Lone_Prodigy
Member
Time wasn't on anyone's radar so I can see why he was killed.
AB is a surprise though.
AB is a surprise though.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
InFAMOUS [Mafia] [OT] No Good Karma...
- Thread starter melonrabbit
- Start date
Let me sleep on it, baby baby let me sleep on it, I'll give you an answer in the morning
I've had some Internet issues over the last couple of days so that's why I barely posted during the day. I should be more active from this point on.
When I was catching up Dusk, AB and Flame were the three people that stuck out but now two of them are dead so I'd have to look at those interactions again.
Time and AB are weird choices. I wouldnt go after the other lynch candidate when town could always just go for them later. Maybe they wanted to incriminate CCS since they were frequently brought up with AB and Dusk. I think the mafia would go for Time and the other kill was from a neutral.
When I was catching up Dusk, AB and Flame were the three people that stuck out but now two of them are dead so I'd have to look at those interactions again.
Time and AB are weird choices. I wouldnt go after the other lynch candidate when town could always just go for them later. Maybe they wanted to incriminate CCS since they were frequently brought up with AB and Dusk. I think the mafia would go for Time and the other kill was from a neutral.
You got an entire day phase to plead your case.
Or to have your scum buds craft it for you.
Well it's my bedtime now, which gives them a good eight hours to work on it
Okay, I wasn't expecting to have two kills tonight when the vigilante was lynched yesterday. I concur with cabot that AB wasn't likely to be a scum kill. If we still had a vigilante, I would have guessed it was a vig kill against someone they thought was scum.
Two possibilities stand out:
1) A serial killer targeted AB because they thought he would be overlooked by protective roles, not realizing that AB was the doctor.
2) Someone, somehow, figured out that AB was a PR and eliminated him for that reason.
Two possibilities stand out:
1) A serial killer targeted AB because they thought he would be overlooked by protective roles, not realizing that AB was the doctor.
2) Someone, somehow, figured out that AB was a PR and eliminated him for that reason.
WaffleTaco
Wants to outlaw technological innovation.
This changes everything. We now have some solid evidence to go on. Time to look back on every conversation these individuals had.
Disagree. I think batsnacks is not a target of the mafia, at least not anytime close to now. Remember, batsnacks' role is known, there's no benefit for scum to take out what is effectively a vanilla town. Sure it narrows down the suspect pool, but they (or these third and fourth and fifth parties) can take them out later.
Also, the killing of AB seems like your typical vig/whatever shooting the second place bandwagon on day 1. We just got unlucky with the role.
He's on my radar because he kind of led the shenanigans at the end of day one. He and SkyOdin seem most responsible for getting us to nearly tie the vote in my view.
Looking back it looks like cabot was opposed to his fluff speculation, and they got into a bit of a snit.
He said "batkawl," referring to batsnacks and Kawl collectively. snacks is a known non-PR, but Kawl is a confirmed town who may have a power, and thus seems like a pretty ideal target for scum.
Yep. Which is why I only really talked about batsnacks. Agree about Kawl.
I would suggest if it was a town / town-aligned person, they should only come forward if they have more utility of some type. Coming forward and then saying they have nothing left to do just narrows the pool of power roles for scum to attack.
I have no fucking idea what the game comp is looking like at this point. Two kills when the vigi is dead, them kills landing where they did and then the possession. Makes me kinda wanna to believe that the possession is just a Fruit Vendor -like troll or something but ehh. Two neutrals (arsonist and 2nd kill), the 2nd kill from scum or something completely different...
not enough information
not enough information
I feel like Cab is scummy. My vote near the start of D1 was a joke, but more and more I feel like he's actually a good lynch target.
If you mean the final 10th post then sure, otherwise LP was actually being fairly open at day end with his thoughts.
Hmm.
Now knowing that it was town v town yesterday, it's a good idea to see who voted where. I'm curious about the votes outside the pair the most.
OA, Zipped, TheG, Zeusy, Blarg are the ones who voted outside of dusk/AB.
TheG wasn't here, Zipped disappeared after unvoting flame when he threatened to claim, Blarg ??????, Zeusy was trying to understand how the game works, OA scumread CCS.
I was annoyed how D1 went down at day end anyway, Dusk was fine as a target, AB never showed up and was still in contention. I was hoping he would turn up eventually and give us something to work with.
I was less sure of AB vs Dusk, but AB had gone awol for half the day and I really dislike lynching inactives who say nothing when pressure is on. I switched to Dusk partly because of this as well as my vote opening up a clear gap to solidify a lynch happening.
Ri, why is trying to tie the vote looking scummy to you?
I was less sure of AB vs Dusk, but AB had gone awol for half the day and I really dislike lynching inactives who say nothing when pressure is on. I switched to Dusk partly because of this as well as my vote opening up a clear gap to solidify a lynch happening.
Ri, why is trying to tie the vote looking scummy to you?
why wouldn't this make sense for a sk? could be a well intentioned SK who chose first kill to help out town, but in effect has helped out scum.
No reason for scum to chase them yet when they helped them.
what's a seer in this instance?
does anyone think this kill was a town aligned power ? considering we flipped dusk, a 1-shot vigi?
I say town motivated, but not town aligned.
Town Paranoid Gun Owner shoot bang bang poor AB who just wanted to play doctor
Neutral something with powers of murderererererrr + n, n = something.
Scum additional kill.
Neutral >= Town > Scum imo.
you mentioned Flame and CCS,
feelings on OA?
OA inhabits the "I dunno"-category with Bronx.
After consulting the superbreaddocument.txt, I'll add isaac and Zipped to the list of persons of suspicion. Well, not really add since they already were there, just that my focus on them dropped somewhat towards the end of d1. Re-reading things sometime today I guess.
Also worth examining who planted a vote on Dusk/AB and never changed.
This gives us isaac, voted and had this curious exchange:
He did very little since, something I brought up in post #729, to which he responds:
and was never seen again.
VOTE: isaacnukem
This gives us isaac, voted and had this curious exchange:
He did very little since, something I brought up in post #729, to which he responds:
and was never seen again.
VOTE: isaacnukem
Lover did you possess Kyan? You have to tell me if you did.
😑
I'm not expecting another (multi shot) vig, but don't come forward unless you think it's a good idea for some reason.
Nope.
Do you know who possessed you then?