BIG thanks to those of you who helped me out last night with my decision.
I ended up realizing a few things. 1) The deal on the 570 was just too good to pass up, 2) That SLI is currently out of the question with my current mobo 3) I'll likely do a completely new build in about a year or so.
So, I decided on keeping it as cheap as possible since I'll likely be changing things on a much larger scale in 12 months. I went with the Zotac "AMP!" factory OC'd 570 to replace my AMD 5870.
[IMG]
Heck of a deal: $379 MSRP; on sale for $309. 20% off coupon = $269 AFTER tax. Plus a $30 rebate PLUS Batman Arkham City + Assassin's Creed Brotherhood. I plan to sell the Batman AC key for $35 (which, if you want that, shoot me a PM), which means at the end of the day I got this card for about $205 and got a free copy of Ass.Creed.Bro. I should be able to sell my 5870 for that.
Anyway, finally got rid of the AMD stuff, got it installed, updated, and played. I loaded up BFBC2 for a while. Like I said, on my old card, I'd hover in the 50s, with a few dips to the 40s, and a rare dip to the high 30s. With the 570, I doubled the AA (16 -> 32), and hovered in the 70s, with the rare dip to the 50s! Incredible. Awesome, awesome performance at 1080p.
[I]HOWEVER:[/I]
I was playing some BFBC2 when my game started stuttering all over the place. Was un playable almost. I checked temps, and they were at 100D Celsius :doh: ! I immediately shut down my computer and inspect if there is a problem in my case. I quickly come to realize I'm an idiot; the cooler fan is in a completely different location that on my 5870, and so it was smashed up against my sound card. :doh: :doh: So, for the time being, I've just removed my sound card, and went back to playing. No more stuttering! Yay!!
That said, my card still seems to idle at like 50-53c, and when gaming, it hits nearly 100% load constantly as I never use V-sync, and temps get into the high 90s. :shock: Now, I'm not saying my cooling in my case is great by any means, but I know my 5870 stayed much lower than that. So, should I assume this might be a tad deffective? Card seems to run fine, and the fan cranks up to full load (85) when I'm playing... but that just seems ridiculously high even for a "factory OC'd" (lulz) card. Should I drive the 1h30m to switch it out with another? I'm leaning toward yes.[/QUOTE]
Maximum Operating Temperature is 97C, so you're instinct is probably right [url]http://www.microcenter.com/single_product_results.phtml?product_id=0371742[/url]
I swear I'm not just saying that to increase my chance of you traveling back / getting me a card... hahah