• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

How is The Wire?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Odoul

Member
HBO's scheduling is so off and I'm so busy I never really got to see alot of it.

Bits and pieces look interesting though. What show is it similar to? The Shield is one of the few shows I'll make it a point to watch though?

Also was The Corner any good? I might have just picked one of them up, but HBO DVD's are ridiculously pricey.
 

KingGondo

Banned
Since you have no replies up to this point, I'll chip in. I haven't seen the show myself, but I've heard from several people that it's excellent. Check out Metacritic, see if there are any reviews. Plus, it's HBO, which hasn't had a bad show in years.
 

Dan

No longer boycotting the Wolfenstein franchise
I've only seen the third season, but it was absolutely stellar. I can't say I know of anything very similar, but I haven't seen The Shield or anything. The show follows the story from the perspectives of the police, politicians and the streets, so it covers all angles. Not really sure what to say. It tracks a lot of characters, and each season seems to follow one main investigation, although elements of them branch into the later ones.

I'd definitely recommend checking it out.
 

Mama Smurf

My penis is still intact.
I downloaded the first episode of The Wire a while back to see if I should pick up the DVDs, having heard it's great. Perhaps it is, but the first episode didn't show it to me.

I do intend to give it another chance sometime though. For a start I found it really confusing. Now I'm normally really good at picking things up, others who get confused at shows and films are always asking me what's going on (pissing me off in the process) and I can always answer. I just couldn't follow The Wire though. Too many names being thrown around too fast before I established who the hell everyone was.

It's also...this is going to sound racist, please don't take it that way...well, it has a lot of black people in it. More so than most other shows. Which is fine, great. Only...I had trouble telling them apart. Please don't come down hard on me, I don't know if it's because, while I grew up with lots of asian and oriental friends, hardly any black people live in this area, or if I'm just useless, but whatever it was, I really struggled. And it just gave me a headache, combined with not following who was who anyway I didn't know what the fuck was going on.

I am determined to give it more of a chance though, everyone who watches it seems to love it. Maybe I should watch the first episode a few times until I get my head round it.
 
I love cop shows, and I thought The Wire was meh. You should definitely watch it though.

It's probably closest to Homicide (and not because it's in Baltimore) despite it's being multiperspective. It's very character-driven and its both sympathetic and honest about both sides.
 
The Wire is a really tough, but ultimately rewarding show. More than any other show, the writing style is like a book, where it's chapters and stuff that flow into each other. So, just the first episode alone isn't a good way to gauge it. In fact, I'm pretty sure the main case isn't even started until episode 5 of a 13-episode season, but 1-4 build a complete picture of the various characters and politics involved. I think if you watch 1-4 (yea, big time commitment, I know), then you'll get the hang of it and get into it. But man, once you see the big picture, and the criticisms and laments that David Simon has about what's going on in Baltimore, and get into the characters and their situations, it's pretty awesome. Yea, I realize it sounds kind of like "you have to slog through four hours of shit just to get to the good stuff," but I don't see it as that, I see it more as "it feels tough at first, but once you get the hang of it, you'll realize how awesome it is."

Basically, the seasons can be summarized like this: Season 1 is the losing war on drugs, season 2 is the gradual disappearance of blue collar workers and how that ties to crime, and season 3 is about city politics, while season 4 will be about the failure of the public school system, at least in Baltimore.

Also, on the black people thing, just try watching more. It didn't mess me up, but my fiancee and my friends had a hard time getting used to the scenes with the projects. But that's just the way Baltimore is, and once you get some more dialogue and character interaction under your belt, it shouldn't be too bad. Also, HBO has a website, and since the show is still filming, I guess they have archives for seasons one through three.
 

Burger

Member
Seen all 3 seasons. And...

Best drama on TV.

It is confusing at the start, mainly because the writers don't really pander to the audience, you kinda just get thrown into the mix.

I thought Season 2 was the strongest, once you know all the characters from season 1 you will just be loving it. I thought the whole dock workers angle was genius, with the greeks & the russians. I thought the last 2 episodes of Season 2 were the best of the show. If you have never seen it, and watch the first episode of season 2 you will just give up, it's hard to pick up from there.

Give the show some time, watch 3 or 4 eps of season 1 and you'll be hooked. Most of the details/investigations don't really kick in till half way through each season, and shit ramps up from there.

I'm glad my flatmate introduced me to it, one of the best shows I've ever seen.
 

Brian Fellows

Pete Carroll Owns Me
I just finished watching season 1 with my dad last night. We are gonna start season 2 next weekend.

The Wire is IMO the best show on television. So many great characters and the story is pieced together so well. It does start off kinda slow but its not a show about instant payoffs and solutions. Each episode builds off the ones before and you have to stick with it to get the payoff.


Mama Smurf said:
It's also...this is going to sound racist, please don't take it that way...well, it has a lot of black people in it. More so than most other shows. Which is fine, great. Only...I had trouble telling them apart.

My mother had the same exact problem. I had to help her out from time to time but the more she watched the easier for her it got.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom