• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Harry Potter [Mafia] |OT| “Yer a werewolf, ‘Arry”

H

Hyperactivity

Banned
TheWorthyEdge said:
I don't know guys!

I feel like when I first proposed to lynch me I was like "Oh boy they're gonna destroy a Horcrux and get a thief out! WOOH!" but then I thought about it and I'm already gonna die so depending on what I do with the Horcrux, give it back to Blarg or keep it until I die, it won't really matter.

It's in towns best interest to just let me die with the poison and try and go out for more Deatheaters. So what if I'm in the game I'm dead essentially, and in the meantime I can only SELL tonight, and potentially have the ability to STEAL and with my death destroy another Horcrux. The only reason why some of you are voting me is because you don't believe me. Well believe me on this: you are going to be really underwhelmed when you see exactly what I told you.

To all the townies. PAY ATTENTION TO WHO VOTED ME.
Click to expand...

AKA, I want to screw with people, so pls don't lynch anymore
 
T

TheWorthyEdge

Member
Hyperactivity said:
And when did this supposed conversation suddenly come up int he first hours?

Am I supposed to believe every single character inn the game has an item?
Click to expand...

No, and it's evident that not everyone does have one because it said LoC didn't have one but I don't know if maybe that's one of his role abilities or not.

flatearthpandas said:
You meant to say this is from an info PM?
Wasn't the fact that you supposedly are unable to destroy horcruxes but that they'll be destroyed if you're lynched with them from a PM? Why coy now?
Click to expand...

Yes. None of this was in my Role PM, all of it came from questions I asked.
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
Also, for clarification you didn't receive a message from NinPot saying that you had been role blocked on N1. That only came to light through further clarification?

When were you banned? That might be further muddying the waters concerning any PMs that TWE got concerning actions he did and had done on him.
 
T

TheWorthyEdge

Member
ah fuck it, just lynch me. I was just trying to help but to late now. I'm gonna die no matter what and some of you wont listen to what I just said.

You'll get a destroyed Horcrux so I guess that's good....?
 
H

Hyperactivity

Banned
TheWorthyEdge said:
No, and it's evident that not everyone does have one because it said LoC didn't have one but I don't know if maybe that's one of his role abilities or not.



Yes. None of this was in my Role PM, all of it came from questions I asked.
Click to expand...

Gorlak already asked about this, and Retroid can verify

What's the flavor for possibly being RB'ed
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
TheWorthyEdge said:
No, and it's evident that not everyone does have one because it said LoC didn't have one but I don't know if maybe that's one of his role abilities or not.



Yes. None of this was in my Role PM, all of it came from questions I asked.
Click to expand...

So is it clear from N1 that LoC does not have an item or do you think that he role blocked you? You seem to be drawing a lot of conclusions from how your actions played out N1, some of which seem to be contradictory.
 
T

TheWorthyEdge

Member
Kawl_USC said:
Also, for clarification you didn't receive a message from NinPot saying that you had been role blocked on N1. That only came to light through further clarification?

When were you banned? That might be further muddying the waters concerning any PMs that TWE got concerning actions he did and had done on him.
Click to expand...

nope, no PM.

I was banned before the game started but communicated through another forum to the mods.
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
Okay.

Regarding TheWorthyEdge:

Simply put, I don't want to lynch him because I want him to serve as a decoy for me.

As long as he is carrying my Horcrux with him, he is a liability for everyone, BUT MORESO for the Death Eaters. As long as he is alive with it, he potentially exists as a waste of 1 scum's Night action.

If they have a Thief of their own, he or she's gonna have to target TWE to get that Horcrux from him; AND, if this game's truly about choices and we have multiple Roles with multiple powers, that scum Thief would have decided to Steal from a Neutral instead of doing something more potentially nasty and/or lethal. For example, lore withstanding of course: what if the apparent scum-aligned Poisoner was actually a scum-aligned multi-class Poisoner/Thief? Then that'd be 1 Night wasted Stealing instead of Poisoning.

TWE said he was Poisoned last Night, and he should be dead by N4 if he is telling the truth. He's gonna die anyway, so let's not waste today's lynch getting rid of him. And if he hasn't succumbed to Poison by N4, we can choose to be rid of the filthy sneak then.

TWE, if you survive today's mob and if you really wanna be "Town", you gotta choose to hold on to that Horcrux for me. Don't Sell it (unless it's somehow back to me). Don't further your own Win condition with it. Keep it. Help me.

Everyone, I honestly believe TheWorthyEdge's survival can help me help Hogwarts. UNVOTE him, please.

Friends close, enemies closer, etc.
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
TheWorthyEdge said:
I don't understand this question. You mean how could roleblock be put into a game of HP Mafia?
Click to expand...

Several people who have been switched have mentioned having a prank played on them, the ?? Posters have mentioned stupefy, etc. typically when an action has been done on someone in this game they have received a flavorful message detailing it. If you have not received one, I find it doubtful that you were role blocked.
 
H

Hyperactivity

Banned
again , I doubt we have a scum thief for the simple reason that out thief is a NEUTRAL

AKA NOT ALIGNED TO EITHER SIDE

As it stands, TWE is an asset to scum. the only neutrals that aren't are sks, which are aligned against scum
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
Also, may I remind you all again that TheWorthyEdge is the only one who's claimed that a Horcrux gets destroyed when its holder dies.

I myself do NOT confirm that this will happen, because there is no info in my Role PM regarding what happens to a Horcrux when its holder dies.

My Role PM only states what happens when I myself actively Destroy it with a power. It doesn't mention what happens to the Horcrux were I to die with it still in my possession.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Blargonaut said:
Also, may I remind you all again that TheWorthyEdge is the only one who's claimed that a Horcrux gets destroyed when its holder dies.

I myself do NOT confirm that this will happen, because there is no info in my Role PM regarding what happens to a Horcrux when its holder dies.

My Role PM only states what happens when I myself actively Destroy it with a power. It doesn't mention what happens to the Horcrux were I to die with it still in my possession.
Click to expand...

This is one of the reasons why I don't trust TheWorthyEdge, though. It's too much of a wildcard to leave a Horcrux out there in the open when we don't know what they do for mafia. I don't care about him being a neutral, particularly one that has so little impact on town, but item-wise he definitely concerns me. Regarding Retroid, LoC; I think they're both town, and both vanilla town at that. I get bored and therefore not paying attention rather than scum trying to lurk. I'm still undecided about my vote but I'll probably shift it to TheWorthyEdge if I don't get a more convincing argument to do otherwise.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Hyperactivity said:
again , I doubt we have a scum thief for the simple reason that out thief is a NEUTRAL

AKA NOT ALIGNED TO EITHER SIDE

As it stands, TWE is an asset to scum. the only neutrals that aren't are sks, which are aligned against scum
Click to expand...

He's not really an asset to scum. If they have Horcruxes, he can steal them and pass them on to us, for example. Additionally, a neutral killed is a mafia not killed. The only problem is that he represents a massive wildcard for town and it depends how risk-averse we're willing to be.
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
Hyperactivity said:
again , I doubt we have a scum thief for the simple reason that out thief is a NEUTRAL

AKA NOT ALIGNED TO EITHER SIDE

As it stands, TWE is an asset to scum. the only neutrals that aren't are sks, which are aligned against scum
Click to expand...

How exactly do you see a Neutral Thief as an asset to scum? I don't see it.

Because he can steal items that you don't believe in?

Pushing to lynch the Neutral claimant is an easy, easy public display, you.
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
Crab said:
This is one of the reasons why I don't trust TheWorthyEdge, though. It's too much of a wildcard to leave a Horcrux out there in the open when we don't know what they do for mafia. I don't care about him being a neutral, particularly one that has so little impact on town, but item-wise he definitely concerns me. Regarding Retroid, LoC; I think they're both town, and both vanilla town at that. I get bored and therefore not paying attention rather than scum trying to lurk. I'm still undecided about my vote but I'll probably shift it to TheWorthyEdge if I don't get a more convincing argument to do otherwise.
Click to expand...

I think you and Hyperactivity are Death Eaters
 
K

Kalor

Member
I'm going back and forth between LoC or TWE. If I end up changing my vote, at the latest it will be before the last 7 minutes.
 
T

TheWorthyEdge

Member
Blargonaut said:
Also, may I remind you all again that TheWorthyEdge is the only one who's claimed that a Horcrux gets destroyed when its holder dies.

I myself do NOT confirm that this will happen, because there is no info in my Role PM regarding what happens to a Horcrux when its holder dies.

My Role PM only states what happens when I myself actively Destroy it with a power. It doesn't mention what happens to the Horcrux were I to die with it still in my possession.
Click to expand...

Salva said so.
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Just as a note, it's 7-7-5 right now for TWE-LoC-Retroid, which implies there's a fair few people not voting in the contenders. That's pretty much unacceptable.

EDIT: ...whoops, I'm one of them. Er-hem. *coughs furiously*

VOTE: TheWorthyEdge
 
B

Blargonaut

Banned
btw, TWE, if your Role claim is actually some gigantic manufactured fake

If you simply combined the various statements of others; my statement of having my Horcrux robbed, the Mundungus Fletcher, notorious Thief lore that I remember someone previously mentioned before you, dealing with the Switcher fiasco by saying your Steal ability is unaffected by swapping, Sawneeks' Poisoned stat-effect shortening your duration and a claim of being Role-blocked during N1 all for a bit of pity effect

Because don't think I haven't noticed that your Role-claim appears to be a Frankenstein monster of fragments of the past

If you're lying to me

Because I'm buying what you're selling right now

If you

are


lying to me

TWE
 
T

TheWorthyEdge

Member
Blargonaut said:
btw, TWE, if your Role claim is actually some gigantic manufactured fake

If you simply combined the various statements of others; my statement of having my Horcrux robbed, the Mundungus Fletcher, notorious Thief lore that I remember someone previously mentioned before you, dealing with the Switcher fiasco by saying your Steal ability is unaffected by swapping, Sawneeks' Poisoned stat-effect shortening your duration and a claim of being Role-blocked during N1 all for a bit of pity effect

Because don't think I haven't noticed that your Role-claim appears to be a Frankenstein monster of fragments of the past

If you're lying to me

Because I'm buying what you're selling right now

If you

are


lying to me

TWE
Click to expand...

Well chances are I'm gonna die soon anyway so I mean, you'll see soon!
 
N

nin1000

Banned
FYI I am mobile now, will end the day on time!
Flavour will follow soo after. So bare with Me.
🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
 
M

Miracle

Member
Well...we got one more hour to go.

I'm keeping an eye on some of the people voting for TWE. Yes I'm that paranoid.

TWE to me seems like the biggest waste of a vote you could make right now. Even him being untrustworthy, the votes on him seem...forced. We will get very little information out of lynching him.
 
R

Rynam

Member
Blargonaut said:
  • Rynam claims here and here to be a Watcher (Mad-Eye Moody), alignment unconfirmed (states Ministry of Magic/3rd-party of unknown motives); claims that he watched Swamped on Night 1 and saw Crab visit her, then, claims to have watched me last Night, and says he saw TheGoddamn visit me.
  • The apparent presence of Dolores Umbridge and Rynam's claim to be Mad-Eye Moody raises some questions; is there an independent 'Ministry of Magic' party here, with motives of their own? Rynam "Mad-Eye" himself seems to verify this, here and here. If not, are these individuals simply part of the Hogwarts defense? Although, considering our establishment's history with Umbridge, she is likely Neutral and seeking her own form of revenge, with her very own Win condition: to mark/Punish a certain number of students? And, perhaps, Moody may be part of an independent 'Order of the Phoenix' faction with secret motives for the greater good; but, I myself was not informed or was stated to be part of such a group in my Role PM, and so I find this last theory of mine the least likely of all.
Click to expand...

Just to make something clear about the MoM part. My Role PM says I'm alignet with Hogwarts, but if Inspected it shows "Ministry of Magic"(Auror stuff bla). I win when all Death Eaters are dead. So yes I'm on the good side, but no I'm not in a "3rd Faction"/Group like the 'Order of the Phoenix'.

I don't know about this "Umbridge" but if you follow the Flavor, Umbridge should be aligned with Death Eaters but shows "MoM" on inspect.
 
L

Lord of Castamere

Member
Ridiculous that I'm being voted for over nothing more than air filled speculation while a Netural sits on the chopping block. Vote twe today so nothing bad happens tonight and return to me tomorrow.
 
M

Miracle

Member
Lord of Castamere said:
Ridiculous that I'm being voted for over nothing more than air filled speculation while a Netural sits on the chopping block. Vote twe today so nothing bad happens tonight and return to me tomorrow.
Click to expand...

...Yeah I'm definitely keeping my vote on you. :p

Guys seriously unvote TWE now. There is very little to be gained by wasting a lynch on him right now.
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
Unless a tied vote doesn't lynch both parties.

Or if Gafia is generally against tying the lynch vote (not sure this communities feelings on it as a tactic).
 
T

TheWorthyEdge

Member
Lord of Castamere said:
Ridiculous that I'm being voted for over nothing more than air filled speculation while a Netural sits on the chopping block. Vote twe today so nothing bad happens tonight and return to me tomorrow.
Click to expand...

ridiculous2.gif
 
K

Kalor

Member
Lord of Castamere said:
Ridiculous that I'm being voted for over nothing more than air filled speculation while a Netural sits on the chopping block. Vote twe today so nothing bad happens tonight and return to me tomorrow.
Click to expand...

Something about this reads as off to me, trying to push the vote onto the neutral as something bad could happen. Despite the fact that he is more than likely a thief as why would he make a fake claim today if he was mafia? The poisoner is more than likely Death Eater aligned so why would he claim poisoned? I'm going to trust TWE to do the right thing tonight.

Vote: Lord of Castamere
 
D

Deleted member 231381

Unconfirmed Member
Kawl_USC said:
Is there any consideration to leaving the vote tied? Two birds at once and all that?
Click to expand...

Votes tied means nobody is lynched, it has to be avoided. I don't want to see anyone switch votes to tie break because they can backwards justify themselves later. I want to see the people on the now-distant Retroid stop fence-sitting, that's very scummy.
 
K

Kawl_USC

Member
Crab said:
Votes tied means nobody is lynched, it has to be avoided. I don't want to see anyone switch votes to tie break because they can backwards justify themselves later. I want to see the people on the now-distant Retroid stop fence-sitting, that's very scummy.
Click to expand...

Ah I see. Well then.

I would still like Retroid to be discussed further tomorrow but at the moment it looks like it is becoming a two dog race.

I've discussed in detail why I feel lunching someone we find suspicious is a better move than lynching TWE. I'm less sold on LoC's scummy ness but I think he has enough little strange actions to add up to enough.

UNVOTE
VOTE: Lord of Castamere
 
M

Miracle

Member
Kalor said:
Something about this reads as off to me, trying to push the vote onto the neutral as something bad could happen. Despite the fact that he is more than likely a thief as why would he make a fake claim today if he was mafia? The poisoner is more than likely Death Eater aligned so why would he claim poisoned? I'm going to trust TWE to do the right thing tonight.

Vote: Lord of Castamere
Click to expand...

Good.

I swear if someone votes on TWE right now...

giphy.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

A Helldivers x Killzone update: Seasons Greetings (2nd Wave Killzone Pack FREE)
37
2K
DeepEnigma replied
Games Done Quick, isn't accepting speedruns of ANY Harry Potter game currently without explanation.
2 3
135
20K
Goalus replied
Harry Potter: Quidditch Champions announced
News
40
4K
struggler_guts replied
Hogwarts Legacy is the biggest Harry Potter game launch of all time | UK Boxed Charts
2 3 4 5
225
18K
cornonthecrobb replied
The 12 days of Gafmas |OT| The year in thread popularity!
28
949
jm89 replied
Top Bottom