, I don't want to vote him or LoC either so I guess I'll just keep my vote on retroid. speaking of crab:

Switch to Hyperactivity then/

Vote: Hyperactivity

 

[Sawneeks]

Care to expand on your thoughts as a dead person walking in about 20 minutes?

I can give someone an item however I don't know if they receive it or not. I only know that Hogwarts-aligned players can use it/receive it at all and I don't think he got it.

 

[Sawneeks]

*I don't think he got it given the reactions to some things, aka the Horcruxes.

 

[TheWorthyEdge]

VOTE HYPER!

FOR BLARG! or.

FOR DUMBLEDORE!

 

[MagnumBoy20xx]

*I don't think he got it given the reactions to some things, aka the Horcruxes.

who did you try to give it to?

 

[Flame_AC]

Blarg is gonna be so excited when he checks back into the game and sees what has happened in the last two hours.

 

[Sawneeks]

Switch to Hyperactivity then/

Vote: Hyperactivity

Why did you switch to Hyper?

who did you try to give it to?

Hyperactivity. Night 1.

 

[SalvaPot]

Day 3 votes


matt attack (0)
lord of castamere 1580 (2137)

crab (2)
rynam 1618
thegoddamn 1643 (1748)
sawneeks 1833 (1846)
theexodu5 1985 (2212)
blargonaut 2174 (2275)
theworthyedge 2197 (2224)
hyperactivity 2327

thegoddamn (0)
flame_ac 1701 (1963)
lone_prodigy 1712 (1872)
crab 1719 (1726)

blargonaut (0)
crab 1738 (1919)
hyperactivity 1743 (1910)
christina mackenzie 1757 (2243)

gorlak (0)
miracle 1774 (1788)
crab 1948 (2272)

nin1000 (0)
theexodu5 1917 (1917)

salvapot (0)
theexodu5 1917 (1942)
crab 1919 (1948)

ninpot (0)
hyperactivity 1922 (1944)

kawl_usc (0)
kalor 1951 (2223)
flame_ac 1963 (2204)

theworthyedge (9)
roytheone 1987 (2086)
enker 1992 (2005)
hyperactivity 2025 (2025)
hyperactivity 2030 (2318)
lord of castamere 2137
retroid 2169
bananaspaceprincess 2186
flatearthpandas 2207
kalor 2223 (2296)
christina mackenzie 2243
crab 2272
lone_prodigy 2301
flame_ac 2322 (2363)
sawneeks 2336 (2356)
kawl_usc 2344
miracle 2352

retroid (3)
kawl_usc 2081 (2299)
magnumboy20xx 2110
enker 2166
roytheone 2187
flame_ac 2204 (2322)

lord of castamere (6)
sawneeks 2082 (2336)
gorlak 2089
miracle 2103 (2352)
theexodu5 2212
thegoddamn 2217
matt attack 2226
blargonaut 2275
kalor 2296
kawl_usc 2299 (2344)
theworthyedge 2315 (2340)
hyperactivity 2318 (2327)

lordofcastamere (0)
theworthyedge 2224 (2315)

hyperactivity (3)
theworthyedge 2340
sawneeks 2356
flame_ac 2363

 

[Sawneeks]

Well if anything you guys now have stuff to go back and read, lol.

 

[Kawl_USC]

I can give someone an item however I don't know if they receive it or not. I only know that Hogwarts-aligned players can use it/receive it at all and I don't think he got it.

And then that's it? You saying you don't know if they receive it at all hints at it being gone from your possession no matter the state of the other person?

 

[MagnumBoy20xx]

Why did you switch to Hyper?



Hyperactivity. Night 1.

Just a quick question: If you try to give it to a scum player, would you retain the item?

 

[Flame_AC]

Why did you switch to Hyper?

We can keep TWE and Crab and LoC alive since we all seem kind of sure they are town or neutral about to die. So we can go for someone who made a very telling move. I'm throwing my vote on it in the hopes of convincing others that theres enough support to lynch him.

 

[Miracle]

oh total shitballs I forgot Blarg's doc role

ugh, sorry I played that really badly. :/

...jeez man really?

 

[Sawneeks]

And then that's it? You saying you don't know if they receive it at all hints at it being gone from your possession no matter the state of the other person?

I just get a confirmation that my action was received. Whether they get it or not I have no idea but given Hyper's reactions and responses I'm assuming he never got it.

Just a quick question: If you try to give it to a scum player, would you retain the item?

Yes.

 

[Kawl_USC]

We can keep TWE and Crab and LoC alive since we all seem kind of sure they are town or neutral about to die. So we can go for someone who made a very telling move. I'm throwing my vote on it in the hopes of convincing others that theres enough support to lynch him.

An hour earlier and I might agree. I think it's too late in the day to be trying to swing that big of a vote stack away from TWE.

 

[Flame_AC]

An hour earlier and I might agree. I think it's too late in the day to be trying to swing that big of a vote stack away from TWE.

Until someone breaks out the real Override.

 

[Deleted member 231381]

An hour earlier and I might agree. I think it's too late in the day to be trying to swing that big of a vote stack away from TWE.

yeah, I really fucked that up. I was trying to conceal my role because it's a fairly powerful one but I left it way too long before claiming.

 

[Kawl_USC]

I just get a confirmation that my action was received. Whether they get it or not I have no idea but given Hyper's reactions and responses I'm assuming he never got it.



Yes.

I don't get how these two answers match up. You don't know if they get it, but if they don't you retain it? So if you retain it then you would know they didn't get it, right?

 

[MagnumBoy20xx]

I just get a confirmation that my action was received. Whether they get it or not I have no idea but given Hyper's reactions and responses I'm assuming he never got it.



Yes.

if Hyper never received it, and you don't have it, then where did it go?

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

UNVOTE

VOTE: Hyperactivity

 

[TheWorthyEdge]

CMONNNN! PEOPLE!

 

[Miracle]

8 minutes left, and if I switched my vote as well, that would make it 7-5 TWE over Hyper.

 

[Kawl_USC]

We can keep TWE and Crab and LoC alive since we all seem kind of sure they are town or neutral about to die. So we can go for someone who made a very telling move. I'm throwing my vote on it in the hopes of convincing others that theres enough support to lynch him.

But for what it's worth I would have preferred to lynch Hyper (or Retroid or anyone we suspected of being scum) over TWE. I'm not super thrilled with Crab right now.

 

[Sawneeks]

I don't get how these two answers match up. You don't know if they get it, but if they don't you retain it? So if you retain it then you would know they didn't get it, right?

I can't use the item myself, I just give it to people.

if Hyper never received it, and you don't have it, then where did it go?

I keep it? If I try to give it to a non-Hogwarts aligned player then I keep it, however I don't know if that happens or not.

 

[Flame_AC]

8 minutes left, and if I switched my vote as well, that would make it 7-5 TWE over Hyper.

No reason not to do it.

 

[Kalor]

I could switch my vote if we want to try lynching Hyper.

 

[Kawl_USC]

8 minutes left, and if I switched my vote as well, that would make it 7-5 TWE over Hyper.

I think we start getting into a dangerous area where we could tie the vote or end up lynching LoC who still has 6 votes by my count.

 

[TheGoddamn]

A shambles of a day, but fun reads!

Vote: Hyperactivity

 

[Miracle]

No reason not to do it.

There is. If I switch now and so does another person, that means it would then be a tie at 6-6 and then nobody gets lynched. Which is the worst outcome.

 

[Flame_AC]

Everyone should start voting Hyper if that's what we're going to do. Have to make sure we don't end up with a tie.

 

[MagnumBoy20xx]

I can't use the item myself, I just give it to people.



I keep it? If I try to give it to a non-Hogwarts aligned player then I keep it, however I don't know if that happens or not.

try to give it to someone tonight before you die. if they receive it, then we might just have found scum!

 

[Kawl_USC]

I can't use the item myself, I just give it to people.



I keep it? If I try to give it to a non-Hogwarts aligned player then I keep it, however I don't know if that happens or not.

Do you have multiples of this item to give out? Or could you be trying to give out an item you no longer have if you already gave it to a hog warts aligned role?

 

[Kalor]

Vote: Hyperactivity

Miracle can make it 7-5

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

Not thrilled with how this final hour has played out with two more town PRs being revealed. I'm not sure why you chose to reveal over LoCs lynching Crab, but I'll trust you for now.

Says the guy voting for LoC in the first place. What did you think was going to happen?

 

[Flame_AC]

If Kalor and Kawl switch votes, then Hyper gets lynched I believe thanks TheGoddamn's vote.

 

[Kawl_USC]

Vote:hyperactivity

fuck it. When have last minute shenanigans ever gone wrong in Mafia. /s

 

[TheWorthyEdge]

FOR BLARRRRRRRRRRG!

 

[Lone_Prodigy]

Vote Hyper now. We have a couple minutes to switch back.

Sawneeks should fully claim now but it's likely too late.